Software
Houzz Logo Print
i_m_fletcher

Sanity Check - Marble Selection and Prices

16 years ago

I was hoping someone here could take a look at our preliminary set of choices around Marble for our kitchen and let us know what you think of the stone and the prices we've been quoted. From my perspective, the stone is spectacular and the prices seem high - but I'd like to get a few independent reactions from the experts here.

The piece of board in the images is our cabinet color - BM Ivory.

First candidate:

5cm Cararra Bianco

Cost: $120 / Sq Ft installed.

Second Candidate:

3cm Calacatta Ruggine

Cost: $183 / Sq Ft

Third Candidate:

5cm Calacatta Manhattan

Cost: $258 / sq ft!

So... big question: Which do you like best? Are these prices at all reasonable? Includes ~43sq ft with 17 ft of pencil edge and allows for one undermount double bowl sink. These prices are for a fabricator near Boston.

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    Love the 5cm Manhatten!

  • 16 years ago

    i_m_fletcher:
    I believe you will have a hard time getting fair comparisons on the price - the 5cm thickness is unusual. I know Houston is not Boston, but the usual in the Houston market is 2 cm - or 3 cm at the most. Is there a reason to pay a higher price for thicker stone?

  • 16 years ago

    Buy the 5cm Manhatten and have them slice it into 2 x 2.5 cm slabs, then the cost drops by half ;)
    Seriously though, you are not in a one horse or one yard area. You need to shop around and let them know you will.

  • 16 years ago

    We used the Calacatta Ruggine in our Lake house with Cherry Cabinets, we loved this marble - the people who purchased our home, really liked it, also! What will your cabinets look like, perhaps I missed that description? If we did not just find this green Soapstone, we may have selected this Calacatta Marble, again! And we may still want to use some of this for a back splash detail! I agree with dianalo, you may want to look around and tell each one that you are trying to get the marble into your plans but you can only use one of them for the final purchase!! Let us know, what you find! roseofblue

  • 16 years ago

    I vote for the Manhattan!

    But wow, 5cm?! The norm here in CA seems to be 2cm. You do get a seam, but don't you kind of need an overhang on the edge anyway? Does 5cm make your edge have to be at least 3 inches or so?

  • 16 years ago

    I vote forth ruggino. that does sound high but it is 5cm.

  • 16 years ago

    I did 5cm Calacatta Oro about 3 years ago and paid $235/sq ft just outside of Boston so your Manhattan price seems right. With our new kitchen (we've moved), I'm doing a Statuario Venetino in 3cm and am paying $149/sq ft so, again, your pricing seems dead on.

    Obviously, I'm a marble fan and as much as they are all beautiful, my vote for one of your three goes with the Manhattan :)

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with dianolo... you should shop around and LET THEM KNOW YOU ARE. I'm in Maine but I shopped for my marble in the Boston area. I got pricing from everyone for similar stones, and then, when I'd chosen my slab, used the lower quotes from their competitors to get the price lowered to match.

    I actually like the Calacatta Rugine best, but I totally agree with the "why 5cm" chorus..... it's still going to look amazing at 3 cm and cost a whole lot less. If this yard doesn't have any Calacattas in 3 cm, keep looking. Most do. (Unless you are really counting on the extra-thick edge, which is definitely an extra-luxe detail....)

    FWIW, I paid less than $80/sf installed for my 3 cm honed Cararra counters, and the MA guys had to travel to Maine to template and install it! (May 2009)

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks everyone - sharing your experiences is most helpful for me. When you suggest shopping around, are you referring to stoneyards or fabricators? Things could get quite busy if I'm going to try different stoneyards and fabricators.

    We had originally been interested in the 5cm slabs as we were going to use it on our island. We really like to look of a thick heavy island top. We revised our original plan to use marble on the island and we've decided upon a 2" thick top made of mahogany. We were thinking the marble on the perimeter should be a similar thickness. After doing some research, it seems that many people use countertops with varying thicknesses in the kitchen. From the limited number of images I've seen, this looks nice. Does anyone have any thoughts about pairing a 2" thick wood island with 1.25" thick perimeter counters? Is this ok? Assuming this isn't an issue, we are going to consider more 3cm slabs - which are not only less expensive, but are far more available.

    Like many of you, I was really struck by the Calacatta Manahattan. However, I'm not sure we're ready to spend over $11k on the perimeter counters. At the same time, the Calacatta Reggine was the warmest and seemed to compliment our cabinets the best. Also, this stone has a slight translucency which really adds to the beauty - you can slightly see it in the pictures, but it is much more prevalent in person. At this point, I think we're leaning towards the Calacatta Reggine - but I'd love to hear more thoughts! It is pretty humorous that many folks go with Calacatta "gold" and we're considering a stone that translates to Calacatta "rust"! You would think rust would be much cheaper than gold... =)

    Roseofblue - our cabinets will be BM Ivory. The island will be topped with 2" thick mahogany and we were planning on marble for the perimeter. In a seperate adjoining pantry area, we intend to use soapstone - but we haven't gotten to that section yet. Thanks for the inquiry.

  • 16 years ago

    Fletch, I like #1 or #2 the best. Your carrara example looks like what we're getting out here in CA--fairly grey with sharper veining than I see in older Carrara installations.
    I like the look of a 2" edge and fabricators are all telling me you can do a 2 or 3" mitered edge on a 2cm slab and it will look the same as getting a thick slab.
    As far as price, your numbers are eye watering. In the L.A. area, yards are charging anywhere from $11-$16/sf for 2cm Carrara. 2cm Calacatta ranges from the high 20s to high 40s/sf with one yard having an $80/sf slab.
    Fabricating costs have been quoted in the $25-$35/sf range.

  • 16 years ago

    Our cherry island top is thicker than our Cararra perimeter counters, and it looks great!

    Also, now that I hear you are doing mahogany as well, I definitely vote for the Calacatta Rugine! I think the red/brown in it will look wonderful with the mahogany.

    Can you get a piece of mahogany finished the same as your island top will be, and take it around to look at slabs? I think that would be very helpful.

    Also... some of the MA stone places (like Gerrity) are fabricators as well as have large slab warehouses. But if you're also considering fabricators who don't have their own inventories, I guess you will need to do multi-phase shopping: first go to 3 or 4 of the big stone yards and choose 3 or 4 marbles you love. Then get pricing from 3 or 4 fabricators. Because don't you pay the fabricator for everything..... you don't buy the slab from the warehouse yourself, right, it's through the fabricator...??? At least that is how it works with the fabricators around here. I asked them which yards they normally get their slabs from, and they named 3 or 4 in the Boston area, then I went down and looked at slabs there.

  • 16 years ago

    My heart skipped a beat when I saw #2. That's my vote!!!