Software
Houzz Logo Print
missmuffet_gw

Which cabinets work with this floor best?

16 years ago

Can you help me figure out which cabinets work with my flooring best? I am keeping a dark oak floor in my greatroom which is now right in front of the kitchen island. The kitchen may have tile - depending on the cabinets . . .

The cabinet style I'm going with is Starmark's Brekenridge, as I like the traditional hearty look. The two colors are the butterscotch stain or a combination of painted white with a dark island. They both have their finer points and their drawbacks. The butterscotch is rich and beautiful but a bit orange. I would love to use it, but I can't figure out what granite or paint I would choose (DH and kids prefer this one). On the other hand, the white painted cabinets with a dark island would be elegant and traditional, but I have white cabinets now and every chip or smudge makes me nuts (I like a tidy kitchen). So here are two pictures of the cabinets I'm considering along with the floor (please look past the renovation dust). The smaller doors are both in the Breckenridge style - the dark one has a decorative edge that I'm leaning toward. The larger door is the butterscotch stain in another style.

Please note this is not a question of whether you like stain or painted cabinets best - I know we could talk about that for years. Rather, it is a question of what would you do if you were starting out with floors like mine (and were keeping them).

">

and

">

Comments (39)

  • 16 years ago

    I prefer the darker stained cabinets, but the butterscotch is a nice contrast with your floor. Is your kitchen well lighted?

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, the kitchen has great light - both natural and electric. By my table is a sliding door and a window, and above the cabinets is a half moon window. There are also windows on the other wall. Actually, the natural lighting has been the most rewarding part of this renovation.

    I guess I fear that the dark cabinets with a dark floor will start to feel like a cave - even with good lighting?

  • 16 years ago

    Yep, I know what you mean about that cave feeling, but I would have trouble working with the Butterscotch. And have seen some finished kitchens with comparable finishes and just haven't liked them even though they're well done otherwise. There are no other options?

  • 16 years ago

    Your floors are spectacular and I love the butterscotch finish with them. I think it will look so rich yet evoke a casual elegance. I can think if countless stones that would look beautiful with it; I wouldn't go too dark, medium tone. The first that came to mind was Yellow River.

  • 16 years ago

    I guess I'm the oddball - frankly I just don't like the butterscotch. It looks "off" to me. But I do love the distressed cream. That really pops for me. And it could set off some beautiful granites.

  • 16 years ago

    Jilljohn - The only other light stains are natural or honey, and I don't think either of them evoke the right mood for this house. As you can see from the floor - the house has a pretty strong sense of who "she" is. So for Starmark (or many of the other brands I've looked at), it is a butterscotch or paint. As for the paint, I like either white with a dark island - or maybe a light gray.

    remodelfla - interesting that you wouldn't go with a dark counter. I was thinking that maybe I HAD to go with a dark brown. Hmmmm.

  • 16 years ago

    I love the floors you are keeping. Beautiful!
    I actually lean toward the white because I love that look.
    However, I hear from your post that you are leaning toward
    the "The traditional hearty look", and I think the
    butterscoth would give this feeling. The darker cabinet
    could also do this too. When you do searches of kitchen
    you rarely find the butterscotch cab with a dark floor. I
    am not sure why but perhaps this is not as popular.
    Since I have not helped you with your choice, I will post
    some links and images so you can do a little homework to
    see what you love the most.

    ~boxerpups


    old GW links that show kitchen with
    wood floors and medium cabs.
    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg1008512413949.html?4

    GW Show me your dark wood kitchen
    http://www.thathomesite.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0222301811981.html

    This counter looks amazing with the dark floors or dark
    cabinets.

    Sopravich

    Notice the dark countertops. This looks great!

    I think if you photoshopped a darker color on the floors
    this might give you a nice "hearty" look with the butterscotch.


    Gilliangham Cabinets

    This is more modern but the contrast is lovely
    with dark and medium stains. Corea Sotropa Designer

    Modern

    And here is a garden web google image of a butterscotch
    stain and dark wood floors.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dark Floors with Dark cabinets

  • 16 years ago

    First, let me say that I LOVE LOVE LOVE your floors! So beautiful and rich looking!

    If I understand your original post, only the island will be up against the dark wood floor? My preference would be for the island to be the distressed white. I understand what you mean about dirt, but the contrast in colors is so striking.

    If you go with a tile in the rest of the kitchen, then you could consider either of the other stained cabinets for the rest, and coordinate your tile accordingly. I think the lighter one gives a more casual, "country" feel, and the darker one is more traditional. It just depends on what your taste is.

    I'll try to attach a link to a pic of a sample kitchen.

    Good luck with your reno. I'm sure it will be beautiful!

    Here is a link that might be useful: White island

  • 16 years ago

    I like the butterscotch with your dark floors. I am not crazy about when someone has wood cabinets and tries to go similar as the wood floor. I think the fact that the woods are clearly different make them look better near each other. I'd rather have contrast that matchy matchy.

    I could even see a part of your counter being butcherblock stained in a dark tone such as the floor's color (but not all your counters in bb). I don't think you will have any trouble finding a nice stone to coordinate.

