Software
Houzz Logo Print
pugrolls

Have to 'Settle' on Countertops

16 years ago

At long last, the cabinets are in and I am responsible for the hold-up on the kitchen progress at this moment. It's time to install countertops and can't seem to find my rock! I had been waiting for a white granite I was very excited about to arrive from Italy. Well, it's in, and it's GORGEOUS, and it's over twice my countertop budget. Figures.

So, back I went to the drawing board. Put on my sneakers and spent hours...and hours...and HOURS walking up and down aisles in stone yards. I've been to every stone yard in the area -- more than once -- and I can't seem to fall in love with anything that I can afford. Apparently everything I love is in the "D+" price range when I need to be falling in love with something in the "A" or "B" range. Champagne taste on a beer budget, I tell you! My heartbreak of the day was falling in love with Quartzite Bianca -- Sochi's stone -- only to find out what it costs. Sigh.

DH has ants in his pants and want me to "just pick something"! I hate the idea of dropping several thousand dollars for something I just "like" rather than "love," but it appears that I've looked at all of my options and am out of time.

Thanks for letting me whine.

Comments (24)

  • 16 years ago

    SOOOOO feel your pain. Same thing happened here. Fell in love w/ crystal ice quartzite and it was over twice the countertop budget. Tried to work it in as a 2 cm slab as a backsplash, still no dice. Went with our second choice a carrara marble (gioia alta) with the granite guard upgrade to reduce staining (which priced out equal to a level 3 granite). Now that I'm shopping backsplash, etc. I do love the marble. My second option, which I seriously considered, was to put plywood or a home depot DIY formica till I could save up for the quartzite. Best of luck, I'm sure you'll find something you like!

  • 16 years ago

    I have no answers, but am so sorry about your predicament. I know how you feel. I actually have a tap water budget, and everything seems like a champagne budget to me! ;-) And so many things at our house seems to need repair or replacement these days... And I really hate spending a lot of money on something that doesn't do everything I wanted it to.

    Are the counters supposed to be the star of your kitchen? Can you put a little more oomph into the backpslash if the counters aren't your first love? Can you try not to compare stones when looking at the yards, so you can allow the beauty of each to show itself to you? I remember stone shopping with my sister (I went with laminate for ours), and she was so stressed, while I could see that once you got one stone in your house and installed on the counters, it would be amazing and beautiful, no matter which it was. It was when they were all standing next to each other that it creates the problem of choosing and comparing.

    Kashmir White or Bianco Romano don't thrill you? Maybe honed or satin if you don't like them polished? Those are the 2 whites I remember liking, and I think they weren't in the expensive range. I truly hope that next time you go to the yards, that a wonderful A or B just jumps out at you and you can be excited about this major purchase.

  • 16 years ago

    I feel your pain, I do but IMHO, you really have to look at the prices BEFORE you even start looking at the products and making your opinions. :-(

    This is how my wife and I got through our kitchen planning. She would walk through Home Depot and look at the prices *before* even considering if she could like the products or not. She said it helped not get her heart broken. Also, she said that she didn't consider anything set in stone until it was installed.

    Good luck finding your perfect white stone! :-)

  • 16 years ago

    I got an idea from a beautifully restored Tudor house where I was a "guide" on a local historical tour. The kitchen had gorgeous calacatta marble around the sink and range but in other areas, the marble was used as inserts and surrounded by wood. The combination of the wood and marble was very pleasing and more interesting to my eye than continuous slabs of marble. But of course, this was a 1920's house and the kitchen was restored in keeping with its vintage period look. The concept has taken hold and I think I am going to combine marble and wood too: marble as a bib around the apron sink and for the island and wood elsewhere. I know this won't be appealing to a lot of people but it does seem to work well in some instances. It also enables me to look at those Class D marbles. Just a thought.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Pugrolls,
    I really feel for your predicament but I've always been able to see how the best and most beautiful things are born within limitations. Nothing gets creativity flowing like a limit.
    To expand on Sayde's idea, do you have an island? I ask because maybe you could consider getting "your" granite or something similar as an island top and something less expensive on the perimeter?
    I also know how it feels to hold up progress by being unable to settle on anything. I did this with our bathroom tile. I pressured myself so bad that I would stand paralyzed and unable to make a decision in the tile stores. My husband told me one day, "if you don't pick something today, don't come home." lol.
    Best of luck to you, hope you fall in love with something in your kitchen. If not the counters, maybe the backsplash?

