Software
Houzz Logo Print
rbsohio

problematic granite installation (long story)pt2

18 years ago

OOPS - I hit submit too soon - here's my entire post:

Well, my elation at seeing my new granite installed has faded fast:(. Much of this is my fault - when the installers arrived with the already cut pieces, I did not measure them. We had prior difficulty with them - when they came to template, they said they couldn't use our exact drawing - measurements were off,overhang would not be right, etc., etc. We then went to the shop, looked at their template on the granite, went home, and called them before fabrication took place to let them know we did not want them to cut the slabs as templated. We sent them a new drawing, with measurements, to address their concern over the original drawing, and asked that they come and re-template. Although they expressed concern over our drawing, they had us fax a signed copy, so that they would use it. Ultimately they declined to come and remeasure, saying, they "got it". As I said, at a glance, the slab in question looked to be the right shape, and I did not actually measure it when they got here.

From Kitchen progress
We love the granite, but are unhappy with this piece. We sent them this drawing to show the difference between what they did and what we had requested.The responded that our drawing would not have worked - which they didn't tell us beforehand. Like I said, they simply told us they "got it", when we asked if they could come and remeasure... Other aspects of the job seem a little sloppy, but we can live with them (Gap behind island riser)
From Kitchen progress
Can this situation be rectified??

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    I don't really see what is wrong, and I can barely see the gap behind the granite on the riser. The gap on my riser is much wider because the riser wall was not completely flat and straight. They filled in the gap with caulking that matches my wood, which looks very similar in color to yours, and it is not noticable. The riser is not eye level, but is hip level and the granite overhang above camouflages it even more. Maybe I am missing something more here. Can you post more pictures?

  • 18 years ago

    The gap isn't too bad - i think we're just looking at everything with a different eye, since they didn't use the measurements/drawing we signed off on for the upper part of the island (in this illustration they were supposed to use the top right picture, but instead it came out like the bottom picture).

    From Kitchen progress
    It probably isn't a huge difference, but it does change the kinds of stools that will fit there. The granite just barely overhangs the corbels. I think we better just get used to it though...they insist their drawing was the only way...
    From Kitchen progress
    We wanted the corner areas to be more gently curved.
    From Kitchen progress

  • 18 years ago

    susan4664 if you click on the photo it will take you to the photo album where you can scroll through Robin's photos. I see what you mean..you wanted the counter to first come out a bit further from the cabinet, even before the curve started, like about 6 inches, but they started the curve at the cabinet back? I see now...you lost overall overhang depth. As far as the situation being recified, this is only one piece of granite, did you have any left they can cut another piece? Probably not but I thought I'd ask. It's a tricky situation...they definitely should have retemplated so that both you and the templaters agreed on the size and shape in writing. The verbal agreement to changes will be both sides saying "you misunderstood" Templaters, at least ones I've dealt with, are only held to the signed templated design. Again, do you even have enough granite left?

  • 18 years ago

    Robin,
    I think I would tell them that the island needs redone. you are not going to get much use out of such a shallow overhang. There are many here who have deeper overhangs on their islands Hopefully the granite experts on the forum will chime in. Is it my understanding that this is not the template that you signed off on? If it isn't, I believe you have just cause for a redo.
    G

  • 18 years ago

    I saw the slideshow and now I see the overhang problem. Sorry.

  • 18 years ago

    I hope I don't make you feel worse, but I don't see this as a small mistake. Your overhang at the ends doesn't look deep enough to sit comfortably at the counter to eat. I would persist in trying to get resolution (ie. cut a new piece of granite). I don't understand why they thought the shape you wanted wouldn't work. Why not?

  • 18 years ago

    you need to get what you requested.. that is what you paid for and that is what they owe you.. if they didn't think it was possible they should have told you that.. and told you why so you could work to resolve the issue.. the overhang doesn't look like you could have more than 1 person sit there comfortably?

    kitchen looks really nice by the way..

  • 18 years ago

    Where are your supports on the cabinets? With more overhang, you'd need more supports. With the overhang done as you wanted, you'd need supports at the edge, and two in the center, for at least 4 supports. IF I'm viewing the diagram correctly, all you have are two supports near the center, right? If that's the case, then yes, they did the curve the only way that would work with the support that you have engineered. To do it the way you wanted, you would have had to add 2 additional supports---which most homeowners would not want. Who designed the supports for your countertop? Was it your carpenter or cabinet folks? Did they communicate with the granite guys to determine what would be necessary, or did they just put those in they were done? Or was it the granite people who told you 2 supports based on a previous drawing rather than the drawing you requested? Sounds like there's been several variations on your island here for everyone to become a bit confused about. And, the miscommunication started with the intial design for the support for the island.

  • 18 years ago

    Ditto everything that livewire said. She's spot on. I might also mention that the brackets shown, would have to made deeper as well for that extra overhang.

    I'm posting a link for a product that we are now using. Livewire, you might be interested in this product too. You can use this instead of corbels for invisible support. Plus, no more knee banging that occurs with some corbels. However, if you wanted to keep your shallow wood corbels (for decorative purposes), just order four of these counter plates and get your top remade.

    See link below.
    Kompy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Counter Plate - Invisible support for islands

  • 18 years ago

    They were given the drawing, they had a slab of granite for the job, there is NO excuse for them not to have done as you asked. I would insist on a new slab. To prevent just such problems, I made a template for my granite people out of an old plastic campaign sign. It was easy to cut with scissors and will prevent any misunderstanding once they actually begin making it for me. Here's a picture of it in place. Another reason I made the template is that it was difficult for me to visualize just how much space I would have with the overhang. Making it out of plastic first and tacking it in place allowed me to make sure it would be what I wanted. Here's a bad picture of it....

  • 18 years ago

    The fabricator accepted a chenge over the phone with a verbal "got it."

    Serious mistake, all his, stay on him until he fixes it at no cost to you.

    Blessings

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for all the input. Live_wire and Kompy - I appreciate the info re: support. I guess we assumed (I know, never assume anything!), that since support was not an issue for the way they wanted to cut the granite (the top left picture in the illustration), that it would not be in issue for how we wanted the granite cut. It was the cabinet designer who planned the island, with the knowledge we would be getting granite tops. No, she did not communicate directly with the granite people - we supplied them with the drawing/measurements, which they then changed to the drawing shown above(again, the one on the top left of the illustration). I guess, if we can sort out the support issue, we will see if they have another slab - we just don't love the upper part of the island. Thanks again for the info/opinions. I wish we had been more forceful when we asked them to come out and re-template....

  • 18 years ago

    Me again. I think I misread your post. If the top has the right overhang in the middle....you don't need deeper support. You just want it to have more overhang at the ends, right? Sorry about that.

    But if you want deeper overhang in the middle too, then you'd need deeper support.