Software
Houzz Logo Print
crzyktchnlady

Please help - faucet selection nightmares.

17 years ago

IÂm sure I have looked at 10,000 faucets by now, either in person or in catalogues or on the web. I didnÂt think what I wanted was so unusual, but it took me forever to find what I wanted. So today I got a message from my "dealer" -he called the manufacturer to get a definitive price and availability and learned that this faucet is "under review" which means who-knows-what but it is INDEFINITELY UNAVAILABLE!! Arrggghh!! I canÂt believe I have to start this process over.

So here is what I am looking for if you have any ideas (or tell me IÂm nuts; I didnÂt call myself crzyktchnlady for nothing). I am in love with polished nickel. I know many people say you canÂt tell the difference from chrome, but I can and IÂm in love and it will look better in my kitchen. I donÂt want a pullout or pulldown. I want an arc style, transitional, single or double handles but single-hole style, not widespread. IÂd also like it to have a good reach  9 inches ideally. IÂm planning on getting a Blanco Silgranite 1-3/4 bowl sink. IÂm trying not to spend a grand on a faucet - I mean itÂs a faucet; are they kidding??!!!

Here is a link to the "under review faucet" (different finish) from a little known company. Thank you to all wonderful smart clever GW people. I have learned so much from you all already.

Here is a link that might be useful: Probably Bad Faucet

Comments (30)

  • 17 years ago

    I'd check these guys first, if you haven't already.

    Plumbing supply
    HICO group and ask what's up.

    There can be all kinds of issues between a manufacturer or distributor and a retail seller. Maybe the faucet is being discontinued - or maybe the two are feuding over some other issue - or maybe the distributor is feuding with the manufacturer. Or maybe somebody is going out of business.

    Kohler Essex and Blanco Essence are fairly similar. I know that doesn't help a lot either.

  • 17 years ago

    On another thread I related my difficulty in actually getting the faucet I had finally chosen. Not available. Yesterday, the same thing happened with a water filter faucet.

    What we're seeing is the fallout from the financial crisis and the housing slowdown.

    You also mention price -- I had a budget for what I wanted to spend. It wasn't the lowest or the highest. What I found is that the middle has more or less gone away.

    Polished nickel is a lovely surface. As long as you don't mind caring for it like silver from time to time (I don't) as it needs polishing. It's always more expensive than chrome but I went for it in my kitchen last time and I love it and I'm not sorry. Nothing crazy about that.

    Grohe faucets might have the style you want. I'd also look at Newport Brass and Chicago Faucets -- perhaps you already have.

    Two internet sources I found with good prices and service are homeperfect and faucets4cheap. I bought my sink from plumbtile and also got good service on a hard-to-find item. Since I needed my faucets right away, I called to see what they have in stock or what they can get. They were very helpful.

    I wound up with something different than I started looking for but I did get a good brand and functionality in a style I know will look great and I was lucky to catch a buy and do it for what I originally wanted to spend.

    Keep going and you'll find it, too.

  • 17 years ago

    I also liked a Cucina faucet and was told by the plumbing supply company that they were not good. I bought the Blanco Grace faucet in polished chrome. Don't know if it comes in polished nickel but it's worth a look. Supposedly Blanco faucets are very good. I'm happy with mine so far (have only had it a week). Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I found it on ebay for $157 if you want that one. The seller says to contact him for different finishes. Good luck!

    Here is a link that might be useful: is this it?

  • 17 years ago

    Oops, sorry, $194 in the polished nickel

    Here is a link that might be useful: tada!

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you all so much! Rubyfig - that is a great price. I will check it out, but I am wary about the brand now based on what Jeanteach posted and what my dealer learned. I need to do more research on this. Of course, at that price it could be worth a gamble. Rococogurl, I'm using Grohe in my bathroom, but they don't do polished nickel for the kitchen. Few companies do. Bmorepanic, I like the Kohler Essex alot, but it doesn't come in polished nickel either. I may need to go back to my drawing board!

  • 17 years ago

    Have you thought of just having one plated? Little more of a PITA, but if that is the finish you love and few make it, it is an option.