  • 16 years ago

    I agree will rookie's post above. That's what I and others have done to stay somewhat in a budget, mix it up if you can. Do get plywood tops until you find something. There is no point in spending all that money for a kitchen and then not liking it.

  • 16 years ago

    IKEA has some nice wood counters that you can stain to whatever shade you like. By saving so much, you can then splurge, as suggested above, on an island or section of counter with the stone you are in love with. There may be a remnant that you can pick up for a bargain since you would not be needing a full kitchen's worth.
    Down the road, you can always replace the wood with more stone. The IKEA wood counters would function better than plywood and be cheap enough not to kill you to take out later.
    I'd also make sure the fabricator knew to let you know (after a certain date, such as a year or 2) when there would be any leftovers in your stone from other jobs. You would not have a deadline and by being flexible you will get the best deals.
    If you don't go with your first choice in stone at all now, could you get a scrap made into a cutting board or trivet, just to have around?

  • 16 years ago

    For your perimeter, or smaller areas, perhaps there are remnants of expensive stone in some yards. Then you could go with the stone you're crazy about in the "spotlight" area of your kitchen. There have been some posters here who have loved their Hi-Macs counters....maybe something you see as "temporary only" could work. Good luck, and keep us up to date!

  • 16 years ago

    I don't know where you live but in Seattle we have all the regular granite shops and then we have oodles of Chinese places that do direct import for about 1/2 the price. And you can save even more if you get the pre-cut counter depth pieces - some run just $200 per 9'. I wonder if you could do the perimeter with the cheaper stuff (as above) but still in granite. I'm surprised by how many granite choices these little shops have - almost everything Pental and the other stores do. My niece did their whole brand new kitchen and island for only $1,800 and that include the sink.

  • 16 years ago

    I'll throw out a different perspective. Is this your "forever" kitchen? If so, then think long and hard about splurging on the granite you really want - it will make you happy for a long, long time and in a few years you won't even remember how much you splurged on it. Scrimp elsewhere if you have to.

  • 16 years ago

    Depending on your layout, if you don't have a long run, the remnant idea is a great one! Also, some yards will discount if they are down to one slab because most jobs require more material than that. Don't rush your decision. Plywood will suffice until your stone finds you. Check out yards further from home. Ours came from a yard four hours away. It was one of the first three we looked at before thousands of others. It ate at me for months until we decided. No regrets - it was worth the extra cost, time and wait.

  • 16 years ago

    Like you, I also could not stand to spend thousands and feel like I was settling/wouldn't be happy anyway. That will never feel like a good return on your investment.

    I have this philosophy that everything can't be the "star" in your kitchen. Do you already have another star/stars or would your countertops be your star? Would that help you feel better about spending for them?

    I was going to say what weissman already did-if you really love it, scrimp somewhere else to make room for it.

    Could your husband get on board with making a compromise on something else to find some more money for your countertop budget? Cheaper faucets/lighting/hardware/any tasks left that you could DIY?

    My father is a serial remodeler and after urging me not to buy this fixer upper-advice I wish in hindsight that I heeded-he gave me just one piece of advice: you will never think for one minute about the money you saved if in the end everyday you are looking at something you don't like.

    At the end of the day, those finish choices are precisely why you are doing the remodel. Finding something you love that you will get to enjoy every day.

    If you get what you love, I think the pain of spending whatever sum of money will go away much more quickly than if you spend almost that much to get something you really don't like.

