Software
Houzz Logo Print
znarf719

Garbage disposals

14 years ago

I must have needed coffee...my first question wasn't what I really wanted to know...but THANK YOU for all the responses.

The real question...I now have a continuous feed garbage disposal. For my new kitchen, a batch feed has been recommended (safer).

Thoughts? And thank you!

Comments (8)

  • 14 years ago

    Nope, not particularly safer. I thought that, too, and I was absolutely going to get a batch feed. I hated that switch under the sink - my hands were always wet when I needed to open the door and flip it. But I read on the Appliances Forum that you'd pretty much have to try to get your hand hurt in a garbage disposal. There aren't even very sharp things at the bottom. Don't worry about it. Get continuous feed with either an air switch or a fiber optic switch. Based on what I read, that was the safest option. (I'm not a fan of the wall switches that look like light switches, though.) I chose fiber optic because it has a sealed gasket and water can't get down it. I love it.

  • 14 years ago

    I switched to a batch feed with this remodel and will never have anything else. It's great.

  • 14 years ago

    I switched to a batch feed with this remodel and will never have anything else. It's great.

  • 14 years ago

    Ginny20 - I re-read your post and now I think I get what you were saying. I think you were saying that you once had a continuous feed disposal with a switch that was under the sink so you had to open the cabinet to operate it? And now you have a continuous feed disposal that uses a fiber optic switch? That makes sense. I thought you were saying you had a batch feed disposal that had a switch under the sink. Sorry for the mixup.

  • 14 years ago

    ak - No, it's not you, I wasn't clear. You did correctly decode my message, however. Let's see if I can be clearer. I'm on my fifth disposal at this house. Before the previous continuous feed with the awful undersink switch, I had Insinkerator batch feed disposals for years, and they were OK. Sometimes I had to fiddle with it to get it to work, and you do have to stop and start if you have a lot. Because it doesn't have the flange, spoons and such will fall in a batch feed easier. With my new continuous feed, they are often stopped by the flange. Although, as you say, if something small goes down there, it is easier to see to get it out of a batch feed unit.

    I prefer my new continuous feed with the fiber optic switch. The small round switch on the counter is unobtrusive, and it would be very difficult to turn it on by accident. I even made sure that my dog couldn't step on it during a bath and turn it on. It takes a finger, a paw won't work. Small kids would need to get on a stool and reach to the back corner of the sink in order to turn it on. Not that that couldn't happen, but it wouldn't be just an accident, unlike with those switches that look like light switches. You and I agree that those are really a hazard with kids around. Or strangers - how many times have I accidentally turned on the disposal at someone else's house.

    And I didn't mean to suggest that continuous feed is safer than batch feed - batch feed is safer, since there is no physical way to engage it while your hand is down there. I just meant that if you want continuous feed for the convenience, the air/fiber switch is the safest kind of switch, just because it won't be mistaken for something else. And the old threads were pretty clear that it would be hard to hurt yourself even on a continuous feed unit.

    I can say for sure that you need at least 3/4 HP, and 1 HP is better. I had only 1/2 HP in the old continuous feed, and it was awful. It was an Insinkerator Badger. My new one is Insinkerator Evolution Pro Compact. Much better. I looked at Waste Kings, and they are good too. They have an anti-jamming design.

  • 14 years ago

    I grew up with Insinkerator batch feeders and that's what I've always had as an adult. They used to have a mechanical mechanism for turning on and now they have they magnetic, which I hate and despise for reasons I'd be happy to detail if anyone cares. I'm delighted to hear about the Waste King, because when we redo the kitchen, we definitely will not be getting an Insinkerator if they still have the magnetic mechanism. (I was as brand loyal as could be. Never even thought about looking at another company. Between the stupid magnet and their horrendous customer service when I needed the stopper replaced, they managed not only to lose me as a customer, but to get me here encouraging people to look to a different brand. Excellent work!)

  • 14 years ago

    Ditto for the magnetic stopper on the Insinkerator batch feed. The magnets come out sometimes and bits of brillo pads get attached to them. Just a PITA. In addition, the stopper does not lay flush with the sink bottom, so it gets in the way when I try to lay a large pan in the bottom of the sink. Finally, the inside of the stopper just gets GROSS!!

    Continuous feed and air switch for me this time around.