    The darker wood door color does not go at all with your floor.
    The light cab's glaze makes it look dirty to me (sorry, but dark glazes on white and off white make me want to break out a toothbrush and scrub the dark parts).

  • 16 years ago

    I Love the dark cabinets with the white one too. I'm not a big fan of the butterscotch ones. We just did our kitchen (well about 1 week from completion) and we have the darker cabinets around the kitchen and the light cream one in the island. The cabinets all have an expresso glaze on them so it coordinates well together with the dark hardwood floors. Our floors are maybe a shade or two lighter than yours, but I think it would great together. We get alot of light in our kitchen along with many lights, and it doesn't look cave-like at all.
    Hope this helps and good luck with your decision.

  • 16 years ago

    I like the butterscotch or white with that floor. The dark cabinet is just too close.

    Are you aware of the Starmark promotion that runs through Friday Oct 1st?

  • 16 years ago

    This probably won't help, as I'm an enthusiast for mixing woods, with their varied grains, tones and colors.

    You have a gorgeous floor, and all 3 of your prospective cabinets are lovely. I can imagine a beautiful kitchen built around any of the 3 doors. You will soften the combining of the woods/painted cabs with the other colors you use, the accessories you choose, etc. The floor/cab comparison will never appear as stark in your finished kitchen as they do now in your photo because the eye will have a much larger field of focus.

    I don't think you can go wrong with any of your options. So, it boils down to what you can best visualize as the kitchen you want to create.

  • 16 years ago

    Count my vote along with the others saying the dark cabinets and the dark floor together would be a little much. I would go for either white or the butterscotch (to my eyes it looks more like honey than butterscotch, but whatever). Before she scaled things back and decided to reface rather than remodel, my mom got a sample butterscotch door like that and we found marble and paint that looked great with it... unfortunately, I don't remember the names of either material. The paint was a Benjamin Moore in a cream tone--there were actually two shades, a slightly darker one for the walls and a lighter one for the ceiling. The granite was a really warm tan with swirls and flecks the exact color of the cabinet, and a much smaller number of some other flecks that were brown-black. It was really a lovely combination. If I can find out the name from her I'll let you know, but believe me, it was lovely, so I don't think you'd have a problem finding granite counters to go with it.

  • 16 years ago

    Another vote for the butterscotch. Think it has a rich look against your floor color.

  • 16 years ago

    The glazed white with the dark island would be my choice.

  • 16 years ago

    Wow, I really appreciate all of your comments and pictures! Thanks also for the great comments about the floor. You should see it when it's clean (drywall dust is killing me).

    Funny thing is, there isn't a clear winner. I guess I know why my inner voice so confused. Pretty nice problem to have after the months of renovation worries! I just wish I had a strong feeling one way or the other.

    Katsmah - thanks for the post on the Starmark promotion. My KD told me that it was extended until later this month, so I still have a bit of time to figure this out. I would like to settle on a choice though, so I can get my order started.

    Dianalo - My husband has objected to the glaze on the white cabinet as well. He really doesn't like it on any doors. It's a shame because I think it would help me tone down some of the options, but alas I guess he'll live here too.

  • 16 years ago

    Have you chosen your cabinets yet? The reason I'm asking is I'm also looking at Starmark cabinets (hopefully ordering within the next 2 weeks), and am trying to decide on a style and finish. I'm leaning towards the Accord door which looks just like the Brekenridge you have chosen. I will have a natural red oak floor (no stain), and am trying to find a cabinet stain that will complement the floor as well.

    My designer said his in-laws recently renovated their kitchen and chose the butterscotch stain. They have a natural oak floor as well, and he said it looked great.

    I have the same concern that the butterscotch kind of looks a bit too orange as well. My family doesn't like the off-white painted cabinets, and even though I like them, its hard to pick something that the family doesn't agree on. I've also heard that painted cabinets may chip easily. So, time will tell...

  • 16 years ago

    Trying to get this to the top...

  • 16 years ago

    Hi cindyinct.

    I've actually revisited the colors - finding that I couldn't make up my mind. I liked the Butterscotch, but just didn't think that I would be comfortable with the paint colors and counters that work with it. I prefer cool colors and I think it really begs for a warmer backdrop. It would be perfect for my mother (as these are the colors she loves), it just doesn't feel like my house. I also love the white with a dark island look, but didn't feel settled with it either.

    I now believe I'll use Honey with Chocolate Glaze. Funny but this is not the color that either my DH or I expected to like, but it is really nice and works with our floors. I had the KD order a door for me in the Brekenridge and a second in the Brekenridge with the decorator edge. As soon as I get them in the mail I'll finalize this decision. My hesitation is that the Glaze will "hang-up" differently on this style door and I won't like it as much as I did in the sample. If that is the case, I might reconsider the Brekenridge style (which I really love and is 15% cheaper right now). As you mentioned, the Accord is very similar to the Brekenridge so maybe it will be a finalist if I have to change door styles. Hopefully, I'll get the samples soon.

    Here are a few shots of the new color (the tall door is the one I'm leaning toward). Would love to hear thoughts . . . .

