Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_16647

Backsplash Delima

18 years ago

The salesman helping us with our granite purchase has been strongly encouraging us to include the 4 inch back splash border into our kitchen design whether we add a tile back splash or not. He says that we will be stuck regrouting where the counter & tiles meet every year and the 4 inch border will prevent that problem. DH thinks he has a point, but I think it's a scam not to mention I don't prefer that look. There are so many sealants out there and I believe that if it's such a problem, the majority of the pictures I see would include the border, but they don't. To me, it seems lke the salesman is just trying to sell more granite. Now we've actually found a slate tile that we both love and will look perfect as a backslash, but DH wants to use the 4 inch border and I don't so we're turning to the forum for help. Can we get your feedback and valued input please?

Comments (18)

  • 18 years ago

    I'll put my vote for w/o (but I don't plan on having that 4" piece either!).

  • 18 years ago

    That salesman is just trying to sell you more stuff. I would rethink doing business with him. You do not need the 4 inch backsplash and I think it looks weird with the 4 inch plus a tile backsplash. Just go with the slate you love for the bs.

  • 18 years ago

    Me too -- my vote is for not following the salesman's suggestion.

    Every area is different, but where I live (Rocky Mountains) we have "active" soil (not as in earthquakes, but as in clay soil which contracts and expands with the varying seasons), so we have seasonal settling. Our (slab) backsplash was installed this past May and already some of the vertical seams have separated. My husband couldn't see it, but I noticed and pointed it out to him. And you know what? It doesn't bother us! If we need to then sure, we'll take care of it.

    But I might like to take care of some of the developing lines on my face first!

  • 18 years ago

    Actually, if that joint between granite and backsplash gets grouted, you'll be grouting it alot more than once a month. in fact, movinc it up 4" off the countertop won't help much, either.

    Point is that joint neds to be caulked, not grouted, then it's a one time deal.

  • 18 years ago

    The seam where the backplash meets the counter isn't grouted for reasons that it cracks there and doesn't hold up well. Matching caulking instead is used in that area, as it holds up better and has a little give to prevent cracking. Some even start the backsplash tiles right up against the counter, but I think it looks better with a matching caulked grout line with the same spacing as the rest of the tile.

  • 18 years ago

    He is definitely trying to sell you more stuff! When we were getting estimates we had two salesmen tell us "if they try to tell you that you NEED the 4" piece they are lying". And you don't put grout in the joint between the granite and the tiles you put a sanded caulk that matches the grout that you use in the backsplash.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you for the input, I think I misquoted when I used the term regrouting, I should have said recaulking. The saleman claims that with tile, we will have to recaulk annually where with the granite we won't. Regardless, the way I understand from your comments is that it doesn't matter if there is granite or tile, both require caulking and he's just trying to sell more stuff? Right?

  • 18 years ago

    Right.

  • 18 years ago

    Ok! Thanks so much!

  • 18 years ago

    Bill - Can you answer this for me, please? My backsplash was just installed last week: glass tiles all the way down to my marble counters. Sanded grout was used throughout and it looks gorgeous. The installer did not caulk where the glass tiles meet the marble? Should he have caulked?

    The installer also told me he didn't think I need to seal the grout everywhere, just over the range (which seems reasonable). Is he correct? And what about the grout at the very bottom where it meets the marble -- should I seal that, too?

  • 18 years ago

    Should he have caulked?

    Absolutely.

    The installer also told me he didn't think I need to seal the grout everywhere, just over the range (which seems reasonable). Is he correct?

    If you're going to seal any of it, you should seal ALL of it. It's not a big deal, and won't take very much more time. Wet an old towel rag or tshirt with the sealer, and wipe it on, let it soak in for about 5 minutes, and then take a dry absorbant rag, and wipe off the excess. No big deal.

    And what about the grout at the very bottom where it meets the marble -- should I seal that, too?

    Not at all. You should have the guy come back, score it out, and replace it with siliconized caulking-- same color and texture (sanded) from the same manufacturer as the grout.

  • 18 years ago

    I was told the exact same thing today by a kitchen designer. We are building a new home in Eastern NC and he told us with the humidity and settling of new construction, it would be a huge mistake not to have a backsplash. I dislike this look and want to bring the tile all the way down to the countertop, but now I am little afraid to.

  • 18 years ago

    I would start a new thread and address this as a question to Bill Vincent who is very experienced in this area. He may or may not be familiar with what the KD is telling you. First thought that comes to my inexperienced mind is are you buying the granite through a recommended source of the KD? (maybe he/she gets a kick back on the sale depending on volume)

  • 18 years ago

    he told us with the humidity and settling of new construction, it would be a huge mistake not to have a backsplash.

    Don't be afraid o' NUTTIN!! :-) Seriously-- I don't know where these people come up with this crap!! If there's that much settling, just how does your salesman say that adding a 4" splash is going to help that? If your floor sinks THAT much that you need an extra 4", you've got much bigger problems than whether or not to use a splash!! As for humidity, I'd like to know just how that affects the countertop, especially so that a splash will help!! This is out and out BS, and it's not even a good attempt at sounding professional!!

    The REAL problem doesn't come from settling or humidity. It comes from movement of the cabinets from leaning, banging against them, setting weight on top of them, etc., and it doesn't matter whether that 4" splash is there or not. If the joint's not caulked where the granite meets the wall, you're going to see that joint open up.

  • 18 years ago

    I had the 4 inch granite backsplash when we built our house.
    I took it out and did a travertine backsplash.
    I wish I had not ever had the granite backsplash installed as it was a waste of granite and money.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Bill, appreciate it, sure hope the person who wrote that thread sees your response.

  • 18 years ago

    I have already decided to nix the backsplash. Thanks Bill for clearing it up for me!

  • 18 years ago

    I'll put it on your tab. :-)

0
Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations