Software
Houzz Logo Print
sallymo2015

Fireplace: paint it or box it in?

15 years ago

Obviously this room is in the stages of moving, but look closely and you'll see nice wooden beams and a brick floor. The shelving beside the fireplace is nothing to write home about, but the plan is to paint it and the trim (not beams) Navajo White (SW) and the paneled walls Macadamia (SW) or at 75% Macadamia. The fireplace has an odd paint technique that we despise. The painter knows all the ins and outs of painting this monster, so we aren't worried about that.

Is it worth painting or should she wait and do a total rebuild over this thing?

Comments (27)

  • 15 years ago

    Paint. Paint. and keep Painting. :)

    Now. Now. and yes -- Now! :)

    What a HUGE change that will make in the whole space!!

  • 15 years ago

    I have to admit, I like the brick on the fireplace BUT with the competing brick flooring, it just doesn't work. So, my vote would be to paint it.

  • 15 years ago

    Don't make a rash decision yet on your FP. Paint the bookshelves first, then decide on what you want to do with the FP.

    The reason it may look bland to you is because the FP is basically the same color as the shelves. Beautiful bricks!

  • PRO
    15 years ago

    Oh no, the picture must be deceiving oakleyok, those bricks have a really ugly paint job, and are peeling on the sides. The painter will have to use a metal bristle brush before he begins, although the front and opposite side is not so bad.
    The dark color of the brick floor and that dark brown paint just sucks the life out of the room.

    So the consensus is that the fireplace could be somewhat charming if it's only painted and not a total redo?

  • 15 years ago

    Paint the bookshelves white.

    Use a split face travertine or marble or some other natural stone to veneer the fireplace.

  • 15 years ago

    Proceed with caution. Paint the bookshelves first. Wire brush the bricks and remove the peeling paint then decide what you want to do. If you use the fireplace you are going to have to think carefully about where you want to go with it. If it's never used just sits then you have more options.
    The big thing to me would be to get those bookcases painted and then see how you feel about the fireplace. Changing one thing in a room can sometimes change the way something else in the room looks. It may make the fireplace look more in tune , it may not but tackle one project at a time.

  • 15 years ago

    If it's going to be awhile before major work is done on the fireplace, paint it now so that you/she can enjoy the room. It shouldn't cost very much to clean/paint that fireplace.

    Live with it awhile after painting, then decide how to proceed.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree--paint the fireplace.

    I recently looked up the process. The method was to brush any surface dirt off, prime and paint with the same paints you'd use on a wall.

    You use a roller and a brush to get into the nooks and crannies, making sure you've taped off surrounding areas before starting.

    Don't let your painter fool you (with ALL the ins and outs)--it's easy to paint brick!

  • 15 years ago

    Paint!!!

  • 15 years ago

    Here's a recent posting from the wonderful blog "Cote de Texas" about the Power of (white) Paint! :)

    Jan at rosemary Cottage

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cote de Texas blog posting -- All in White Family

  • 15 years ago

    Well, I totally thing the natural brick looks much better than the white in that blog, especially after she made everything else white, it really pops against the brick! As for OP, if the brick is already painted, then I certainly would not feel bad painting it again.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree about that brick featured in the blog. It was so pretty left natural and added some warmth and interest in the room. The sun-room was much better before too. Personally I wouldn't want to spend much time in that house.

    As far as the brick the OP asked about...paint it. Will certainly allow the wood and the brick floors to be more noticeable.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm usually against painting brick, and I agree with those who say that the room in the blog looked much better with the brick left unpainted, but Sallymo, I would paint the brick on your fireplace in a minute. I really think the room will look much better.

    I would paint the fireplace first, and then do a reassess. As in then decide on painting the shelving. I would make a decision regarding painting the paneling last, after fireplace and maybe shelving painted.

  • 15 years ago

    Here's another page of eye candy and inspiration!

    Enjoy!

