Software
Houzz Logo Print
pahance

Which Pillow? (Pic Heavy Post)

19 years ago

What are you thoughts on this combo? [I Photoshopped these pillows onto the chair, btw.]

The chair is in the Family room, just to the right of this sofa:

This is the one I really love, but I'm not sure it'll work with what I have:

I also like this one:

Sometimes what you love is not necessarily what works, unfortunately. Which pillow do you think looks the best? They're all needlepoint and each one is over $100, so I *don't* want to regret my choice after dropping that much $. Please share your opinions and help me decide!

Comments (32)

  • 19 years ago

    I'm not crazy about any of them. None of them seem to relate to the sofa. I think that I would go with something simpler, or no pillow at all.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm not sure I like any of them to be honest, and for $100 I'd want to love them. It seems like the light sofa set is very modern, and the chair is more reminiscent to me of Pottery Barn and the pillows more english country. If you need a pillow, I'd find one that picks up the colors of the sofa, and in turn, find a chair colored pillow for the sofa. A simple, geometric pillow, not necessarily a needlepoint.

  • 19 years ago

    I don't care for any of them - they don't work with the furniture in the rest of the space. I would look for a pillow with a much lighter background, and some of the green and black to connect with the cleaner, lighter look of the rest of the space.

    Perhaps the featured fall leaves pillow on the Pier 1 site would be a possibility? Can't buy on line any more, only in stores, but the green and the lighter feel might be nice.

    pillow

  • 19 years ago

    Can you photo shop this fabric onto you chair? Maybe something more contemporary to go with the rest of your room.

  • 19 years ago

    The pillows are very traditional in what looks like a more modern space. White setional, silver lamp, etc. I would choose a geometric.

  • 19 years ago

    Although I really like your needlepoint pillows, I think your pillow style and your chair style, don't have anything in common. I agree with the others, that none of them work. A pillow for that leather chair should be something very simple, maybe in a chenille, or even a kilim style pillow like the ones from Pottery Barn, something that shares colors with the chair.

    Red

    Here is a link that might be useful: You can find these on Ebay now

  • 19 years ago

    Try placing the red flower pillow (the one you really love) on the sofa, remove the black/white pillow from the sofa and maybe put a soft lime green throw on the leather chair to pull the color from the green sofa pillows. Seems like it's the black/white pillow that trying to shout "modern" while the other items are moving towards traditional. It's a very pretty room too! :)

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback! Gosh, I am such an ADDecorator (though eclectic sounds so much better) and I do have a tendency to lose focus because there are so many styles I love. This is also the first time I've ever really deviated from more of a traditional type decor, so I'm learning. I decided though, that I wanted to do the family room in a more contemporary style. The formal LR is much more traditional.

    I don't consider this living room to be modern though. Modern is a different animal altogether, IMO.

    In keeping with the black and white and green (with a little red here and there) scheme, along with the contemporary style, I'd like to find a way to bring these elements into a throw pillow for that chair.

    I'll try to do the Photoshopping tonight and see what I can come up with.

    Thanks again for your much appreciated adivce!

  • 19 years ago

    This is really pretty...

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    Like redsox's idea of pulling white and green together into a pillow on the brown chair, as a way of linking the brown chair to the very contemporary sofa/tables/pillows you already have going. I also thought perhaps using the white/green pillows from the sofa and putting some of those on the chair.

    It's the traditional heavy brown of the chair combined with the stark modern black/white/green of the sofa that is throwing me. If the chair was done in black leather, that would tie it together too.

    However, I am not there in the room. "Eclectic" can work if you love it and people are comfortable and give you compliments when they walk into the area. When you look at the arrangement with fresh eyes, how does it look to you?

    I am impressed with your photoshop abilities!

  • 19 years ago

    Papercrane - 'tis true about the brown chair being a bit out of place with the black & white (and the sofa is actually more an eggshell - it's not stark white), but I bought the chair before my decision to go with this color scheme. No, the room will never look like something out of ELLE DECOR but I think I can still make it presentable. Actually, I'm not even at the point of no return with regards to the whole black & white thing. If I remove the black lamp shade and the the black pillows (they are actually two), I'm pretty much left with a blank slate.

    But I don't want to do that! :-) Unless you guys think it looks totally rediculous, that is. (You don't, do you?)

    RedSox: Thank you for the pillow suggestion - I love it! Where did you find it? Here it is Photoshopped onto the chair (maybe a little too big?), along with Les's Pier One pillow. Thanks, Les! The Pier One pillow really picks up the bronzey tones in the table nicely, doesn't it?

    Redsox - I also did your fabric (which I love, btw), but I can't find where I saved the pic and I need to get off the computer for a while. I'll look for it in the morning.

    Thanks again, all!

  • 19 years ago

    rosewind...here is the link. The price is steep but maybe you can find something similar for less. The pillow is under textiles.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pillow Link

  • 19 years ago

    Maybe a little too retro (I like it though)...Good price too.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Ebay pillow

  • 19 years ago

    What pillows are on your white sofa? Do you actually need a pillow on the chair? It doesn't look real roomy, and I'm wondering if color or softness is what you're after -- maybe a throw would work also, and add some variety from an assortment of pillows in the room.

    Colorwise, the first vase pillow and the last leaf pillow work for me -- heavy on the neutrals, I guess :)

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, Squirrel. I don't know, I guess was trying to give the chair (and the room) a little more character and thought sort of a unique pillow on the poor lonely chair in the corner would help accomplish that. LOL (I cannot deny as well that I covet needlepoint pillows.)

