Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjl443

Still trying to figure a layout

14 years ago

Hi there - I have been enjoying reading everyone's updates :)

We are still trying to figure a layout and keep going around, around in circles. We are leaning to keep our main (formal) dining room and use that as our primary eating area and expand into the kitchen eating space for more storage/workspace/etc.

I seem to remember seeing that folks on here did not like the big stainless all-refrigerator/all-freezer units, why is that? We were considering hte frigidaire/eletrolux or the whirlpool. We would like a lot of fresh food space in our kitchen.

I will post the layout and see what thoughts you all might have, thank you so much.

Roberta

Comments (37)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think some more information would be helpful.

    What are the measurements?
    What is the sill height of that window in the eating area and can you change it?

    Is the stairwell completely open on the kitchen side as indicated?

    Could you alter that truncated wall hanging out at the end of the family room? Would you be willing to relocate the opening to the family room?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is a quick comment that's not really what you asked: Is there any way to add windows to the dining, living, den and family rooms on the walls where there are none now? Having light enter a room from two sides is a huge improvement. IMO it's what makes SFH houses so much more attractive than houses with party walls. Rooms with light from only one side tend to be gloomy and dull to live in.

    I've got to run now, but it occurs to me that you could use up the present eat-in space and maybe add an island. You might find it convenient to have a couple of stools at the island for the occasional snack meal even though you use your DR for all other ones. (Just don't add so much kitchen seating that it winds up being easier to eat there instead of the DR.)

    My standard advice when beginning kitchen planning is to consider the pathway of the food as it travels in your kitchen from storage> prep (with water, perhaps from a separate prep sink)> to cooking > to plating and serving. Ideally you should also think about where the groceries come in and have the storage place convenient for that. Since you plan to eat in your DR, the finished food should wind up near that doorway. You can have your clean-up area (main sink, DW and nearby dish storage) in a distinct zone, as long as (ideally) the dishes windup in a convenient place for when they are needed for plating. Try to make sure your DW, doesn't wind up in the middle of the main prep/cooking action pathway. You don't have to have the sink under a window (but many people like this) and it's best if you have the range on an exterior wall for easy direct venting. I also advise that any separate ovens be fairly close to the cooktop (if used) so that when you are making something that requires action both on burners and ovens that you're not traipsing from one to another with a hot pot in your paw. In working on the functional food pathway try to eliminate times where you need to back track. This example is bad: freezer with frozens peas placed where you have to walk past the stove to get the water at a tap and then back to the stove. A better progression would be freezer (with counter nearby to momentarily put the peas)> water source> pot storage> trash (for bag)> stove. See what I mean?

    The very first thing to do is to make measured drawing of your space on graph paper. That will give you the fastest set of possible dimensions to play around with. Then put some thought into the food pathways and only then think about decorative features and ammenities you'd like. If you start by focusing on decoration before you've got a good functional layout then you'll have more angst making the necessary trade-offs.

    I'll check back later to see your dimensions and see how you're coming.

    HTH,

    L.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi, RJL. Agree more information will help you get answers directed toward fulfilling your wishes.

    In the meantime, just musing, I like your intent to use your dining room. If that were my floor plan, though, I think I'd like the dining room taken out of its corner and placed attractively straight ahead as you enter the front door, efficiently between the family room and the kitchen, which would now be developed in that wonderful left corner space, wall moved/opened up as desired. The kitchen would likely have a doorway directly into the front room, (or possibly one placed by it in the dining room), so that front room use would be enhanced by a new, closer relationship to the kitchen.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi - sorry to post the double pictures, but I realized I had a more accurate image with more details I should post. Is there a way to delete the first one?

    The kitchen eating area window is fairly low so would need to be moved up to accommodate cabinets under which I think would be ideal. There is a small window over the sink also that it looks like I missed!

    We could add a window on the exterior wall in the dining room. We have actually considered adding french or sliding doors there to the outside since next to us is an empty/unbuildable 3/4 acre lot that looks like a big field/meadow so no neighbors on that side for a couple acres.

    But would that help our kitchen unless we moved the entire kitchen into that dining room space. We thought about opening up that range wall to the dining room with just a vent hood over as an option, maybe with cabinets on the backside and a raised breakfast bar area countertop?

    I have had 3 KDs come out and 2 suggested making the dining room area and current kitchen into huge kitchen. The third suggested leaving the dining room intact but putting an 8 foot window wall on the back so completely moving the windows and would need an architect/engineer/a lot more $. Hoping to keep under 40-50k with all.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    >>Try to make sure your DW, doesn't wind up in the middle of the main prep/cooking action pathway.