    Disclaimer-I am justifying this identical decision as just this afternoon I heard back from the fabricator that the marble I really love came in at fully double the price I expected! Crushing. I feared something like this and like you have been all over town diligently trying to find something else. However, in a sea of indecision and second-guessing myself at every turn during this exhausting remodel, there is finally something that I LOVE and it is this marble. And I will spend more for it and I hope my dad is right that the initial pain of spending more than I planned will be vastly outweighed by having one thing that I love to greet me in my new kitchen each day. :)

  • 16 years ago

    I almost settled for granite that I liked but not thrilled about. The granite I chose (which gets installed tomorrow - woohoo!) was $2K more than the other so I compromised by not getting a new range this year. I'll live with my old white electric coil range for another year until I can afford a new smooth-top range. And maybe even be able to afford induction. So maybe you could compromise something else for awhile and then upgrade that item later on. That's the one thing about building (or remodeling I guess) is that its so hard to say I can't have EVERYTHING I want. But not everything matters as much. Does that make sense?

    If this is your final house - I say get what you want when it comes to things that are "permanent" and hold off on things you can upgrade later.

  • 16 years ago

    PUgrolls-
    I haven't read all the responses above, but I wanted to offer this (and if someone already suggested it, I apologize)

    I had the same predicament when we were building our house. The kitchen was the room I spent the most time on and neglected the rest of the house. I REALLY wanted Typhoon Bordeaux throughout my kitchen, however, it would have put me over budget by about $3000. I was having an island installed so what i ended up doing was using absolute black on my perimeter countertops and typhoon bordeaux on my island.

    Now i didn't love this idea, but my husband wouldn't budge with going over budget and this was the only way i could get my TB granite. I do love the look (although I REALLY wish i had got it honed instead of polished)...

    So are you having an island? Is there anyway you can do some of the granite you Love then pull another color from it with one of the lower priced granites and put that in the rest of the kitchen? JUst an idea..

    Good luck!!

  • 16 years ago

    Pugrolls --

    There are SO many of us that are in the same position as you.

    I am not even redoing my entire kitchen and I totally have had to compromise on what I really want.

    It started out as wanting new countertops and a new backsplash, and I really wanted quartz for the countertops. I priced out a few different colors (group A colors through group E colors for Zodiaq; Cambria colors are all one price; also priced out Hanstone and Caesarstone), on the low end was around $3300 for a color I didn't *love* to (gulp) $5000 for the color I loved. When DH heard that he said No Way! (especially to the $5K one)

    I then started researching other options - granite (not crazy about it), solid surface/Corian, and laminate (which we currently have). Decided to try laminate since I really don't like solid surface or granite.

    The last month or two, I feel like I have ordered every sample from WilsonArt and Formica. There's a few colors I like, but none I LOVE. DH has seen how frustrating it has been for me and he knows I am really trying to keep the cost down. What I think we are going to do is get quartz on the island and laminate on the perimeter. If I can never upgrade to quartz on the perimeter, I would be OK with that.

    My point is that most of us here understand the frustration you're going through. I think going w/the countertop you love - even if it is only in small bits - is a great way to compromise.

  • 16 years ago

    I have sochi's quartize bianca. I don't know what your budget is but I paid $80 sq/ft in May after taxes and cutouts and everything. I thought that was a mid-range stone price.

    Because my fabricator was very open with me, she showed me her correspondence with the stone yard where I found the stone, the slabs were sold to her at $30 sq/ft. Actually there was another yard that offered it to her in the mid $20s but I didn't like the veining on those slabs cos they weren't consistently straight enough.

    She told me I would've gotten a better price if I didn't go with the most expensive stone yard.

  • 16 years ago

    padola07- wow, that's a good price for quartzite . Where are you located?

  • 16 years ago

    I am in New York but I found my stone in New Jersey. I used Atlas Marble and Granite as the fabricator and the slab was sourced from Arena Stone.

    Basically I had 72 sq ft of kitchen and fireplace to do. Delivered and installed I paid $5995 but I had about $300-$400 in pricey mitered edges. So the stone installed and sink cutout alone came to about $80 sq ft. She had to get 2 slabs for my work so that didn't help my price cos most of the second slab was waste.

