Software
Houzz Logo Print
rabmen_gw

Guidance needed from Marble owners

16 years ago

Hello, and thank you in advance. My wife and I are on the horns of a dilemma. We both are leaning toward using honed Imperial Danby marble from Vermont, but are concerned about the stones ability to deal with stains (red wine, etc.) The etching is not an an issue for us. We do however use our kitchen every day, and are are can be quite messy during prep, etc. our past two houses had granite in them, and we had no issues.

For those of you who have installed marble could you share your your thoughts regarding: What sealers have you had good results with? What has been your experience regarding lasting stains (for instance: a wine glass ring left over night after entertaining)? What have you used to deal with/clean stains? Thanks for sharing.

rabmen

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago

    Of all the marbles, I understand the Danby is the least porous. I tried to go with Danby also but it was unavailable in my area at the time. I went with honed calacatta instead. I haven't really used it yet and can't attest to the stain removal, etc. Many GW members love their honed white marble and have had great results by sealing. One sealer, Miracle brand 511 Porous Plus is a favorite and there is one other....can't remember the name of it. The sealer will prevent most staining and there are stain removal techniques for really stubborn ones.
    The sealer will not protect the stone from etching when acidic stuff gets spilled on it. The etching isn't very noticeable on honed marble and will develop into a patina over time if you let it. Another option is to have the stone re-honed (costs a couple hundred bucks though).
    If you can score a sample and beat it up a bit, you'll be able to get an idea of what you can live with. I had a few samples I tested for about a year before I took the plunge. The polished one didn't do as badly as I expected. The Danby held up the best of all, the honed calacatta came in at a close second. I left spills overnight on the samples, poured vinegar on one, ketchup, etc. They all still looked really pretty to me after I cleaned them up.
    My daughter scribbled all over some of them with a black pen, they were unsealed and those marks were impossible for me to get out. I didn't use the heavy stain removal techniques though as they were only samples.
    Hope this helps!

  • 16 years ago

    We have Honed Olympian White Danby marble from Vermont. It's only been installed for a few months so I don't know how helpful I'll be.

    It hasn't been exposed to any red wine yet but we've had ketchup, mustard, and various other things on it that have wiped up easily.

    There was one stubborn coffee stain that I poured a little bleach on and it took care of it with no issues. I read on this forum that if the stone allows a liquid to penetrate the surface and stains it, it will also let bleach penetrate it to get that stain out. Worked like a charm!

    I have a few etch marks but they are barely noticeable. We have had a handful of small dings that I just buffed out with a some very fine steel wool. Overall, I'm very impressed with how easily it cleans up.

    Hope that helps a little!

  • 16 years ago

    I have a white marble similar in looks to Danby but more porous. I used Akemi Nano sealer over the installer's sealer (Bulletproof) which wasn't.

    It's a year old and we use it every day. It's on all the counters in a small kitchen .

    Our sealer has worked very well and there's a follow up product that removes some of the etching. What I've found is that the coffee doesn't stain or etch, it dries down and wipes away. Pomegranate the beet juices are more problemmatic than red wine for us but if wiped immediately (with the sealer I used) no problems. We don't have any stains.

    The worst etching culprits have been the fat in dish soap and sauce spills from Chinese food.

    Also, I'm not completely adoring the edge with the undermounted 30" sink with a 1/8" negative reveal (we have a couple of dings) -- in retrospect, I'd have been happier with something like a Kohler stages sink with that beveled edge or one with a positive reveal so the marble is pulled back from the edge but we weren't replacing cabinets so my options were nil.

    If you use a good sealer (there are many suggestions on numerous threads) and wipe up with regularity it should be fine. You'll need to accept etching and some scratching too, which no one discusses. One end of our island is a major prep area and I had to find non-scratching plastic boards and mats (Crate & Barrel).

    Marble isn't for everyone but we really adore ours and we have had many compliments on it as well.

    Danby's a lovely choice.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for all of the input. We are doing some testing this weekend on a sample.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi there! I had carrera installed a couple of months back. More precious than Danby, but no problems at all. I have both honed and polished.

    It was impregnated by the fabricator with a silicone based sealant and recommended that every few years I use a water based sealant on it.

    I am a certifiable slob. Ask my husband. I have an almost 7 year old and a 5 year old. Let's just say the apple does not fall far from the tree. We cook lots of Indian food and the other day I made pakoras. With turmeric in the batter. Turmeric!

    It took me a good 15 hours until I discovered the dried batter drips all over my countertop. Bright yellow drips. Soap. Water. No stains. Nothing.

    Turmeric is notorious for staining. Years ago it stained my formica countertop for a few months. Did not even tinge my honed marble.

    Don't worry about staining. But make sure you can handle the etching. Or so they say. I have't noticed any etching on either my honed or stained and I am big on lemons, vinegar and messes.