Software
Houzz Logo Print
wklink99

Kitchen Island alternatives

12 years ago

We are working on the layout of our new kitchen and would like to seek your advice on the island size.

The kitchen is a "[" shaped and about 18 x 11. The breakfast area is adjacent to kitchen and about 18 x 8 so the total area for the kitchen & breakfast area is 18 x 19. No matter what size of island that we end up with, the walking space between island and the back of the chairs for the table will be quite narrow. Nevertheless, we are contemplating two options:

1. Build a 2x7 island with a 3' counter top. We are unlikely to use it as a place to eat.

2. Build a 4x7 island with no overhang. This idea is to maximize the storage provided by the island and we could put flatware in the drawers which will be easily accessible from the breakfast table.

What do you think? Which option do you prefer? Thanks!

Comments (10)

  • 12 years ago

    Do you have a preliminary design of layout?

  • 12 years ago

    If I'm visualizing right--which I may not be--why don't you do the wider island and put a bench against it on the breakfast side for banquette seating? It solves the problem of the narrow clearance for pulling out chairs.

    Or forego the island and embrace the wacky, old-fashioned idea of a kitchen table. Islands aren't always the best solution.

  • 12 years ago

    It'd be helpful to see a floor plan.

    18' is a long enough stretch to fit a counter against one wall (2' deep), then a generous walk way (5' deep), then a generous island (6' deep), then another generous walkway (5' deep) and then the other wall.

  • 12 years ago

    Here's a sketch of the layout.

  • 12 years ago

    Is that a wall on the right side of the breakfast area...or an opening to another room? If you have a wall, maybe a banquette would work. You could put the banquette against the wall, with the table and chairs on three sides. This should give you room for seating at the island, too :)

  • 12 years ago

    why don't you built a 3 foot deep island with 24 inch cabs backing up to 12 inch cabs? My parents have that and the storage is very useful.

  • 12 years ago

    I'd say you definitely don't need seating at the island with a table two steps away. The is no function it could add that the table isn't already providing.

    I don't actually think this u-shaped kitchen in its current shape is a particularly good candidate for an island.

    What lack in your kitchen is pushing you towards wanting an island? More storage? More counterspace? Separation from the breakfast nook? A feeling like the space isn't used well?

  • 12 years ago

    I would suggest a couple of things:

    1) while I agree that no seating is necessary when you have a table that close, sometimes its nice to just have a couple of stools for "perching", especially if you have small children.

    2) I'd make your 3'6" aisles wider and the island shorter.

    3) I like the idea of 24" cabinets backed by 12" cabinets, unless you really don't need the storage. Its what we have (our island is 10', 5' of which is taken up by regular 12" deep cabinets, and 5' of which is an overhang for two stools).

  • 12 years ago

    Use a kitchen table. Islands are whacko.

  • 12 years ago

    What's to the right of the Breakfast Table? Windows? Wall? Door?

    What about above/below the table? (They look like doorways.)

    Do you have a separate Dining Room? Is it close by?

    If you don't have seating at the island then you don't need quite as wide an aisle.


    We need the above information as well to give you options.


    [Edited to add FAQ link]

    Here is a link that might be useful: FAQ: How do I ask for Layout Help and what information should I include?

    This post was edited by buehl on Thu, Sep 25, 14 at 19:45