Software
Houzz Logo Print
observer3

Sequence of zones problem

18 years ago

Hi --

I am planning to have all my kitchen work space on a single island but some way can't figure out what to put where, so please solve my problem. I am thinking that the flow of the work calls for the following zones on the island, in the following order:

plop zone and prep zone: The plop zone is for coming in the kitchen door and plopping down everything I have bought and putting it away in the (nearby) refrigerator and food closet. The prep zone is for setting out all the ingredients for a meal and then preparing them for cooking. Physically, the same space is for both plop and prep.

cooking zone: It's where the cooktop is. Oven and microwave are nearby.

staging zone and clean-up zone: The staging zone is for arranging the food in serving dishes, the food to stay there until it's time for it to be carried to the dining room. The clean-up zone is where the dirty dishes and pots go for clean-up. Sink and dishwasher are here. Physically, the same space is for staging and clean-up.

So hopefully this would be an efficient arrangement, except for one thing: Really, there should be a sink in the prep zone. The sink, in the clean-up zone, is too far from the prep zone for efficiency. But I am not willing to spend the money to have two sinks. Is there a solution to this problem?

Comments (18)

  • 18 years ago

    My number one reason for renovating the kitchen was to add a prep sink, for exactly the reason you describe and to make it work better for two people. If you have the space, I would put in the prep sink and try to cut your costs elsewhere. Consider saving money on a countertop or appliance that you can fairly easily change out later. I don't have another solution for you, sorry.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with astidh. I use my prep sink more than my main sink for food prep. It is 24" wide and across from the stove, fridge, freezer. Zones are great and often they require duplication for better efficiency.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not following you. Are you saying that your main sink, dw and range will all be on an island? Is there a reason you are not utilizing the perimeter space?

    Effective zoning has so many more considerations than those you've listed above, for example; Is glassware located convenient to the fridge; is the mw convenient to the freezer; where will the coffee pot be kept and is it near a faucet and convenient to mug storage; is the trash receptacle(s) near the sink and convenient to the prep space; the list could go on & on.

    Also, why do you feel the staging area needs to be located near or around the sink? Imo, the staging area should be a stretch of counter (or pennisula or island) near the DR or entertainment area.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Paulines that the question is framed a little simplistically, but it seems fairly straightforward to say that if both prep and cleanup require a sink, and if you've only got one sink, then the prep and cleanup zones must share the same general space.

  • 18 years ago

    Can you post a layout? It's difficult to give advice without seeing what your layout is...not just in the kitchen but in relation to the rest of the house.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks to all of you for the advice.

    Astrid, how big is your prep sink? Stiles, would a prep sink smaller than 24" have been adequate for you?

    Pauline, Yes, my sink, cooktop, and dw will all be on an island. The reason I will not be using perimeter space for any of these is that I am not going to have any perimeter cabinets or countertop: The entire working part of the kitchen will be a single longish run of cabinets, constituting an island, and, parallel to it, a wall, into which will be built in the refrigerator, an oven, a pantry closet, and a shelf or two for small appliances. We are building this room from scratch. My reasons for going about it in this peculiar way are 1) I want two of the walls to be unobstructed glass, for the light and the views, 2) my tastes for this room are strongly minimalist, 3) and, above all, I intend to save money by having as few cabinets as possible.

    Thanks for directing me to the many zoning considerations. It will be a puzzle to figure it all out. In general, I will be trying to locate items in the wall with the built-ins as close as possible to the related items on the island.

    It's not that I think the staging area needs to be located near or around the sink. Rather, as you suggest, the staging area will be the stretch of counter closest to the DR, and meanwhile the clean-up area will be the stretch of counter closest to the DR (where the dirty dishes coming out of the DR can be piled) and will have the sink and dw. So the staging area and the clean-up area will occupy the same stretch of counter, the former before the meal, the latter after.

    Jon, Yes, if there's only one sink, the prep and clean-up zones could occupy the same space. Or they could occupy separate spaces, e.g. the prep zone to the left of the sink and the clean-up zone to the right of the sink. But what is the most efficient sequence of the zones, in terms of minimizing steps and also minimizing cabinets and counter space, consistent with having fully adequate space to work in?

    Buehl, I can't post a layout as yet: I had thought to solve this problem before creating a layout, and besides, I don't know how to post a picture. I hope to do these things very soon. Meanwhile, perhaps you will picture a 20' X 20' room; top and left-side (on the page) walls of glass but with door to the drive-way in the left-side wall and door to the back forty in the top wall; bottom wall containg the built-ins and, at the right-hand end, the doorway to the rest of the house; island parallel to that last wall. Actually, the island will be L-shaped, the extended, shorter part running parallel to the left-side wall in the direction of the bottom wall. I realize a drawing would be much better than my description, and I will try to come up with one.

  • 18 years ago

    You've thought things through well, in terms of zones and zone sequencing. But if you strictly follow your own logic -- which works, by the way -- then you need a prep sink in your plop & prep zone. It is quite simply, a necessary part of this particular functional equation. And while I understand your desire to save money, consider how much money you'll save overall by this design.

  • 18 years ago

    I just have to say I LOVE "plop zone"! I think that's my biggest zone, LOL...maybe the whole kitchen is one...

  • 18 years ago

    It sounds like you will have a wonderful view!

    Something like this?

