I would vote for seating on more than one side of the island. Otherwise conversation is difficult when everyone is seated in a row. My friends and I always end up around the island even when there is a perfectly good table a few feet away.

I would put garbage near each sink. That's where things get cleaned up. What are you doing for your corner sink? I've got one I don't know what to do with.

Is it me or if the fridge wall different in the two drawings? Built in?

I envy your pantry, but it's a little far away.

Great space. I'd love to have that much room!

I agree with all the comments suggested by Mugsy42. I especially agree with the comment about the island seating.

My only comment would be - have you allowed yourself enough room with the sink in the corner? Have you considered placing the sink along one of the walls rather than the corner?

I'd shift the prep sink to the right so it's more toward the end thereby giving you more uninterrupted prep counter. Also better for RF landing.

When I look at the plan it appears you have full depth RF. I'd go with the 3D counterdepth or built-in energy star if possible.

I have a corner sink now, and find that we all collide at the sink, and neither person has a good reach into it. I am changing the layout when we do a renovation sometime later this year, and we will locate the sink along one wall. Seems you have way more windows. For your reference, my kitchen + eating area is 12.5 x 22.5. Good luck! And see my link below if you'd like to compare. We are nearly final, but not quite!

Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Layout Review Link