  • 17 years ago

    Rubyfig - I was wondering if that is possible. How would I go about doing that - through the manufacturer, or if not, who would do it? If it's not the manufacturer, I wonder if it would destroy the warranty. Thanks again.

  • 17 years ago

    If you can be a little flexible in your requirements, Kohler makes the Parq faucet in polished nickel but it requires two holes not one, and they have the Revival faucet (which I have) in brushed nickel but it requires 3 holes. You can see them on the Kohler website.

  • 17 years ago

    Those are nice faucets, weissman, especially the Revival. I think I need a single hole because of the shape of my 1-3/4 bowl sink - I don't want the faucet spout offset too far from the center. But I need to get more flexible and may move to brushed nickel instead of polished.

  • 17 years ago

    crzy, not sure what it would do to the warranty (although if the fittings are well made, I don't see why it would matter) but a plater would do it (I'm in the costume jewelry field, and I have noticed that the workroom regularly plates chrome, nickel hardware, all sorts of things). I would look for one locally first, and they can tell you what base material can and can't be plated (usually, it is a no-go with stainless). If that doesn't work, here is one you can use through the mail. I hope that helps a bit. Good luck!

    Here is a link that might be useful: acme plating

  • 17 years ago

    I think those eBay faucets look like a great deal! It's the faucet you are looking for, and it certainly is reasonably priced. If not, what about the Rohl arch faucet with side spray from the Rohl "Country Kitchen Series"? Rohl makes high-quality faucets, and their polished nickel finish is very nice (I have their polished nickel faucet in my bathroom for 4 years, and it looks great). I also think Rohl is excellent at bridging a look that is between traditional and contemporary, and would look good in either decor. The only thing this faucet does not have on your list is that it is an 8" reach rather than 9". The polished nickel is $418.50.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rohl A1676LMWS Kitchen Faucet with sidespray

  • 17 years ago

    that is a nice faucet akchicago found. :)

  • 17 years ago

    Hey Rubyfig, I'm glad we have the same taste! But the arched faucet I REALLY like is the Perrin & Rowe U.4702. But at $1200 for the polished nickel finish, I think it's out of the OP's budget, and definitely way out of mine! But could it BE any more graceful and elegant???

    Here is a link that might be useful: Perrin & Rowe arch faucet

  • 17 years ago

    "under review" sounds kind of ominous! The first thing I thought of was high lead content. With the cheap price and probably China origin, I guess it's possible? I would be wary...

    I've seen quite a number of faucets similar to that one-- Blanco makes one, as does Hansgrohe, I think. Maybe you already saw those?

    It's a pretty faucet but you can find another similar without the weirdness of this under review deal...

  • 17 years ago

    AK - We also have the same taste - that P&R 4702 is my absolute favorite faucet choice. It would be "the one" for me except for the price. That's what I meant by outrageously priced. Way outside of my budget, but it sure is beautiful. The Rohl country faucet may be my best alternative. I think I saw it a while ago but was worried about the shorter reach. I'm taking a second look. I am wary Nesting12, especially with a less well-known manufacturer. Hansgrohe has a nice arc faucet that comes in polished nickel, a bit contemporary for me, but I'm reconsidering it too. Rubyfig - I don't know if I'm adventurous enough to go for the plating option, but I am going to look at the website and keep an open mind.

    Thank you all for your ideas. I love this site!!

  • 17 years ago

    Sometimes the kitchen folks at the snooty stores actually beat internet prices, so look into that, too. They won't beat the unauthorized dealers, but if you show them an authorized dealer quote they will often beat it. That happened to me and it made life so much easier. Then they handle everything in that nice good-service way-- if there are issues, you can call them, etc. So don't rule that out. I had, but ended up exhaustedly asking a salesguy a million questions out of desperation and he then beat the internet price and voila-- learned something.

    That Rohl faucet is pretty. It was a complete wrong choice for my kitchen, but I admired it in the showroom. Nice proportions.

  • 17 years ago

    Yay for polished nickel! It's my favorite finish.

