Software
Houzz Logo Print
annes_arbor

I need your advice. Please vote!

18 years ago

I have to decide where my bin pulls will be placed on the drawers. Here are some pictures (drawers and bin pulls are just taped at present so everything is a little askew).

1. Should I put the bin pulls on the border or center part of the drawers?

Option #1

Option #2

2. What configuration do you think looks best for this set of 4 different size drawers? Or would you put glass knobs on the two lower right drawers instead of the bin pulls.

Right top drawer pull lined up with bottom right pulls

Left top drawer pull lined up with bottom left pull

Top drawer pulls not lined up with any pulls on the bottom

Thanks for your help!!

Comments (22)

  • 18 years ago

    I vote for option one on the top! It looks best centered.
    I am going to do a little research and let you know about the bottom ones they are harder to judge!

    Christine

  • 18 years ago

    I don't know if these answers are "correct" or not, but I like:

    1. Option 2, cup pulls in panel. Although actually, the more I look at it, I'm not sure it looks right with the cup pull in the reall large drawer panel!

    2. I think I'd like to see both sides lined up, an option you didn't include. Otherwise, I choose option 1, with the right side lined up - though I have to admit #3 doesn't look bad either. I don't like #2 much.

  • 18 years ago

    1. I vote for option #1

    2. would like to see w/ the knobs you spoke of

  • 18 years ago

    i think i like option 1 on the first photos but i think you need to do something different on the second set of photos....too many cup pulls for me. can you use a different pull for you trash pullout??? either a utility pull or a rectangular pull of some sort? or the glass knob.... but i would try to mix it up. when i picked knobs/pulls, i was suprised how many different option people put together once i really started looking.....i think if you go with the cup pulls, i would line them all up (on both sides).....i think i would like the symmetry better. you are soooooooooo close to some final decisions!!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    so i just checked your pics again because this one is stumping me......how about cup pulls on the top drawer, a rectangle pull on the trash pullout and the glass knobs on the lower right hand drawers???? i would buy one of each and play around at home to see if anything strikes you....good luck!!!!!!!1

  • 18 years ago

    Since all the drawers/doors don't seem to have that border, my first guess thought would be to put them all in the middle, that said, what I honestly believe should determine where they go is where your reach goes naturally to open them. Do some testing and see where your hands comfortably reach and x will mark the spot.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your comments.
    Sandsonik--I can't line up the top right and left pulls with the ones on the bottom, bc if I did one of the pulls on the top drawer would be farther in from the end than the other one.

    gglks--I worry there are too many cup pulls too. Very interesting idea about another type of pull on the trash pull out. I could match the one on my DW and bottom freezer drawer. It looks like this.

    The glass knobs are in this picture (they have a nickel center piece not pictured)

    Do you think that three types of hardware (two types of pulls and glass knobs) might be overkill?

    Please keep your thoughts coming. This is really helping me think the problems through more clearly!

  • 18 years ago

    Personnally I'm not a big fan of pulls on the top rail - just never looks right to me - it's OK on dishwashers and pull outs but even then I'm not so sure.

    I think you could get away with 3 no problem and it will look great. While I see lots of clean lines you seem to like a bit of flourish - I wouldn't back away from that.

  • 18 years ago

    Have you considered just doing the bin pulls on all of the top drawers and the glass knobs everywhere else? I think they look a little heavy to me when they're on all of the drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    As far as the top set of pictures go, I think you could use either placement. I tend to lean towards placing them in the center as opposed to the top (purely aesthetic reasons), but if they're easier to reach at the top, then I don't think that option looks bad either.

    My first thought on the bottom set of pictures is that none of those look right and you should use a different type of pull for the trash pull-out (at first I was going to suggest using a glass knob on that because I thought it was a hinged cabinet door, but since that won't work I think the handle you used for your dishwasher would look great).

    I don't think it's "too much" to have 3 different kinds of hardware, as long as you use them in places it makes sense. I wouldn't use the dishwasher handle more than twice, then stick with the cup pulls on drawers and the glass knobs on doors.

    Just my 2 cents!

  • 18 years ago

    I think (for what it's worth!) that you should try the pulls at the same height from the top if you are going to put them on the top rail: so the slab drawer pull should be the same height from the top of the drawer as the 5 piece drawer. Take another picture that way and see if that helps with your decision.

  • 18 years ago

    I like the bar handle in your last pictures with the glass knobs below. Is it for the dishwasher or what? I can't seem to get my mind around the cup pulls. the combination of the bar and glass knobs with the other decor is so beautiful. The cup pulls change the feel of your style for me. I also like the bar for top drawers if I need a place to hang towels while cooking. What over all style are you going for? The bar and glass look sophisticated and the cup pulls feel more antique country to me, and I personally prefer the feel of a bar pull as I have snapped fingernails in cup pulls when I grab too fast, but that's my problem, lol.