    Maybe I'll end up going with a throw for now until I find just the right pillow. I s'pose that would be the safest choice!--and we sure could use a throw in that room with the temps dropping outside.

  • 19 years ago

    Yeah, I would put a nice throw for now.

  • 19 years ago

    A throw - I love squirrelheaven's idea! A throw covers more of the chair and gives you more room to pull things together. I also love the fabric on that last pillow (the one with the leaf on it). Is there a way to get a throw in that pillow fabric? It looks like it echoes the colors in the rest of the room.

  • 19 years ago

    I thought that was a professional photoshoot of the sofa!

    So, with those actually being your pillows and furnishings, if you should be thinking of a throw -- something a bit different might be a wool shawl. They look very nice draped over a chair. I looked around a bit and linked a site that seemed to have some really nice ones -- hand-embroidered at that! Black and white works well, connecting to the sofa area, and there were a couple that had a contemporary look to them that seemed to pick up the feel of your sofa and pillows. Novico might be another source.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Website of Shawls

  • 19 years ago

    This artist has a white poppies on black and black lilies on white.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Shawls on Novica

  • 19 years ago

    Here's a somewhat contemporary needlepoint pillow with what I thought was a soft green background (but looking at it in the virtual, may actually be a yellow) and a touch of red (linked to see the pillow). Something like that also looks very pretty in there, imo, and flows with your sofa area. Textured throw from ZGallerie!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Needlepoint Pillow Site - Audubon Hummingbird Pillow

  • 19 years ago

    Their fern pillow seems to pick up the green also.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    Maybe you long for some red in there?

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    FWIW, I think it is the black and white pillow that is the difficult one. If you dropped that and worked with SH's pics of the needlepoints and throw and concentrated on the lime and red I think you could get it to work!

  • 19 years ago

    Wow, Squirrel - Thanks so much! I went on a search for throws but couldn't find anything I liked. You've given me great ideas here! I really like my favorite flower pillow on the sofa with the existing green ones. I think a coordinating one on the other side would really fit the bill. As for leather chair, I actually think I like the lime throw on it the best. Where did you find that one? Or is a Squirrel Creation? ;-)

    And Jilly - I think you may be right. I think I'll just relegate the black pillows to the basement sofa, which is khaki and in need of pillows anyway. The lamp shade was one I already had and put it there while waiting for the RH ivory one to arrive (it's on backorder) which I was going to trim in black gross-grain.

    I really wanted the B&W to work, but love the lime & red together. All my furniture is brown anyway and I won't have to figure out how much would need to be replaced with black.

    Thanks to all who gave me constructive critisism. And Squirrel, once again, a big THANKS for the wonderful mockups. You're a doll.

    ~Patty

  • 19 years ago

    Squirrel you do an amazing job.

    I love your sofa and room. I don't care for the black and white on the brown chair at all - whether it is a throw or a pillow.

    What if you had a throw on the chair that had lime green, eggshell and red in it? Don't know if there is such a thing but then you would tie it all together. Also the throw covers a bit more of the brown chair which I think helps.

    Anyway good luck with your room, can't wait to see what you decide.

  • 19 years ago

    Glad it helped, Rosewind! It's a different look, but I looove the botanicals on the white sofa, and the red with the green is beautiful, very fresh and happy :)

    The throw was a lucky find! It's linked below. There are some others in lime green also. There are two on page one below that are really pretty, and then if you put 'green' in the 'shawl' search block to search within those results, you'll find some others, including solids.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Shawls at Novica

  • 19 years ago

    I agree the black and white pillow is what has to go.

    I think the pillow that you liked from the first post can work fine if you get rid of the b/w pillow. It's giving the space a modern vibe you don't seem to want.

    Get the pillow you love, plus another one, or two :-), that you can add to the sofa to pull it all together. Squirrel's last mockups are nice - minus the b/w stuff.

    I would definitely stay away from the cute doggie pillow and go with the bold florals. I think they go nicely with your furnishings and let you play with the balance between traditional and contemporary elements.

    You can always save the more "frou-frou" needlepoint pillows for a bedroom or other cozy corner.

  • 19 years ago

    >>I would definitely stay away from the cute doggie pillow and go with the bold florals. I think they go nicely with your furnishings and let you play with the balance between traditional and contemporary elements.Kaileanm: Oh, absolutely. Now I am on the hunt for another floral needlepoint that'll jive with the other one. Wish me luck and thanks for the tips!

  • 19 years ago

    Please show us when you're done, Rosewind! I love the green and black, too, so 'into the basement' set me hunting, too, lol. If it were me, I think I'd have alternate looks for the room, one with the more contemporary green and black :) (No Squirrel-y pieces, either Novica or ZGallerie accessories :)

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    Springvillegardens, thank you for your nice compliment. You're very sweet - and I will definitely post pics when I'm finished!

    Not bad, Squirrel, not bad at all. I guess this is the upside to having a white sofa - you can change the look so easily and the possibilities are fairly limitless. Oh - and I, too, loooove those botanicals. I may even decide to go with those instead of the other pillow - who knows.

    You know, that coffee table is too big for the sectional and I am eventually going to replace it. I think if it were black, these colors - the B&W - would work really, really well, even with the brown chair. I spent some time looking at decorating mags over the weekend and found that decorators do indeed make use of brown furniture with B&W; ideally though, there should be a few black pieces in the room - a coffee table, a B&W rug, art, frames, etc.

    Well, you've given me some things to think about. Thanks again, Squirrel!

  • 19 years ago

    The furniture does look like a black-brown from here :) So, I guess that's what I'm seeing, with the brown leather being what's 'off.' Loove the florals!! It's a beautiful room :)