Expensive vs. Cheap subway tile?

agk2003

13 years ago

The subway tile i've seen locally is generally around $2/SF. Will I notice a difference between that and the more expensive (upwards of $10/SF) subway tile? i saw a comment online that says the thinner tile will look cheap but others tell me you can't tell once it's on the wall. What do the GWers say? thank you! so confused... thought we'd save a little here.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

elphaba_gw
13 years ago
There's been a thread on this a few years ago (maybe more recent too). Some differences of opinion but the conclusion I drew was to stay away from subway tile from Home Depot. People had the same story we hear over and over about home Depot, that their products often are made exclusively at a lower price by brand name manuacturers - better to pick a brand name and go to THEIR warehouse - my contractor bought Daltile directly at a very very low price. I've only had it for a short time but it looks beautiful. I thought it was a small thing I could do to encourage the possibility of a quality that would be better than if I bought at bottom basement prices from a big box store.
On the thread I'm thinking of, stories varied. In some cases the tile was obviously made specifically for Home Depot. In other cases, it was hard to tell. I just took a safer route for a price that was not much more (can't remember exactlyn- but probably changed by the time you read this anyway). YMMV
Good luck.
zaphod42
13 years ago
I'm looking at a slightly more expensive subway tile for a couple of reasons.

More irregularly shaped. Less hard-lined edges. Softer more organic feel.

Tile is thicker. Need this so that it matches thickness of border element I picked. Depending on your need to mix and match, make sure the thickness of your selections are the same.

has a fine crackle to the finish and a little more richness/depth of glaze. If you want your color consistently even, maybe less expensive tiles will work better.

Just some of my reasoning for selecting the more expensive version. I'm not 100% on mine yet, but heavily leaning.
Related Professionals
Oxford Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Augusta Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Sacramento Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Gillette Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Hot Springs Kitchen Remodelers · West Palm Beach Kitchen Remodelers · Clearlake Kitchen Remodelers · Forrest City Custom Countertops · West Palm Beach Custom Countertops · Rocky Mount Custom Countertops · Plainfield Custom Countertops · Olean Custom Countertops · Burlington Custom Countertops · Wausau Custom Countertops · Victoria Custom Countertops
beaches1980
13 years ago
Afer looking all over the city, I still couldn't find the right creamy/white subway tile. So I stopped in at my local box store and was surprised to find the right color ceramic subway tile. It ended up being the least expensive solution. I have no idea how good or bad the quality is, but I love what I ended up with and was happy it was only $100. My installers had no issues with it.

This post was edited by beaches1980 on Mon, Nov 4, 13 at 20:40
debrak2008
13 years ago
My BS is from Home Depot and Lowes. The subway tile was available for more money at a tile showroom. It was the same exact tile. Got it from Home Depot. The pencil line is from Lowes. I looked at more expensive tile but this tile was the exact right color.

As posted some are looking for more irregular edged and thicker tiles. I did not want this so the HD tile was perfect. Remember you must take into account the thickness of the tile when you put in your outlets.