  • 18 years ago

    Much good advice, thank you so much. I think the consensus is that on the 4 drawer section I need to break up all the cup pulls. I will try to take a picture with glass pulls on the lower right drawers and another integrating the handle (if I can figure out how to attach them!)

    Caryscott--I think you've pegged my style: clean lines with a few flourishes. I never knew how to describe it before.

    Kompy--Your suggestion is a good one, but I can't do glass knobs as many places as you suggest bc the knobs and pulls are all purchased and can't be returned. (although I do have some extras of each that will allow me to make a few changes from the pictures)

    Claybabe--Another good idea. I will take a picture tomorrow with the arrangement you suggest. Perhaps placing all the pulls the same height from the top of the drawer will make it all look better.

    Bodica--Hmm. I was hoping that the polished nickel would sort of dress up the cup pulls and take them away from a country look. I have a 1923 house, so antique was definitely something I was striving for. As someone who barely has fingernails (maybe too much anxiety about my kitchen remodel lol), I think I'll be ok with the cup pulls.

    Again, many thanks for all the feedback.

  • 18 years ago

    ok here's my 2 cents....first, three different knobs would add a nice design feature to your kitchen. (I have just 26 different knobs in my kitchen so what do I know?) heh heh

    Now as to the knob placement...I'd do center knobs on the slab drawers and then center on the top trim on the five panel drawers.

    On that last cabinet, I personally see only one good option...and that is to use one pull in the center of the top drawer. The other scenarios all look unbalanced. You could also do one pull on that top drawer, one on the pull out trash, and glass on the other drawer bank (I like that idea best because it breaks up all the silver of those pulls).

  • 18 years ago

    I vote option #2 with the pulls on your DW...I know, that's not one of the choices! Seriously, I think the cup pulls are too massive for most of your drawers...they seem to overwhelm them, especially the shallower ones with the wide frames (second drawer in first set of pics)

    Honestly, none of them look "right" for different reasons in each picture.

    Or maybe, knobs that coordinate w/the cups on the shallower drawers & cup pulls on the deeper drawers.

    For the second set of pics, I agree w/IglooChic.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with igloo chic too.....use one pull on that long drawer. It just looks terribly busy with all those cup pulls so close together. I like the idea of some glass knobs, but i am not sure that the clear glass knob is right. It's a little too fancy...maybe too white (if you can call clear glass "white"). I think a stainless roung knob would look nice.

  • 18 years ago

    Just curious, why are some cabinet fronts plain and some framed? How were pulls shown on these cabinets at the showroom?

  • 18 years ago

    First, I have to say, you have the most gorgeous kitchen.

    Second, I would not do a cup pull on the the trash pullout (unless you have one of those self opening thingys). It is just too hard to open with a handful of gooey garbage (I'm thinking that long cab is the trash, no?).

    Third, we have a somewhat similar setup and used different pulls (altho I am totally embarassed to post pix of our mish mash kitchen in the same thread as your stunner - which, if it was a movie star, would definately be Aubrey Hepburn). Anyway here is a pic of what we did. We did the handles on the drawer bank next to the trash, but I would keep the cup pulls on yours.

  • 18 years ago

    Budge1,
    You've got to be kidding about your kitchen being mish-mash. I think it's really attractive and unique. I love the black cabinets with the subway tile. By the way, what faucet is that? I have two questions though, why did you leave the floor vent white and have you thought of trying to bring a touch of black to the upper part of you kitchen? Black hardware maybe?

  • 18 years ago

    I agree that you should use different pulls for the second cabinet. The cup pulls look way too heavy on the narrow bank of drawers to the right of the trash pull-out--the glass knobs might be perfect here. I think I would need to see pictures of some of the other configurations before I decided.

    Good Luck! Don't you just love 86 different opinions?

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you so much for your opinions and ideas. I worry that the camera angle is making the cup pulls dominate the drawers. They don't give that impression in person (except the 4 drawer cabinet). Also, I'm supposed to get chunky furniture "feet" (design still to be decided, not the samples on the first two pictures) and that will also give the banks of drawers more substance.

    I feel as if I need to tape up all the drawer fronts and put up all the cup pulls in the entire kitchen to see whether they really dominate the space. The drawer fronts are supposed to be installed on Friday/Saturday, so maybe after the cabinet maker does this, I can tape knobs and pulls before we screw them in.

    Budge1--I love your kitchen!! I would have loved to do a dark bottom cabinet with a white upper but bc my kitchen doesn't have a window, I went with all white.

    Bodica--these are custom cabinets, so there wasn't a showroom where these were displayed and knobs/pulls were attached. For better or worse, my cabinet maker and I determined every dimension of every aspect of the cabinets, crown molding, and soon-to-be furniture feet.

    Buehl--the dishwasher handle is actually much bigger than the cup pulls. This is why I think the photos may be distorting the perspective.

    Nuccia--I do like 86 different opinions. That's what makes this forum great. But I'm glad I didn't run all my decisions by this group LOL.

  • 18 years ago

    any updated pics????????

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations