Software
Houzz Logo Print
ali80ca_gw

Air Switches....are they interchangeable??

13 years ago

If I get an insinkerator garbage disposal, do I have to use an insinkerator brand air switch or are there other brands available that work with them? To me it appears that other brands should work, but I am not 100% sure. Some of the other brands appear more durable than the insinkerator air switches!! More expensive too...lol

Comments (14)

  • 13 years ago

    You can definitely use a Waste King Fiber Optic switch with your Insinkerator, because I do. My guess would be that they are all interchangeable.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks Ginny...it makes me wonder if the more expensive ones are remotely worth the extra cost. Do they last longer??

  • 13 years ago

    I don't know about longevity. The fiber optic is more expensive, but it also operates differently. Something about light - kaseki explained it in the thread I've attached. I got it because it has a closed gasket in the part on the counter that you push. Water can't go down it. That just seemed better to me. It also has a 20 sec automatic stop. (You can press again to restart if you want.) I don't know if regular air switches have that, and it's a nice feature. I really love mine. It's been operational for going on 2 years.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Air switch for Insinkerator

  • 13 years ago

    I have an ISE air switch. It was the cheapest I could find and what my electrician regularly uses anyway. There are more expensive ones out there, although I wonder about how much more expensive they look IRL. ISE can be used with my brand of GD as they are independent of the G?D. In fact, an air switch can be used to control lights instead of a regular light switch. Cool, eh?

  • 13 years ago

    they are interchangeable. I have a insinkerator disposal and have a rohl switch at one side and my old set was with a franke air switch. I personally prefer the regular airswitch instead of the fiber optic as 2 of the them have malfunctioned for me.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks guys! I have only ever seen the insinkerator ones irl. I was just curious why some of the others were more expensive...or are we just paying for the name? Breezy...what brand of gd do you have? and yes it is incredibly cool that they can control lights, I have never heard that before. I kinda figure if something happens with the air switch when they are inexpensive, I can afford to replace it. That would annoy me if I paid lots of money for it in the first place.
    GWlolo do you like your rohl one? They look pretty, is it irl?
    Ginny...Ive never even heard of a fiber optic one (we Canadians don't always get out much...especially when big stores are an hour away!)

  • 13 years ago

    My GDs are ISEs. One at each sink.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks everyone. ISE seems to be the place to start then and if for some reason they don't work out I can change them. I am looking forward to having a garbage disposal...lol Oh the small things that please us :)

  • 13 years ago

    I've had an airswitch for 11 years. Water compromising the integrity has never been a problem, although mine is mounted on the granite counter to the right of the sink. I don't recall the brand, but it was not specific to my garbage disposal. I don't know about fiberoptic switches, although I wouldn't like one to automatically cut off after 20 seconds.

  • 13 years ago

    I have an ISE air switch. It is my second one -- bought in a package of three and we decided to try painting one to blend into the granite. It worked -- for a while -- a year or so?. We then had the decision to order another one in a dark finish for about $100 or just go with the second choice -- brushed nickel. We've been using the ISE brushed nickel for whatever part of 6-1/2 years the painted one hasn't been there. They switches are fine. You only need to pay more if you want a specialty finish to match your other plumbing fixtures or to blend into your counter. Even then, you could probably do a better paint job on the white one than I did and have it longer.

  • 13 years ago

    lascatx, my biggest problem would be remembering where I had placed the spares! For the price, ISE seems a great place to start.

  • 13 years ago

    i used a different brand airswitch for my insinkerator. i think mine was mountain gourmet or something. a lot of sink companies make their own brands too. sometimes their finishes are better at matching their sinks.

  • 12 years ago

    The only difference that I could tell was that Rohl has a Limited Lifetime Warranty and Insinkerator has a one year warranty. I'm picking one out now.