Software
Houzz Logo Print
verona_nj

Stain Issues with Maple Cabinets

17 years ago

I'm looking at maple cabinets in a butternut stain. I've heard that maple doesn't take stain well- mottling, smudges, etc. Anyone have a problem with that? Anyone have Omega or Dynasty cabinets in maple with a stain! TIA !

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    You have to look at the samples from the manufacturer.

    A lot of commercial work is not actually stained at all, but the color it in the finish layer itself.

  • 17 years ago

    We did maple cabs with a glaze in our daughter's bathrooms. The idea of the glaze was to try and offset the yellowing that occurs with maple over time. You might be amazed at how much maple yellows. So now we have sort of a "dirty maple". It works because there is not much cabinetry, but if I had a whole run, as in a kitchen, I don't think I would be satisfied. The uptake of the glaze is uneven; I think a stain would be worse. Our cabinet person told us that maple doesn't take a stain well, and that we should not stain the maple.

  • 17 years ago

    My cabinet guy won't stain maple. Like brickeyee said above, I guess the stain you do see on maple really isn't a stain at all - the color comes from a sprayed on finish that my cab guy claims is not even 1/2 as good in any aspect (looks, durability, etc) as the normal staining process he uses. He just doesn't want his name on stained maple. He will do natural (clear) stain only on maple.

    My friend is doing medium-darkish stain on maple and the stain company she was sent to to pick her stain says that they have lots and lots of customers who choose stain for their maple, and it's not at all unusual - and I think her sample looks just fine, but I can't attest to how it will look going from an 8" sample to a huge cabinet run, nor can I attest to how it will hold up as there seems to be a number of processess to stain and evidently the maple process isn't the same as normal.

  • 17 years ago

    Our cabinet shop also told us that maple doesn't stain well. We went with a natural maple, but the top coat they put on it won't yellow. My understanding is that it's the finish (polyurethane?) that causes the wood to yellow.

  • 17 years ago

    My last kit was custom maple cabs. The finisher matched something of ours exactly and used a dye mixed in the varnish. They came out beautiful doing it that way.

  • 17 years ago

    My new kitchen has custom stained maple cabs. The stain definitely brought out the grain pattern. If that bothers you, choose a natural or light finish. Some of my cabs have a quiet pattern while others are more pronounced. DH loves it as he says it shows the character of the wood and friends have commented favorably that it looks like real wood. I'm attaching a photo of the shelf on my hood as it's very "burled" looking, but you can also see the pattern in the surrounding wood as well.