    ">
    ">

  • 16 years ago

    Still liking the butterscotch best. It is warmer and richer. The new choice looks a little washed out to me. It would be ok, but not my first choice.

  • 16 years ago

    What a coincidence. I've also been looking at the honey with chocolate glaze. Its really nice, but with my light floor, I'm not sure there would be enough contrast. You have to pay more for the glaze, but my designer said they do a really good job on both the glazes and painted finishes. He said the glazes are hand rubbed. I like all of your choices, it just boils down to what you and your family like best (or maybe just you!). Other options I'm considering are cherry oregano, and the off white painted/glazed. I may ask for my designer to order a door for me as well. Good idea.

  • 16 years ago

    The chocolate glaze makes the cabinets look as rich as your floor without competing or being "matchy matchy"...the effect will look gorgeous. The counters can be any color...if you like quartz, Cambria recently released some unique colors. Have fun with it and show us when its done, please!

  • 16 years ago

    I like your new choice. I think it's the chocolate glaze that helps it tie in with the floor better than the previous butterscoth did. But I also think the white/creamy look would look lovely as well.

  • 16 years ago

    I have a sample quartz countertop that looks good with the butterscotch as well as the honey chocolate glaze. Its Zodiaq Autumn Light. Here's the link: http://www.discovermarble.com/engineeredstone/zodiaq/autumnlight.htm.

    There's also many Cambria quartz colors that go very well - Brecon Brown, Burton Brown, Sutton and Stafford Brown. Here's the link: http://www.cambriausa.com/collection.cfm/all-colors.

  • 16 years ago

    bumping this post...

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks everyone! Those are quartz choices. I think I'll have to see the full slabs though. I don't make up my mind quickly (as you can see). Once I've got the sample door, I'll take it out to the dealers to see what looks best.

  • 16 years ago

    love the new colour best

  • 16 years ago

    You're not alone. I don't make up my mind quickly either....Its quite frustrating.... you don't want to know how long I've been thinking about renovating my kitchen. I'm hoping to get it done this time around.

  • 16 years ago

    .... Just wondering if your sample doors came in yet, and if so, what you decided?

  • 16 years ago

    Actually I just put in cabs in a cinnamon color (close to the butterscotch) with dark floors and it looks fantastic. I'm so happy with my choice. I like a patterned granite so used typhoon bordeaux with it. It picks up the colors of the cabinets, the floors, etc. I'm sorry but I don't have a picture of the floor right now as they are covered over since they are still finishing up the kitchen (and every other room.) I like the butterscotch cabs the best and for the same reason you do; I got tired of seeing every nick in white cabinets.

  • 16 years ago

    cindyinct - Thanks for asking, Yes my sample doors came in, but did not look like I had hoped. You can see a picture in the message titled Sloppy or 'To Be Expected' Glaze? (I'll try to post a link) I spoke to the KD and he is ordering me a sample in another style, so we'll see what that looks like. I'm also going to look at the Alder door in Ratan. I'm not sure that I'm ok with the Alder though - as I think they'll get destroyed around here. My DH is starting to think we need to look at other brands to get this right, but I'm not sure.

    cpartist - who is the maker of your cabs? I've been looking at many builders and I don't recognize the "cinnamon" color? Can you post a picture?

  • 16 years ago

    From your first choice of cab colors, I'd choose the cream and the darkest stain and try to incorporate both colors like picture number two that boxerpups posted. It would look fabulous, in my opinion!

  • 16 years ago

    So, for those of you that didn't see the doors that came in with the odd glaze, here are the pictures:


    They looked sloppy to me. The KD suggested that I try the stain in another style. So I ordered the Starmark maple door in the Accord style in honey with chocolate glaze. I also ordered an alder door in the Brekenridge with the ratan stain. Finally, I decided to open myself up to another brand and ordered a Kraftmaid maple door in the Englewood style in honey spice with mocha highlights. Here's a shot of the three doors:

    The door on the left is the alder door, the door on the right is the Kraftmaid door and the door in the middle is the maple Accord door. I'm leaning toward the Accord. It looks much better than the Brekenridge. What do you think?

    {{!gwi}}

  • 16 years ago

    The Accord is the door style that I mentioned to you earlier that I am ordering, or should I say plan on ordering soon. The glaze on the sample you posted looks really good. So..... have you decided on that door style and finish?

    Cindy

  • 16 years ago

    Don't like the one on the left at all. No personality. The one on the right is nice. Maybe a little stodgy, though.

    But the one in the middle is JUST RIGHT! Love it! Still love your floors, too!

  • 15 years ago

    So..... just curious if you've made a decision yet.

  • 15 years ago

    I went ahead and ordered the Starmark Accord in Honey with Chocolate Glaze. Feeling a bit of relief and a bit of anxiety. I hope I did the right thing, and won't regret not having white cabinets. You see I've started looking for granite, and I'm just not finding the perfect mate to this color. Most of the colors that look so nice with the doors, just aren't our style. So now a new search begins . . .

  • 15 years ago

    I think your choice looks beatiful!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks remodelfla, and thanks to everyone else that took the time to help me get through this decision. Your responses were greatly appreciated. I'll let you know how they look in a few weeks.