    I have the Kohler Essex and just love it, it's a gorgeous faucet (mine is brazen bronze). I'd also recommend getting one you love for the design and quality and having it plated. It might not cost all that much, especially if you can find the faucet on eBay or elsewhere for a deal.

    Another plating company I've had great experiences with is Mac the Antique Plumber, who can seemingly replicate any finish on earth.

    If you've come across any with this single-hole, two-handle style AND a pulldown spout, please let me know! That was my initial desire, but no such beast could be found.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Mac the Antique Plumber

  • 17 years ago

    I don't think I have seen any pulldowns with two handles either. So many choices and we can't find our hearts desires! Right now, the Rohl Country and Essex (plated) are at the top of my list, but I'm going to shop around again. I'm buying most of my stuff (appliances, fixtures, etc) from Ferguson and I was pleasantly surprised that their prices were lower than I expected. They beat Sears on appliances and they were willing to deal where I found a lower price on some items, including internet prices, even matching Home Depot on one item. Sadly, I doubt the P&R will ever get down into my price range, even on eBay.

  • 17 years ago

    Why would you want two handles? One handle is so much easier. I would never go back to a two-handle kitchen faucet. Kitchen faucets are used in a way that the temperature you need varies a lot depending upon the task at hand, from ice cold to warm to hot, depending upon what you are doing with the water in the kitchen. Having two handles makes changing the temperature of the water more difficult. Also, if your hands are dirty from chicken or whatever, you don't want to need to grasp two handles to turn on the water! Two handles look nice in a bathroom faucet, but in a kitchen very inefficient and a PITA.

    Also, in your list of "must-haves", I'd ditch the side spray requirement. As has been reported many times on this forum, the side sprays do not compare favorably with pull-out or pull-down sprays because they tend to break more easily, they do not have as much water pressure, you need to be holding the lever the WHOLE time the spray is on, and they require another hole drilled in your countertop. If for example you have the faucet, the side spray, a disposal air switch, a hot water dispenser, etc. you are looking very busy with your sink area. It's also more to clean around. The less holes the better. I can see no reason to have a side spray. Even if you want a "traditional" look, the side spray won't really give it to you, while on many pull-down or pull-out faucets the spray feature is not very visible and will look very traditional or contemporary whichever you want.

    I would think your choices will be much greater without a sidespray, and with one handle.

    Don't compromise on the polished nickel finish. Don't get a satin nickel. You won't be as happy, and this is quite a long-term puchase. Also, polished nickel is timeless, and has been around since plumbing fixtures were first made. Satin or brushed finishes are quite recent, and may run the risk of being dated (I don't know). Polished nickel is simply beautiful.

  • 17 years ago

    Alwaysfixin, you raise some really good points. I am definitely not fixated on two-handles. I'd prefer a single but could not find one I liked (arc style in PN) except for the very expensive Perrin & Rowe that akchicago also loves. Many others are very bulky at the bottom with a big R2D2 looking barrel base. I also started out wanting a pulldown and then nixed them because they are all so huge and fat and bulky. I couldn't get past the look. My kitchen is small and I wanted a more graceful looking faucet, definitely an arc style. If I could find an arc style pulldown that has a somewhat graceful profile and single handle in PN, that would be it. I'm taking a second look at the Hansgrohe Swing C. We all seem to love polished nickel but I think that's my big problem. Too bad more companies don't use this finish in kitchen faucets. Maybe I need to bite the bullet on $$$$ - as you say it's a long-term purchase.

  • 17 years ago

    What about the Kohler Vinnata? It is a popular faucet on this forum. Do a search on this forum for "kohler vinnata" and you'll come up with a lot of threads and pics to look at.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kohler Vinnata in Pol NIckel at Faucets.com

  • 17 years ago

    I agree w/AlwaysFixin [except, I like the brushed nickel better :-)].