    I forgot to add that Rigdefield Marble or Marble.com came in at around $12000 for their quote. I could've given up at that point but I was determined to get that stone so I literally called up every stone yard in NJ.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks so much for the kind words, support, and advice everyone. This forum is so great! :)

    We have white wall cabinets in an L-shape with an espresso island in the middle of an overall 11x11 space. We need 51.5 square feet of countertop. The way we envisioned it, our countertops would indeed be the "star" of the kitchen. I had been toying with the idea of splurging on the island surface, but given that our cabinets are two different colors, DH is really set on having one countertop surface to unify the kitchen.

    rhome, I too really like Bianco Romano and Kashmir White, and I think we could afford them, but DH doesn't like the red dots in them (he thinks they look like blood drops). I'll probably try him again if I find pretty slabs of them though, now that we know the prices of the other stuff.

    I had been thinking about going with a sparkly white quartz and letting the backsplash become the star of the kitchen, but for whatever reason DH thinks that quartz doesn't "look high end," and he wants the countertops to look high end. Still, I think they look very nice, and it's a very popular surface where I live, so I may try to work that angle with DH.

    Speaking of quartz, chocolatebunny, Costco offers a pretty great deal on Caesarstone if you are a member. Also, several stone yards in Seattle offer their own brands of quartz surfaces that are far cheaper than the ones you can get at the big box stores. Something to look into, anyway, if you haven't considered that already.

    brittu, I'm actually also in Seattle, and I'm familiar with the places you're talking about. We had been holding out for 3 cm stone so we wouldn't have a seam on the edge, but maybe it is time to reconsider 2 cm.

    padola07, that is a screaming good deal on your Quartzite Bianca. I got quotes from two different fabricators in Seattle, which averaged out to $130 and $150 per square foot, respectively. Just ridiculous! I may go back to the stone yard today to try to get a sense of who is trying to benefit from the ridiculous mark-up.

    All of this said, this ISN'T our forever home. I try to keep that in mind when I find myself obsessing over the kitchen. Still, in this market, who knows? We may be here a long, long time. :p

    Thanks again for the thoughts and kind words!

  • 16 years ago

    In my own opinion, the most lovely material for countertops is granite, class 3. The fact that it is beautiful and tough, it complements almost all kitchen designs. I think you will love it as well. Just sharing... :D

    Here is a link that might be useful: In Stock Kitchens

  • 16 years ago

    Go for what you love and do not settle for anything less. Your kitchen is the heart of your home. We splurged on ours ($120 sq ft) and we calculated it would cost us $450.00 per year. I can live with that!

  • 16 years ago

    Pugrolls -- I did price out Caesarstone through Costco and actually got a cheaper price for Hanstone through a local company. I have been told there is really no difference in the quartz companies, just the colors.

    I too have approx. 52 sq ft of countertops and wanted them to be the star.

    FWIW, I did price out 2cm quartz and in some cases it cost more than the 3cm. For my job I needed 1 & 1/2 slabs and in certain brands they only sell full slabs, so I would have been paying for 2 even though there would be a lot of waste. It may be different for granite, but just to let you know.

    When we were on vacation the place we stayed at had 2cm countertops and I thought they looked fine. I can't imagine the average joe would notice the difference between 2cm and 3cm tops. All they would notice is the granite.

    I like Danille's idea of calculating the cost per year. Clever!

  • 16 years ago

    chocolatebunny, thanks for the info. I'd actually never heard of Hanstone; I think you're right that there's not much difference between Quartz products other than colors.

    I'll have to try Danielle's cost calculation too and see how far that gets me. :)

  • 16 years ago

    I am in the South End of Seattle and am also starting to research granite. I see FineLine Pacific fabricator has some good reviews. My cabinet installer also told me about Orca in Puyallup, they are a small family owned company. I also was looking at the granite through Costco but they are very limited in selection. I plan to go to Pental and Cosmos slab yards in Fife to look around.