Software
Houzz Logo Print
gobruno_gw

Should I get these CL chairs (different)?

16 years ago

Ok, so here I am again.... I passed on that last set of CL dining room chairs bc they needed way too much work. I saw a set of 6 of these on CL, and am considering getting them. The good part is that they are all side chairs. So, I can make seating for 8 by getting 2 upholstered head chairs. If I got these, I think I'd add a beefier foam padding and reupholster, of course. Thoughts?

{{!gwi}}

If it matters, I think I could get all 6 for between $150-200. Here is my dining room (I've been working on the accessories, and I'll post photos of all that when I'm done!):

Again, excuse the blurry photos!

This is our current dining room table:

Thanks!

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    You have a large room with high ceilings so I think you need chairs with higher backs.

  • 16 years ago

    They look like midcentury Hepplewhite revival to me. I think they would work with your table. Are all the seats done in different needlework? I would keep the needlework even if you took it off the seats.

  • 16 years ago

    I thought about the higher back thing. Part of me feels like it would be fine to have lower backs bc there is plenty else to look at in the room, but part of me has the same concern about the high ceiling.

    Palimpsest, yes all the chairs have needlework seats. The ones in the photo are in pretty good shape, but 3 of them look really worn. The seller is going to include 4 replacement needlepoint seat covers that are new. I don't know if they came with the seats or what, but they are all hand done. I agree, I was planning on keeping the needlepoint when I recovered the chairs.

    Any other thoughts?

    Thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    Hepplewhite, Sheraton, and Regency furniture is all rather small and delicate and it was often used in very large rooms with very high ceilings. Houses in my city that are contemporary to this furniture often had 12 foot ceilings in the public rooms. My building, which is 1840 and probably had classical and early Empire furniture which is a bit heavier, has 14 and 12 foot ceilings on the "public" floors. and the rooms are 25 feet long.

    Its not a contemporary way of looking at it but they were often used in high ceilinged spaces. In contrast some of the very high backed Frank Lloyd Wright chairs were used in rooms with ceilings that were relatively low for the period. Its a matter of playing with scale.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the perspective, palimpsest. I'm new to this CL stuff, and have usually bought all my furniture new. I know that not all used furniture is created equally. So, some of it is worthy of another owner, and some isn't. I would like to try to get something off of CL bc I think I would get a much better value for my money. At the same time, I hesitate a lot with this decision bc I don't want to get something that is poor quality just bc it's inexpensive, and that I'm going to want to replace in 3 years. I guess I'm wondering how I'll know that it's the right choice.

    My husband's criticism of some that we've looked at are that they look so worn. So, I wonder, will all used furniture look worn, or is it just the ones that we're looking at? Won't we make the chairs look worn eventually anyway; so, does it matter? We bought the new dining table above, and we love it. It is beautiful. But, within the first week, our 3 year old put 2 nicks in the edge of the table. It felt so tragic. If it were a used table, I don't think I would have cared....

  • 16 years ago

    Good point about the nicks in the table, gobruno. That's one of the reasons I almost always get used furniture. If I pay $50 for a chair and someone spills on it, I'm not going to flip out.

    I also think that if you keep searching you will find something that will work well for you off CL or at an estate sale. The chairs you linked are pretty but may be too small. Your dining table is a classic and will be nice with older chairs.

    Red

  • 16 years ago

    Ok, so probably pass? I'm trying to be patient, but I just want to get something to cross this item off my list! The problem is that I'm not in the biggest metropolitan area; so, the selection isn't all that great. Thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    While they are pretty chairs, I don't think they look very sturdy and that is something you will want with a family. How often do you plan to use the formal dining room and chairs? I think Queen Anne style chairs would look good with your table, have the heigher backs and also tend to be sturdier. Finding the right chairs on CL is all about being patient, knowing what you want so when you see it you will have the confidence to act fast, and good keyword searches. Try things like: chair, vintage, antique, mahogany, queen anne, duncan phyfe, ethan allen, etc

    Look for something like these from my local CL.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Queen Anne Chairs

  • 16 years ago

    I'd pass. If you beef up the seat cushion, it will take up a lot of space in the back of the chair and throw the scale off. Generally look too small and delicate for your room. The right chairs are out there....you'll find them.