Software
Houzz Logo Print
jaksopcam_gw

Cabinet question - shelf construction

18 years ago

I got estimates from many kitchen places and have narrowed it down to Omega and Medallion. Right now the Omega price is better but I really liked the KD at Medallion and they are willing to negotiate. This guy has been consistantly following up with me, he contributed his own ideas and listened to mine. The best guy I've met and feel confident about working with him. I would like to hear from anyone that has knowledge of both brands.

Another question is this: The Medallion doors and frames are all wood but he told me the interior (shelves, I guess?) are vinyl on furniture board. I could upgrade to all wood for an additional 10%. Honestly, I am not sure what this means and is it really important? I think Omega was all wood. Opinions???

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Vinyl shelves were a sticking point for me in choosing cabinets. I wasn't interested at all, so I went with Omega instead.

    The majority of my Omega cabinets are wonderful, but I do have serious issues with their pull out shelves for two of my lower cabinets. When you pull them out, the shelf stays in place and the drawer (which is mounted on top of it) slides out. If you pull to full extension (which they're supposed to do) they flip over. I think this is a problem because of my inset doors, but I'm pretty upset about the problem. It's going to cause weeks of delay on the job while they're remanufactured to be safe, and will require a difficult removal since they already have their granite in place and the backsplah.

    Omega has dealt with each issue on the cabs swiftly, so I can't fault their customer service, but this design flaw is going to be an expensive and difficult mess.

    MEdallion never got back with me on a bid, so I can't compare prices.

  • 18 years ago

    I have Medallion cabinets and am very happy with them. I have the Brookhill style in the Designer series painted Divinity. The designer series has furniture board cabinets and shelves. They are VERY sturdy. I am very happy that I did not spend the extra money on the Designer Gold series which is an upgrade. I did upgrade my drawers to soft close/full extension. My mom is currently doing her kitchen using the Silverline series which is less money than mine. Her cabinets are beautiful! She got Maple with Hazelnut stain. She upgraded to full extension drawers.

    If you would like, search my kitchen and take a look.

    If you have any further questions, I'd be more than happy to help! Good luck in your decision.

    Barb

  • 18 years ago

    5\8 medium grade furniture board shelf is pretty sturdy. Are you doing any really wide cabinets (say more than 34 inches)? Will you be putting anything heavy on the shelves of the wider cabinets? Are the wider cabinets uppers or lowers? Uppers are pretty narrow so it will be hard to overload them to the point they sag. If you end up having a problem you can always get new shelves cut where you need them for probably a lot less than the upcharge.

    Info:

    Shelving
    Vinyl or laminate covered particleboard and plywood are the materials of choice for shelving due to their more rigid structure and resistance to bowing under pressure. The thicker the shelf material, the more resistant to sagging they will be.

    Generally, wider shelves(over 36") should be supported along their length to prevent sagging when loaded. Some inexpensive cabinets will have fixed shelves, making it difficult to store items of different heights, or to change positions as the need arises. Adjustable shelves allow for the repositioning of shelves by simply inserting the removable shelf clips into a new location.

    Here is a link that might be useful: source of info

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you all for your answers - I really appreciate it. Barb, I couldn't find you in the finished kitchens (I looked for bbtondo).

    GW is so great!

  • 18 years ago

    My new cabinets are Medallion, St.Andrews cherry w/pecan finish. I am also very happy with them.I have my shelves loaded so I may build a support just to be safe.

  • 18 years ago

    Jak: Here's the link to my kitchen photos. I also wanted to mention that all my shelves are 3/4" thick. My widest upper cabinet is 27" and those shelves aren't going anywhere!

    Barb

    Here is a link that might be useful: Barb's Kitchen

  • 18 years ago

    Medallion offers 3/4" adjustable shelves. In the Silverline and Designer series, the shelves are 3/4 furniture board with a maple-tone laminate. For the Designer Gold series, the shelves are a 3/4 ply with a natural maple veneer and clear coat sealed top coat. These are very sturdy shelves.

  • 18 years ago

    They use furniture board and terms like that to describe pressboard or mdf. All wood is a relative term that is used very loosly. Particle board is considered real wood as it is tiny chunks of wood glued together. As a cabinet guy I use veneer core plywood for shelving. I build either adustable shelving or permanent, whatever the client wants.

    The comment on the permanent shelves being cheaper or less quality is backwards. When the shelves become part of the cabinet they add strength to the box. The one I am on now we are mixing fixed shelves and adjustable shelves in the kitchen. On any cabinet over 24 inches wide try to get 3/4 inch material used on the shelves. Thin shelves will sag over time with some weight on them.

    I really don't understand why they charge so much more to use 3/4 inch plywood on a kitchen. It only cost me a few hundred more per kitchen to use better materials. That doesn't add up to 10% any way you look at it.

    Kenneth