Software
Houzz Logo Print
jen19083

Preliminary granite choices

18 years ago

OK - I was out at the granite yard today (it was 32 degrees and windy here in the Phila. suburbs).

Here are some contenders. Picture these with either a light, travertine-like porcelain tile or a darker slate tile. I may switch out the knobs and pulls on my cabinets to an oil-rubbed bronze, so I can draw out the browns (and maybe get a brown composite granite sink):

Number 1:

{{!gwi}}

I'm drawn to the browny/tanny tones, but need to make sure I don't make the kitchen too monochromatic with my cabinets:

Number 2:

Number 3:

I kind of like out this one is more black/white/grey - I think it's a neat contrast to the light brown of the cabinet.

Number 4:

Number 5:

Number 6:

{{!gwi}}

Number 7:

{{!gwi}}

Number 8:

{{!gwi}}

Number 9:

{{!gwi}}

Number 10:

I may drag a friend (w/good taste) to the granite yard tomorrow. This is a tough choice!

Comments (29)

  • 18 years ago

    Lots of nice choices! Do you have the names of the granites? I like #5 and #6. #6 I really like them because a touch of black in that granite would add some nice contrast and drama. It all depends on the look you are going for. #1 and #2 would be out for me becuase they blend too much with you cabinets but I like more contrast. I like the idea of a darker slate tile with #5 & #6. That would be gorgeous!

    Love looking at your granite choices. I think you will have a beautiful kitchen!

    You'll get lots of good advice here.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh boy! Lots of good choices! Here's my votes:
    #1 - copper/pinkish inclusions clash with cabinet color
    #2 & #8 - don't like salt & pepper, too much similar toned browns, overall blah -- but I don't like brown and you do, so ignore me :)
    #3, 5, & 6 - I like those colors and the brown seems to coordinate with the cabinet.
    #4 - I think I like but the color washed out in the pic.
    #7 (Yellow River?) - This is a strong dramatic statement. Either you love it or you hate it.
    #9 - To me it's a little too quiet, but the colors are right.
    #10 (Bianca Antiqua?) - the brown shades are too gray for your cabinet, IMO.
    Take some samples home and look at them in different lights over several days. Good luck!

  • 18 years ago

    I personally like the look of #5's and 6. Where were you looking at granite? I live in Bucks County.

  • 18 years ago

    i like #3...but this is also completely personal preference as i like veining as opposed to speckling.

  • 18 years ago

    My pics and views in order of favs:
    #7 Yellow River: one of my favorite granites. Gorgeous choices for a backsplash and I feel lends itself toward a more contemporary light feeling kitchen
    #5 I like granite with flowly movement over chunks/flecks. I like the caramel color running through it and how the grays pick up the color of stainless
    #3 OK.. a little washed out but I like the colors and movement with your cab
    #6.. it just interesting to look at for me
    #1 has alot of warmth but just seems kinda common looking
    #10.. I think has too much white ground and inconsistent movement which might make templating challenging
    #4: too soft of colors running through it making it appear bland to me
    2 and 8: really does nothing for me
    #9 Sorry... I just dislike that one.

    Those slabs of Yellow River are FABULOUS!

  • 18 years ago

    My personal favorite is #5. It looks interesting and really enhances the color of your cabinets and the hardware.

  • 18 years ago

    Great selections-- my vote at first was for #1 or #5. Then I looked again, and decided that #5 would be my pick........or maybe #6 or #9. The hard part is how different your cabinet looks in some of the pix- sometimes pinkish and sometimes more tan. (My guess is that in real life it is probably more tan).
    So to summarize- #5 gets the win, with 6 and 9 close runners up.
    Keep us posted.

  • 18 years ago

    #1 works but it's too blendy for me.

    #6 is great!

    And, #10 is a definite maybe (looks like the sun was behind the clouds when you took that photo?)

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Jen:

    You crazy lady. I can't believe you were out in this Philly cold & wind today at the granite yard. My bones froze just walking to the mail box. It was unbearable (I'm in West Chester). Which granite place to you go to? I know many granite places in the area, so if you need some more names, just let me know.

    My choices are #5, 6, 3 in that order. Nice color cabinets (I have the same color). I prefer the veined granite oppose to the the other styles you have there. Veining is more interesting to look at.

  • 18 years ago

    I like #3 the best because I think the veining is pretty, but not overdone; and I like the amount of white in it. I also like #4. #1 and #2 are just too much brown and your kitchen will not have much contrast and kind of just look blah, when you really want a "wow" look.

    If you pick #3, have you thought of maybe black pulls/knobs and perhaps a white or black Moenstone (granite composite) sink? Do you have your tile picked out? Can you post it? Is the tile for the floor or backsplash?

  • 18 years ago

    With the cabinet door & hardware you have shown...I vote for either #4 or #5.

  • 18 years ago

    3,6,7,10 in that order. 7 is gorgeous but I'm not quite sure I like it with your cabs.

  • 18 years ago

    I actually like #1.

  • 18 years ago

    I was liking #5 until I saw #6...The same colors, but the large pattern is very striking and less busy. It's my favorite.

  • 18 years ago

    OK... I'm voting again for 7 again since no one else did and because I think those slabs are so beautiful that I'd find a way to use them!