    Jan at Rosemary Cottage

    Here is a link that might be useful: Another gorgeous blog with white painted brick

  • 15 years ago

    Sally, I didn't know the brick was already painted. I say point it too if you want.

    The FP (and room) in the first blog looks like it was dunked in plaster. Cold cold room.

    The FP in the 2nd blog is a bit better because there's some contrast in the brick.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow, that's one UGLY fireplace.

    Definitely paint it, leaving the mantel unpainted. And a nice contrast behind the shelves on either side would balance the visual bulk of the FP.

    If you want a bigger mantel, all you have to do is make a wooden box to cover the original mantel, just thicker and wider.

  • PRO
    15 years ago

    lazygardens, I like your idea of just making a larger mantel. I had suggested that she not paint the small one that is there, but making it larger might be easier than boxing over the whole thing (or I know it would be). It would help reduce the large amount of brick. Also, the shelves will be white and the paneled wall behind a different color. The painter will do it all at once, as he can prime, fill in nail holes in the paneling, etc, and it will take him 3 days most likely. The owner is having it done while on a vacation so she won't have to live in such a mess as she did with her recent kitchen redo.

    I'll post an after picture when it is done. Then we could decide whether or not to beef up the mantel.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh my gosh that is the funniest faux painted fireplace I've ever seen. I mean it looks just like it's made out of wicker! LOL Too funny. I can see why they want to change it.
    Speaking of wicker, I have that that wicker shelf, only I painted mine white.

  • 15 years ago

    When I painted the unattractive wood paneling wall surrounding my brick fireplace, it made the fireplace stand out in a bad way! It showed me clearly that the mantel was all wrong and the proportions were all wrong.

    I ended up putting a traditional wood surround around the brick fireplace. I was considering tiling the remaining exposed brick, or leaving it as-is, but I eventually painted it.

    If you want to see some pictures, check out this thread:

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/decor/msg071748377774.html

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not sure I'd paint it. Maybe try to "unpaint" it first and see what you've got. And do that before you change the shelves on the sides as wendyb suggested. Oh and the rug in front is not helping matters imho.

  • PRO
    15 years ago

    Please ignore the rug and everything else in there, as it is just out of the way for other projects that were ongoing when I took that picture. The idea of removing the paint was suggested by the homeowner, until she saw the brick under the bad faux paint, and it was not good! wendyb is probably right about the mantel being a wrong proportion.

  • PRO
    15 years ago

    I always appreciate everyone's follow-up so I want to do the same. The homeowner decided to paint the fireplace, keep a casual look for this "den". The white is Navajo, and the wall color is from Behr, but I don't have the name at the moment (so partial follow-up, I guess).
    The painter just finished and things are not in place. New furniture is next, and some type of area rug to warm up the brick floor. I don't know how this picture will translate, but in person it has a real cottage appeal, feels twice as big, and is a big hit with everyone involved.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow!!! Wonderful transformation -- fresh and light and very charming!

    Thanks for the update!!!! :)

  • 15 years ago

    It looks great, thanks for the "after".

  • 15 years ago

    Great change! Looks like a different space.

    There are two things I might consider in addition. I would have painted the wall above the bookcases in the same color as the bookcases, to take the eye up to the beam and match the fireplace height. I think having that little wall area in the other color chops up the wall space.

    I would box in the mantel so that it was at least as wide as the beam above it, but leave it stained as it is now. I think it will break up the brick a bit, and also balance the weight of the beam overhead.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, the magic of paint!! That looks much better! That's a great idea that Les suggested about the mantle.

    I covet that brick flooring. We bid on a house that had the living room floor done with brick, and it looked very cool. Actually, the whole house was cool, but it wasn't meant to be.

  • 15 years ago

    I'd do the backs of the bookcase in the wall color or even a shade or 2 darker.
    This does look soooo much better that the original pic! Good call on leaving the touches of wood stained.