Software
Houzz Logo Print
morton5_gw

Do you regret deleting your trash compactor?

18 years ago

I know that many of you have strong feelings about trash compactors, and I am well aware of their virtues and vices. I was planning on getting rid of mine in the remodel, but now I'm getting cold feet. We are a family of 7 and generate a lot of trash, even after recycling and composting. So, my question is, if you got rid of your compactor, do you miss it? Did you have to increase the # of trash cans in the garage? Do you find that your pullout is as nasty to clean as the compactor?

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    We kept our compactor. When we moved in, the one that came with the house wasn't working. We replaced it and use it strictly for recylce type items. I had never had one before and I love it! Maybe you can give it a trial run and just not use it for a week. Hope it works out for you!

  • 18 years ago

    We don't miss our compactor. The pullout is not as messy, and if it was, it would be far easier to clean...And to know every bit was clean. I was never sure of that with the compactor, it had so many places to get gross.

    We have the same garbage service we had before...There are too many variables to say how much that change might have had on our overall volume of trash.

  • 18 years ago

    Getting rid of the trash compactor was one of the best things we've ever done. We've gotten so much pleasure from the wine cooler that moved into the space. In our remodel, we will have an under-the-sink two-bin pullout for both trash and recycling. There's just two of us, so this arrangement might not work for you. If you compact only dry, clean paper waste (like cereal boxes), then keeping a new compactor clean shouldn't be difficult. But if milk cartons and juice boxes go in there, even rinsed ones, it may start to get nasty in short order.

  • 18 years ago

    I never understand the issue with them getting nasty...we put just about anything in there, and we do think before squishing I guess (normally with a box on top or news paper or mags) but we also always use good quality TC bags. Ours is never nasty. Really...no smell, nothing :) I could not live without it. We were in a rental for two months between homes (remodel hell here) and between two adults and a baby...we had buckets and buckets and yuck yuck trash! Our TC is a godsend I'll never go without again!

  • 18 years ago

    We don't miss our compactor at all! We love being able to have recycling as handy as our trash in our two pullouts.

  • 18 years ago

    We don't miss ours, either. We started out with 5 in the family and now are down to 3 1/2. We aggressively recycle (meaning not just cans!) The only time we fill our weekly trash can is when we have a big party. Our recycle container is slightly larger than our trash can and fills much faster. Having a seperate container for composting helps as well.

  • 18 years ago

    Getting rid of my 19 year old TC and replacing it with an undercounter beverage cooler is one of the better decisions of my remodel. Never liked the TC, rarely used it, it just took up good cabinet space. I now use a pullout double bin trash/recycle system which works great plus the beverage center gets daily use.

  • 18 years ago

    When I remodeled I thought about it and decided to get another compactor - glad I did - don't put smelly things into it and it won't smell. We only have trash pickup once a week so it's a big help.

  • 18 years ago

    Not only am I keeping my compactor, I added a 2nd one in my walk in pantry for recyclables. I love having a compactor in the kitchen. We inherited ours with this house and i was prepared to yank it but immediately loved it. It doesn't stink, and we typically only have one bag of trash a week.

    And I especially love the one for recycling. Before the compactor I had cans and boxes in an ever-growing pile as trash day approached, and now it is all contained and out of site. Love that! If I could only have one compactor I'd skip the trash one and do the recycling one.

    Anita

  • 18 years ago

    We are getting rid of ours during our kitchen remodel (starting tomorrow!) because the trash compactor bags are expensive. I think we are making the right decision!

  • 18 years ago

    Can't wait to get rid of our old one
    that hasn't worked in a long time &
    is kinda gross looking...won't be
    replacing it. I prefer the trash outside
    pretty quickly.