    This is out biggest problem right now - the dishwasher interfering with sink/stove access. That and the narrow doorway to the dining room.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would make your kitchen an L-the short side is the current range wall-the long side is the back sink wall-extend the cabinetry right under that window since you want to raise it anyway. In the central floor space of the kitchen you can get a butcher block cart or the like. Then your dinette table is turned the other way and moved down to straddle the zones between kitchen and family room. Much more enjoyable day to day usage. I'd leave dining room as is,probably. You already have this large open space-maximize it- I don't think any more "opening up" has to occur. You might actually fit more than a cart in the center of kitchen,if you wish.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Roberta- I seem to remember that you have kids, is that right? You'll probably want to see the dining table from the kitchen, so I think opening up the wall between (at least somewhat) would be a very good idea.

    However, that might work better if you swapped the range and sink. Then, you would have a nice view out the new french doors or slider, to the meadow, but not have it blocked by your range hood! :)

    The range/cooktop could go between windows on the back wall, with an oven or double ovens on the end. The stainless steel fridge/freezer combo would look great by the pantry and you'd still have room for a little snack counter with the microwave.

    The island would be a great place for a prep sink and it would give you a lot of prep space for cooking and baking. What do you think? {{gwi:1915864}}From Cottage house plans

    And here's a few photos of cooktop/range between windows. {{gwi:1443515}}From Farmhouse plans
    {{gwi:1646414}}From Kitchen plans
    {{gwi:1646416}}From Kitchen plans

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    lavender_lass - this is a great idea!! I have tried a bazillion ideas on the ikea cabinet layout site, vizio and others. I am going to draw this up and see how it works. I am thinking I need to allow super-wide clearance/no island in front of those fridge units?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It shows you have 13'9" (according to the dining room layout) so you'd have plenty of space for the fridge/freezer AND the island. The stools might make things a little tight, but you'll know more when you draw it all out.

    Since you have stools at the counter, in the dining room...stools at the island could be optional. If you went without them (or maybe just one on the end for prep area) you could use the island as prep, for the fridge/freezer space as well :)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The deal with the stainless versions of all ref and all frzr is that the doors can't be changed. So, altho you might want both doors to open the same way, you can't do it.

    They have one big door so the clearance is kinda big. Closed the unit is about 26" deep. Open they use a whopping 57". So, it would not get along well with stools.

    The other things about those are that together, they form this giant side by side with no landing space within reach. Most people want to put stuff down behind, on the island. That's not going to work in your kitchen because of the stools - so I'd be afraid that as glorious as it is contemplating all that room, I'd be stuck taking items out one at a time and walking to/fro the far side of the island.

    I'd rather do a 36" combo unit and then add ref drawers on the other side of the island and an elcheapo big freezer in the garage.

    So doing the math, your kitchen is 13.5 feet. Minus two sides of 26" for cabinets and counter tops on the outer walls and a pair of 42" aisles leaves enough room for an island with a 26" wide countertop on it.

    A ref like the electrolux needs 57" of clearance so it sticks out 31" into the aisle leaving 11" for your body standing in front of the door. And that's without stools because even if its 13'9", another 3" ain't bringing those stools, another 24" gets you stools.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm confused - is the kitchen 14'7/16" (like the watermark) or 13'9" (like the dining room?)

    Either way, you don't have room for both the island seating AND a bottom wall of full-depth cabinets/appliances.

    I would try lavender_lass' layout, but change cooktop to range, put a 36" fridge in ovens' spot with MW nearby somehwere + maybe additional cold storage elsewhere as mentioned, and put a second oven undercounter in the island if you really need two.

    Here is your math at 13'9" (165")
    165" total
    -25.5" top wall (24" cabinets + 1.5" counter overhang)
    -48" aisle
    -40.5" island (24" cabinets + 1.5" top counter overhang + 15" seating overhang)
    -48" aisle (and this is really a bare minimum for an aisle behind seating - it should really be more)
    = 3" left.

    With that 3" left you can do a very shallow pantry that is recessed into in the stud space of the wall (which is about 4" deep) for a total of 7" deep - see cindyandmocha's kitchen to see how much something like that holds. If you actually have 14'7/16" inches, you have 10&7/16" left and you can probably just go with that without having to get into the stud space.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cindyandmocha's finished kitchen w/ recessed shallow pantry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi -

    We need big aisles, my DH and I are not small people and he has HUGE wide shoulders. He is a space hog and we are always fighting to get to the sink space. I love the idea of shallow pantry wall with island and back wall. The center aisle is a thru-way to our dining room also.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    rjl
    I hadn't noticed your post before and had fun reading and playing with the layout.
    First some comments:
    1. I would not want to move to another home with the visual space you have around your home. That is hard to come by. And if you have children, there is much more explorable space than most subdivisions allow. But I would want more light/windows.
    2. I would want to keep the formal dining room. It is nice with company to go into a separate room. But I would definitely put in french doors (my pref) or sliders if they fit your style better.
    3. I have a very large (6'5'') male friend. I know he would be uncomfortable in my 3' aisles. But if your DH can be comfortable in 4' aisles, I would really want an island in your kitchen. I think the major work areas are staggered here so two people are unlikely to be working back to back.
    4. Personally, I would want to keep the wall between DR and Kitchen. Removing it makes the DR feel like a breakfast room.
    5. I would want to keep the small BR table although it is basically in the FR. It can double as a game table, homework table. . .
    6. I would rather have storage on the bottom wall than seating at the island.