  • 18 years ago

    My sister has ordered cabinets about exactly the color of yours and loves #6 and puts #10 in second place, but mostly would like to know the names if you have them.

    thanks.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks everyone for taking the time to look and respond. I tried to take pictures of the names of the slabs, too - methodically, after each slab, but I was so cold I might not have gotten them all.

    Number 1 - I'm not sure if I have the right name - it might be "Angel Dust." I agree with some of the comments; it might not have enough of a contrast.

    Number 2, I believe is, "Lup. Supreme" - also could be too browny, not enough contrast.

    Number 3 is "Giallo Falesia."

    Number 4 is nicer in person - I didn't get a great picture based on the shadows/sun (yes, that's my shadow). I think it's "Kashmir White," but the marking on it was confusing.

    Number 5 and 6, I believe, are different slabs of "Golden Beach."

    Number 7 I thought looked like Yellow River too, but I believe was marked "Solari Sale" (or maybe that means it was on sale:))

    Number 8 is "Giallo Farfalo"

    Number 9 is "Lapidus."

    Number 10 - I couldn't figure out the name - there was no marking.

    Debi and Rockrisley - I was at Euro Marble and Granite in Norristown. I haven't gotten an estimate yet. My friend got his granite from there and paid $55/sq. ft. I can't at the moment remember which granite he got, but it was a dark green one. He had great things to say about them. I haven't gotten an estimate yet myself.

    Depending on my granite choice, I may switch out the pulls/knobs with an oil-rubbed bronze, and maybe an espresso silgranit sink.

    I haven't picked the floor tiles yet.

    Here's my before photos (sorry for the clutter)- I'm keeping my cabinets.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm with laurie... #4 or #5. GORGEOUS! Good luck!

  • 18 years ago

    Like the sign on number 7 says, it's a KEEPER! I vote for number 7!

    Number 6 is my second favorite!

  • 18 years ago

    #4 First choice, but on my monitor it doesn't look like the Kashmir I've seen but it is really nice with your cabinets. If you choose it please let us know what you find out about the stone.

    #5 Second Choice.

    Your cabinets are great and your choices were good ones.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with mustbnuts - #7 is a KEEPER. I also like #9 if you want something with less movement.

  • 18 years ago

    Great choices! I like 6, 7 and 5 in that order. I personally tend to gravitate towards the granites with lots of black, but the Yellow River is so gorgeous if the colors work in your home. Tough decision. Good Luck! Your cabinets are beautiful.

  • 18 years ago

    I like 3, 5 and 6. I like the browns and the movement of the stone. They are similar to the granite that I chose with my cherry cabinets. My granite is called Golden Queen, and I think it works very nicely with the cherry.

  • 18 years ago

    I like #6 and #10 best, I think. I like the black areas and that it provides some contrast to the cabinet and think you're right that an ORB pull would probably look great with this.

    #1 - too samey, I think and I'm not sure how I feel about those rose/coppery areas.

    #2 - really dislike, does nothing for me.

    #3 could work and this seems to be the direction that attracts you, but I thought 6 or 10 were better due to the darker areas. I could be completely wrong!

    #4 - I think I like 3 better than 4, but I kept changing my mind on that. 3 and 4 would round out my top 4.

    #5 - you know, this might work. I think it's just not to my taste. I do think it's too close to cabinet color too.

    #6 - great!

    #7 - meh. Doesn't really do anything for your cabinet.

    #8 - really don't care for that, especially with your door.

    #9 - not a bad looking granite on its own, but not a good match IMO.

    #10 - yep, I really like this one! On second thought, perhaps better than #6.

  • 18 years ago

    i like 1,5,6, and 8. these seem to have more "punch" with the cabinet. Some of the others are just kind of bland. thats alot of choices! you definitely need to narrow it down to about three or four and then look at those to decide.

  • 18 years ago

    This is a touch choice. Several look great with your cabinet. But my choice would be #5 then #7.

  • 18 years ago

    Now that you've posted the pix of the kitchen I'm definitely voting for one of the whiter ones, probably #5 (although anything from 3 to 7 is great IMO).

    Also, I want to congratulate you for an outstanding idea. Your cabinets look to be in good shape, but by making one or two changes you'll end up with a whole new kitchen. It's easy to get carried away by the $100K-and-up kitchens here, but you're making a very smart choice, IMO.

    Jeaniekitchen, gorgeous granite!

  • 18 years ago

    Jen,
    I feel your "pain"! I just selected my granite (finally) ALSO in 32 degree weather on Long Island. So, it's not the best weather for granite selection for sure! I went to SEVERAL yards before I selected my granite and I must say...you will know it when you see it! Granite is going in after Thanksgiving and now I am in "backsplash selection mode". Numbers 4 & 5 are nice however bundle up and keep looking if you aren't convinced. You can view my selection if you like:
    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg1114524819890.html?8
    Best of luck and let us know what you selected!
    Melanie1121

  • 17 years ago

    4 - If even a bit less muted in person than appears in photo would be my easy first choice. I really like the movement, colors and contrast with the cabinets.

    I also liked #3 but wonder if the background color is too light for the cabinets.

    Like #6 very much as well.