    I do have the Vinnata and love it; but the faucet head is bulkier (partly b/c it's a pull down w/spray button). It has the same reach (9-1/2") which is a good thing w/a 1-3/4 sink (that I also have). The Vinnata is an inch taller (16-1/2" vs 15-1/2"). It has one handle that can be installed on the left, middle, or right (mine is installed on the right). It's been a little over a year and it's working as great today as day 1. I've never had to polish it, I just wipe it down w/a soapy dishcloth when I do the dishes...no changes to the finish. It actually seems to clean easier than my old chrome faucet...it doesn't show water spots (an issue on our old chrome faucet and all the chrome faucets still in the upstairs bathrooms) and I have to actually look close to see if it's dirty! All pluses, IMO! (I also have the Fairfax pull out on my prep sink w/the same finish and the same comments apply.)

    [Regarding water spots: while they don't bother me in a SS sink they really bug me on a faucet! The brushed nickel has made my life easier! (My SS sinks also doesn't seem to show many water spots (brushed finish maybe?)]

  • 17 years ago

    So funny. The Vinnata was my very first faucet choice. I was sure it was the faucet for me, but just from photos. Then I saw the real thing and could not believe how big it was. Obviously, I had not bought a faucet in a long, long, long time. My current wall faucet dates from the dinosaur days. I said to the sales guy "When did faucets get so huge?" OK, it's true, I'm out of it. I need to get with the times and reconsider.

  • 17 years ago

    I had the same reaction-- the faucets seems so huge to me too! I ended up with a KWC pullout that, to my eye, is not so gargantuan. I have a smaller kitchen and the sink is right under the window and a huge faucet would just look odd. Although I do love the way the Tara looks, so graceful and pretty.

    I like chrome for faucets. To me it works best for both modern and traditional settings. Just love chrome... and it's usually cheaper! It shows water spots all over the place, of course, but they wipe off immediately, too.

  • 17 years ago

    Gosh, I can totally relate to your faucet selection nightmare. It seems that as time goes on in the remodeling project, one just get so weary of making decisions and more afraid of making mistakes!

    I looked at several faucets myself and spent far too much time zoning out on them at numerous web sites. My dear son was about to have me committed! When in doubt, I look to what Buehl has decided on and I got with it. So, I ended up with the Kohler Vinnata. Thanks Buehl! The Moen Woodmere was a close contender, but since it's a newer faucet it was more pricey than the Vinnata.

    The Perrin and Rowe faucets are to die for, but I couldn't justify the expense and I was tired of the separate side sprayer.

  • 17 years ago

    crzyktchnlady...you do realize the Vinnata is only 1" taller than the one you linked to...correct? The prep sink version (K-691) is shorter than the one you linked...15-1/8" vs 15-1/2". However, its reach is only 7-1/2" and I think that would be an issue w/a two-bowl or large single-bowl sink.

    Dimensions for Vinnata (both):
    http://www.us.kohler.com/onlinecatalog/pdf/1013943_4.pdf


  • 17 years ago

    You're welcome & thanks for the compliment Karena_2009!

    I have to admit, though, that I did not have faucet angst for the kitchen b/c I saw the Vinnata early on and fell in love with it! The PR, however, was another story! I had picked one that I really liked but when we went to install it, it didn't fit b/c of the BS behind the PR sink! I then had to search for something similar, but never found it. After a couple of weeks of going all over looking at bathroom faucets, I finally gave up and just settled for one. Interestingly, after seeing it installed & using it, I really started liking it and I'm now seriously thinking of getting the same faucet for the upstairs bathrooms...as soon as I can convince my DH we should spend the $$ on them!

    [I have a "bad habit" of trying to fix things when they have problems and I keep proving we don't need a new one of the item...it's sure tough to justify new when you can inexpensively fix the existing!]

  • 17 years ago

    My pleasure, buehl ;-). Are you a KD by any chance? Anyhoo, good luck crzyktcnlady on your faucet selection.

  • 17 years ago

    Crzyktchnlady - I am linking an old thread about Perrin & Rowe polished nickel faucet that gives some pros and cons about the finish. Hope it helps in deciding whether you want to spend about triple what some other faucets cost!

    BTW, I love my Newport Brass polished nickel faucet, but it's not in the style you want.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Old Thread about P & R Polished Nickel Faucet