    Here is my first, off the top of the head idea:

    1. Widened the door into the DR
    2. Widened the window over the present sink
    3. Shortened the other window and put the sink under it. Moving the sink isn't necessary, but it gives much more and better room around the cooking area at the stove.
    4. DW can go on either side of the cleanup sink. I put it to the right because that kept it from interfering with the prep sink. I would put drawers in the island and store dishes opposite the cleanup sink. Glasses would go in the wall cab between the two windows.
    5. You really need more storage for kitchen ''stuff.'' I widened the pantry into the DR. That makes a great storage area.
    6. You will love a prep sink. In this location, it is convenient to fridge, range, and prep counterspace. Put a pull out trash cab next to it.

    Problems I see with this:
    1. I don't at all like the traffic pattern when you come in through the garage with your arms full of groceries. If this were mine, I would sure have (as I do, for the same reason) a collapsible wheeled grocery cart. Store it in the garage, and you can bring in in one or two trips what would take six.
    2. I don't know what the exterior of your home looks like and what the change in windows would do to it.
    3. I wanted to bring the exterior wall cabs at the top further toward the sliding door, but I also wanted to keep the BR table separate at least a little bit from the main FR area. This needs playing with.
    4. Not many wall cabs. But maybe the big pantry and island are enough storage.

    FINAL BIG SUGGESTION: If you would like an island, you need to do a mockup. Don't try to evaluate from graphs. Use newspapers to block out an island in your kitchen. Then use chairs to give it mass. Have your DH walk around it.

    Thanks for letting me play house with your plans. And obviously, from your postings, you are enjoying playing with all options. That makes remodeling fun.
    Sandra

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just looked at my graph again and I have two suggestions about the pantry:

    Use just two doors. Sliders if swinging doors would interfere too much, but swinging doors would open the whole thing.

    And, if you can, why not recess the back of the pantry. You don't really need an extra 3'' or so of depth here, but. . . .
    Sandra

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Boy, that kitchen's getting pretty big, RJL. I don't think you're doing much better here--so far--than you were with your kitchen designers and their "huge" profit-generating designs. You know, unless you decide to can a couple rows of collards while you bake pies and stuff a turkey for Thanksgiving dinner you'll never use all that counter space at once. Good thing given its new, starring role as the defining view in your house.

    How about taking a new, clear-eyed look at this and how to use this remodel to make all spaces on this floor even more wonderful?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    An fyi, I do love the shallow pantry still. I wanted to note that both my husband and I are "extra-large" people. After two years, we haven't had any issues with there not being enough aisle space. I even asked him about it after reading this, and there is simply plenty of room for us both to work in there. I also wouldn't give up that counter space on the island for anything, we use every inch of it all the time.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi -

    I just saw some feedback on these ideas that I missed! I met with a GC last week and he strongly suggested that we not knock down the entire wall between the dining room/kitchen, as our house is pretty traditional/colonial and the labor costs to make it a knee wall/half wall and keep the existing dining room would be a lot less and still accomplish a lot of the open feel.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi -

    I am reading comments and trying another idea again, with island. I added the actual measurements on that back wall with windows/walls on the outside of the wall.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi, RJL. Regarding the dining room, I really like the way you're bringing in light from on the left wall. Developing that corner of the house to be bright and inviting should pay off big time.

    With a lot of chairs needing to push out, though, I likely wouldn't do a wide slider for access to the garden but instead a single French door in a position where people could walk right to it through the room without having to turn and pass behind chairs to get out. Next to the door behind the chairs could be either one or two more French doors that mostly stay closed.

    The kitchen area? If it were mine and I were leaving the kitchen in the middle, I would not expand past the left wall of the staircase. That leaves plenty of space for a good kitchen, and I'd draw a firm line and keep it within it.

    I'd then frame a handsome doorway in the hall leading from the entry to the kitchen, maybe on a line with the back of the closet. This would narrow the view through a bit to try to frame an attractive and usually tidy view through (if possible with stove and sink to the left of the view), and also create a tad more privacy. It would also define the powder room as out of the entry hall.

    (In fact, I like that so much, I'd probably do the same at the back end of the hall, two framed doorways to create an enfillade--an architectural device to create interest by lining up doorways to channel a view through 3 or more spaces. This would also make the rear rooms seem farther away from the front door and also define the powder room as not in the kitchen/family area, either. A way of adding the kind of architectural detail this sort of home might have had in the past for not much money.)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think you have plenty of room for at least a 3' deep island...but if you're concerned about space, just keep the stools past the fridge area. The back of the stools could be opposite the big window (seen as you enter the foyer) and maybe one on the side, with the back to the family room. Two or three stools should fit no problem.

    The prep sink should face the range (IMHO) and also be easily accessible from the fridge. The microwave could be undercounter at the window, the island, or on a shelf, in the pantry area.

    Something like this? {{gwi:1915868}}From Cottage house plans

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How deep is the kitchen? From window wall to fridge wall?
    Sandra

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi - Here are a couple ponderings of mine:

    1. We want to have 2 dishwashers - is it better to have them both in the same place on opposite sides of a sink. Or is it better to have 2 cleanup zones each with their own sink?

    2. I have been flip-flopping between having the range overlook the dining room (where it is now but the wall would come down to half wall) or on the back wall between the single and double windows. Is is worth giving up those wall cabinets in order to get it on the back wall versus having the chimney stove hood in between kitchen/dining room. The GC i met with suggested leaving the crown moulding in the DR as it is and not full integrating into the kitchen, both for cost reasons and for having a formal dining room kept intact. I can see that the view from the dining room with the crown and over-doorway height wall might look sorta off with a hood coming down from the kitchen. I.E. unless we are totally taking down that wall/header/crown/door height drywall and the hood would look ackward from the DR? It really is a lovely DR I just want to see it more than twice a year.

    3. I have tried for a long time to be a clean-as-I-go cook and the transformation just hasn't happened. I am a very spontaneous cook, I am messy and the mess is LARGE. When I cook it's usually a lot of things at one time for multiples meals for the 3 of us, or for a gathering of friends for birthday party/Thanksgiving for 10-12. Everything is served family style (for a holiday) or buffet style (birthday party). No gathering at my house goes without a BIG MESSY kitchen meal.

    But I like my kitchen to be clean too, so I need ease of cleanup.

    Thank you!

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The depth of the kitchen is 13.6 foot. We bought an as-in cabinet from IKEA in a color we might like (I don't think I like it but I figure we can use the cabinet in our garage also). I put it right in the spot where it would be depth-wise for an island (which blocks our current U-space but it gives us an idea).

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Maybe with a counter-height bar instead so that I get that extra wide-prep space. Maybe not with stools but more of a serving area to pass things to the DR for a meal. If we are going to keep that drywall/crown/header up there I want to frame out the opening so that it looks intentional and have full wall on both sides so that it looks somewhat balanced?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here is an updated plan. Here is my dilemna - I really like the look of a sink centered under those 2 windows. However is that creating too long of a kitchen run from the other areas/fridge. I would try to make it shorter if it wasn't for those windows. I have a great window contractor who can move them up for me and make them match the other small window height wise. I would replace all 3 to match and have no grids as this is the view to our backyard.

    I would try to put a dishwasher in the island but I fear that there will be too many doors opening (oven)/range oven opposite each other or staggered which seems like a maze to walk through.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi again - just for some background - here is the style of the outside of our house. I am including a couple before/during/after photos:

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gotta love the toilet in the front yard!!!! The kitchen was at least usable for the last 4 years, the bathrooms not so much we had to redo them before we could even move in.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have some ideas for this, but first--what is the Xed out block to the right of the entrance to the dining area?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That is a dishwasher. I wasn't sure about having it on the end would that make is tougher to put dishes away?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Rjl- I like your latest plan! I don't know that you need the prep sink on the island, but I do like the one overlooking the dining room, since it's close to the fridge and handy for drinks/parties.

    The dishwasher by the prep sink looks good, but I would flip the dishwasher by the main sink, to the other side. This way your main sink would also be the easiest sink to use by the range/cooktop.

    The island would be fun to do in another countertop surface. Maybe a wood top with marble end? That would be great for your baking area (oven under small window) and you could even lower that end of the island, if you like. Maybe bookcases/display on the opposite side, where there are no stools? Great place for cookbooks :)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I was wondering if a 3rd sink made sense or just to leave the island without. I can see wanting it for prep, but I can see without. I really see us using that short L-side towards the dining room as prep- take stuff from fridge, clean, cut shop, cook on stove... I see us using the island top for setting groceries down to put away and such and to sit at the end for breakfast.