Software
Houzz Logo Print
joseph_corlett

Dear Concrete

Dear Concrete:

We've never liked each other. Yes, I'm being blunt, just the way you were with me this week, laughing at my 70 grit as I tried to cut through an etch of yours. Unlike Travertine and her eons-old cousins, you can change your ways technologically and continue to do so, cruelly toying with my optimistic nature. I want to hate you the way stoners hate Corian, but that may cost me too much emotionally and materially. We fought bitterly for two days, but I'm not sorry. We're both better off; your appearance improved as did my checking account balance.

You sweet-talked your way to the 15th floor of this oceanfront remodel 11 years ago, when you were the hottest thing on the scene. Do these bring back any memories?

Your fabricators did a nice job; these curved cabinets can be tricky to detail. Your graceful and fluid returns wouldn't look any different had I done you myself:

Your installers, not so much. How did they ever collect leaving your splash like this? How could the former owners overlook this for over a decade? Matching cookie jars?

Of course my first attempt at a repair failed miserably. I thought I could steal an inch from your backside like I do with solid surface when I have no color matched repair material, but your superficiality ruined everything. Instead of having your aggregates ground and exposed consistently, your fines were troweled to the surface and finished:

I think they are nuts for doing it, but on the second day I found out the new owners are ditching the hood for an over-the-range microwave. That freed up a 5 1/4" x 30" piece of color and particulate match. Yeah, I cut you right in the kitchen. My Festool sucks up virtually everything. Maybe they can poultice the grease spots out of your top edges. I couldn't cut 'em off or the edges wouldn't match:



I couldn't do anything with your crack at the sink rail. I doubt you'll come any further apart; after all you are Glass Fiber Reinforced Concrete (GFRC) and have metal lath in your midsection. An external rod like Unistrut reinforcement across the sink base would have prevented this along with dead level cabinets:

Your scarf joints at the sink looked terrible, as do your unfilled and pitted edges:

But I gave you some love and some color matched methel methacrylate:

Here's your stainy etchy thing at the top right of the sink. You made me pay, but I got it out, exposing some air bubbles in the process that had to be filled. The light reflection shows the sealant they used that had worn away completely in the sink area. I guess almost all tops are plastic. Corian is acrylic, engineered stone is polyester, and most granites are resinated (plasticized) at the factory. And now you concrete. My Festool 150 with 80 grit abrasive left you nude except for a light coat of Proseal and paste wax:

You seemed to like it. Before and after:


There is etching and then there is etching. Although it's difficult to tell from this picture, the brown spot towards the sink is about 1/8" deep and virtually un-repairable inconspicuously. I'd suggest a custom stainless escutcheon to the sink edge; no topical sealer on earth stands a chance. Like the heavy trucks and freeze-thaw cycles on I-75 in Michigan, hand soap is your Kryptonite. Who knew?

Concrete, to refinish you properly, I'd have to buy a small planetary machine and with the abrasives, that would be about a $3,000.00 investment. Considering this is the second time we've tangoed in four years, we're going to have to start seeing a lot more of each other before I'm willing to make that kind of commitment to you. Even with the machine's beautiful finish, suppose I cut through your layer of fines? Exposed aggregate and more pinholes to fill? Now your deck doesn't match your splash. Pull the splashes, refinish, and reinstall? Maybe. I never underestimate how much some folks are willing to pay. Fashion trends, vanity, and you Concrete, remain my patrons.

Comments (11)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay. You have to start a blog. Fabulous story (and pics!)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The best part of my slab leak (which destroyed custom cabinets that were only 6 years old) was being able to ditch my concrete counters! Bye bye concrete, hello soapstone.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Treb- does DW ever get jealous? Just wondering...

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Treb- does DW ever get jealous? Just wondering…"

    After 33 years of marriage, she calls my writing "fearless", the single best compliment I've ever received. I'll try to live up to it.

    Were she the jealous type, I would have been in big trouble with this essay of my attraction to another woman which took 4th place in the 2009 OCC Essay Contest:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Woman In Armchair

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You did a great job tidying things up here, especially on the backsplash! Looks perfect!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Tre, I never know what to expect but do know that it will be a treat!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You seem to be magic.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wonderful !! You have a lot of talent both with the stone and the story. c

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I too am learning that flirting with concrete may be trouble....my buffet has had to be replaced three times and I am wondering whether this relationship should be cut off before it gets ugly.

    Yet, the color attracts me, and like a moth to flame, I find the roughness of the material sexy, like Brad Pitt's beard--that perfect juxtaposition of beauty and rustic.

    My words not even close to the music of Treb's.....but I totally feel the pain and love of concrete!!!

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    firsthouse_mp:

    Grilfriend, can we talk?

    If your buffet has had to be replaced 3 times, your relationship has gotten ugly. It was ugly after the first replacement.

    Dump that fool.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    great job on the concrete - and great story to go with it!

    firsthouse - sounds to me like your relationship is already abusive...