Software
Houzz Logo Print
maydl

Trying to compare two range hood light bulbs ...

18 years ago

My Zephyr range hood came with two 40-watt incandescent spot bulbs that provide woefully insufficient light. Can anyone tell me if two 35-watt medium base halogen flood bulbs of the same size will give significantly brighter light?

The output of the 40-watt bulbs was rated at 280 lumens, the halogens at 1250 candlepower. Online research says it is very difficult to compare these units of measurement in a meaningful way. That's why I'm asking for your knowledge born of experience about which light source will be brighter.

Thanks so much! I will cross-post to the Lighting Forum.

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    ...it is very difficult to compare these units of measurement in a meaningful way...

    It's essentially impossible to compare those two units in a meaningful way. If you were talking about the water coming out of a hose, it would be like trying to compare gallons to PSI. There's no direct relationship between the amount of light generated by a bulb (lumens) and the intensity of that light (candlepower) coming off of the same bulb in a particular direction. You could have a light source that produces very few lumens but concentrates them into a high-candlepower beam (like a cheap laser pointer) or a source that provides very little candlepower but a staggering number of lumens (like the moon).

    When you say the hood came with "spot" bulbs, can you be more specific about the type of bulb? Do they even have medium bases on them (a "medium base" is the common screw-in base seen on everyday 'light-bulb' shaped light bulbs.)?

  • 18 years ago

    I tried the spot light bulbs in my range hood first and did not like them because it did just that, gave me a spot of light on the cooktop which gave me insufficant lighting. So I switched to the flood lights and it worked great for me as it gave me more light and more coverage on the cooktop.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks so much, jon, for responding.

    The hood came with two very small 40-watt medium base bulbs, like tiny old-style track light reflector bulbs, about 2" long and 1-3/4" wide. Identical bulbs by Philips are marked "40-watt spot"; the Philips web site gave the 280 lumens information.

    The SATCO light bulb catalog offers a 35-watt medium base short MR16 halogen bulb designated as a 36-degree flood with 1250 candlepower.

    So you see, the information I have comes from disparate sources, and I still have no concept about what the relative brightness of the two bulbs might be. The Zephyr installation instructions limit the wattage of each bulb to 40 watts.

    I can plunk down the $20 to buy two bulbs and test them, but I was hoping to find someone who'd know the answer to my question before possibly wasting the money.

  • 18 years ago

    Okay, it sounds like you've got a 40R14, i.e. 40 watts, reflector shape, fourteen eighths of an inch across -- something like this. It's no wonder that those things suck.

    Yes, a halogen bulb should be significantly better. However, the bulbs you're looking at may not be the right halogen bulbs. If they actually put out 1250 candlepower then they're concentrating all of their light in a very tight beam that will make a couple of very bright spots on your rangetop instead of illuminating the whole thing. In other words, you're looking at spotlights. What you should be looking at are FLOOD lights, which look the same but have the filament positioned differently so that the light spreads out at a wider angle.

  • 18 years ago

    My Zephyr came with two 35 watt halogen bulbs. I think they are MR 16. I find the light to be plenty bright enough, and it does light up the entire 30" stove top. I have a low setting also so I can tone down the light if it's too bright. 35 watts is the max wattage allowed on mine (Hurricane) but I can't imagine needing more then that.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, again, to Jon, and to iwantakitchen and susanilz5. You've made me feel more confident in ordering the 35-watt medium-base short halogen FLOOD bulbs.

    Jon, one more question: The SATCO bulbs did say that they were floods with a 36-degree beam spread. Is that not enough, or should I be looking for a bulb called a WIDE FLOOD? I'm wondering if a medium-base wide-flood halogen bulb exists in the tiny, stubby size needed for my range hood.

  • 18 years ago

    36 degree floods should be fine.

  • 18 years ago

    Jon, thank you!