    Or, this:

    Assuming the family entrance is the driveway, the main traffic pattern will be straight through your work zones and on into the rest of the house. If that's the case, then be sure to have plenty of aisle space b/w the peninsula & built-ins. Additionally, a wide aisle gives you some protection from the traffic. Since your main zones (prep, cook, cleanup) will be on the island, the wider aisles shouldn't be too hard on you....just the distance b/s the refrigerator & ovens to the island.

    One thought, though...have you considered just one 24" - 36" span of countertop on the built-in wall for landing space for your refrigerator & oven(s)? Put it b/w them and it would serve both. Just a thought. If not, you may have to make the aisles narrower to give you a safe landing spot for both.

    No seating on the short "L"


    Something to fuel the discussion!

  • 18 years ago

    Holly, you have inspired me to think more about plopping with regard to the ideal sequence of zones, and I thank you. My inspiration is: Why is it that only the groceries should plop in the plop zone? Why shouldn't the bringer of the groceries also plop after all that hard work? So here it is: The plop zone counter should have a kneehole under it so that the bringer of the groceries can pull out a chair and plop. And this works out perfectly with the idea of combining the plop and prep zones: The person doing the prepping (now who could that be?) can then also be sitting down while doing all that prepping.

  • 18 years ago

    Buehl, what an enchanting creature you are. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

    To clarify: The short arm of the L should be positioned as in your second picture from the top. The wall at the bottom of that picture should be three squares shorter, terminating, at its right-hand side, three squares away from the wall at the right-hand side of the picture. The three squares vacated by shortening the bottom wall are for the doorway to the rest of the house. The line you have marked "DR/FR/etc." should actually be just a blank wall. (As to where the rest of the house is: If you extend to the right the line of the bottom wall in the picture, the rest of the house lies below that line.) The door to the back yard should be straight ahead from the doorway to the rest of the house. The island should be moved as far to the left as possible. The long arm of the island might be a foot or two longer than I need; that's something I am trying to figure out in asking my question about the sequence of zones. That said, obviously what you drew is very very close to what I have in mind; you did that just beautifully.

    Yes, it will be a lovely view in the direction of the back yard. I have been conflicted about the view out of the right-hand wall, though: there sit the cars and driveway in the middle of the pretty view. I have thought about moving the driveway, but couldn't come up with a plan that gave convenient access.

    Fortunately, the family entrance to the house is not by means of the door that will lead into the kitchen: Very near the door-to-be into the kitchen is the actual door into the main body of the house.

    Having a counter for landing space is a great idea; thank you. I think the arm of the island will serve as landing space for the refrigerator, but something very nearby is needed for the oven. I have not progressed very far in thinking about the layout of the wall for built-ins. I was thinking about a shelf, or two, or counter for our many small appliances, and perhaps that could be combined with the landing space for the oven. But I am thinking that this set-up will destroy the whole sleek minimal look of the kitchen.

    Re seating on the short arm of the L: I am thinking of having a kneehole that goes all the way through. That way, one person can plop, or two people can prep, or two people can eat. Re the eating space on the long arm of the island: I plan to have it there because I like the proportion, but I don't plan for people to actually eat there.

  • 18 years ago

    I haven't installed my prep sink yet, so I can't really tell you if the size is sufficient, but I could only fit in one that has 15" x 15" internal dimensions. One issue is whether or not you usually work alone in your kitchen. What would drive me nuts is when DH and I were in the kitchen together, both wanting to use the same patch of counter between the range and sink, one of us trying to prep/cook and the other trying to efficiently clean up along the way. If you are usually alone in the kitchen it won't matter so much.

  • 18 years ago

    Astrid, I have the same problem you had, husband cleaning up after me, using the sink just when I need it. You and Stiles and Sweeby hae convinced me that I do need a prep sink. So many thanks to all of you knowledgeable and very generous people who have helped me solve this problem.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, obsever1-you won't regret the decision for a prep sink. To answer your question about size, I suppose I could "live" with a smaller sink, but I knew I definitely needed something bigger than a round prep sink that looks nice but isn't very functional, imho. The 24" enables me to put a pot of boiling water from the stove to drain pasta, clean a cutting board if needed, or just wash hands.

    I like your minimalist approach and look forward to hearing about your progress.

    Melinda

  • 18 years ago

    FWIW...we have a 15-3/4" x 15-3/4" prep sink that's plenty big enough for pots of water, washing/prepping veggies, etc. It fits in either an 18" standard sink base or 36" corner sink base (ours is in a corner).

    Also, the smaller bowl of our main sink is 10-1/2" x 15-7/8" x 7" deep and an 8 qt stock pot easily fits in it.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you again, Melinda and Buehl. Buehl, your sinks are very handsome, so please tell me who makes them. (Your counter top is terrific too. Absolute black granite? I am thinking of Nordic Antiqued, but maybe stainless steel.) On the main sink, you're still glad you went with a double sink rather than one large one? Do large roast pans it into your main sink?

    Barbara

  • 18 years ago

    Our main sink is, of course, a Ticor (so many of us on the Forum have Ticor sinks!) My prep sink is Kohler...and it cost half again as much as the main sink!

    Main sink: Ticor S405D
    Prep Sink: Kohler Undertone® Five-Sided Undercounter Kitchen Sink

  • 18 years ago

    Buehl, thank you yet again. I have one more question: What sortware did you use making those layouts?

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH