Software
Houzz Logo Print
stagman_gw

cabinet question

15 years ago

Long time lurker, now at kitchen phase. I appreciate all the time and effort that everyone takes in responding to posts, and would be grateful for your input to my question. We are currently building a new home and are planning our kitchen. Should the cabinets in the master bath match the kitchen cabinets ( color, style). KD seems to think so. I think that it will be too much and seem like we got a job lot of cabinets and put the extra in the bath. We have been to a few open homes here and they do both ways.

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    My personal taste would be more like yours - i.e. not to have them match. You have to wonder if your KD is getting more incentive (called "spiffs") from that particular manufacturer, since I have rarely heard of a KD saying both kitchen and bath should have the same cabinets, unless they are within visual distance of each other. And even then, I think it would be better to have them be different.

    Small piece of unasked-for advice - you will get better and more responses from your posts if you make your subject line more specific.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm with you and AKChicago...I'd rather they did not match. Matching cabinets, to me, say "builder special" as that's what builders do. I know when we built we were not allowed to have different cabs in the bathrooms than we had in the kitchen. Now that we've remodeled our kitchen, the only "matching" cabinets are in the MBA & Hall Bath upstairs. The PR & Kitchen each have different cabinets (and even different labels...Omega Dynasty for kitchen, Kraftmaid for PR).

  • 15 years ago

    We have the same style of cabinet but not the same colours - we have cream painted shaker maple cabinets in the kitchen and natural maple shaker in the bathrooms. And we have different counters as well - both granite but different types. Giallo ornamentale in the kitchen and Wenge in the bathrooms.
    My own little idiosyncrasy - but I think its kind of yechy having the same stuff in the kitchen and bathrooms. Think about it - you're in the bathroom doing your bathroom stuff and washing your hands after and then you go into the kitchen to prepare dinner for your family on the same kind of counters with the same kind of cabinets. Yech! My KD thought I was nuts but went with me on it.

  • 15 years ago

    I personally prefer that the cabinets all match, I think it helps the house flow better. I don't mind too much if it's "just" the kitchen that is different and the rest of the cabinets are the same though.

    When we were looking at homes to buy, the ones that were all different cabinets, counters and tiles were out.

  • 15 years ago

    Perhaps it depends upon the house. My master bed and bath are upstairs and not in the same style as my kitchen at all. It would never occur to me that my bedroom furniture should be in the same style as my dining room furniture, so why MBR cabs like the kitchen? I prefer the style of the master bathroom to coordinate with the style of the master bedroom, especially if it is en suite. But, perhaps in an open floor plan ranch style home where the rest of the house coordinates, there could be an argument for being all matchy matchy. But, I think in most circumstances it is unnecessary.

  • 15 years ago

    Similar but not identical styles in different rooms is an appropriate pattern, but strikingly dissimilar styles is a mistake. No Old French Countryside in one room and Mies VanderRoh in the next, thank you very much. You can make this mistake even using cabs from same vendor.

    On the other hand, furniture pieces can be appropriately dissimilar, if they compliment one another and the cabinetry or create a wonderful ironic perspective--think of the 18th century pieces on the spaceship in the "2001 A Space Odyssey" movie.

  • 15 years ago

    None of mine match. My kitchen in cherry in a natural stain (the color cherry turns after a few year), my master bath is a much darker cherry (almost a mahogany color) and my guest bath is maple with a light stain. If I had medium stained cherry everywhere it would have been very limiting.

  • 15 years ago

    I think that being able to pick more rooms means being able to get more choices you love into your house. I'd hate to be boxed in to one style for every cab in the house. I'd also love to use several counter choices throughout and not be stuck on one.
    We are getting a Corian counter in our kitchen, white marble for our master bath and have wanted to put a particular granite we love in our family bath ever since we started counter shopping. This way, we get all 3 and do not need to leave any of them out.
    Our master bath has a white cab because it works with the room, and our kitchen cabs will be white for the same reason, but I fully expect to put in a wood vanity when we do our family bath over. Life is too short to limit one's choices.
    I agree you want to stick to basic sort of theme such as not country in the kitchen with a full on urban modern bathroom... but there is a lot of wiggle room with doing different styles in different areas. Eclectic can work if done with care.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for your replies. We are getting a deal from HD by by spending X dollars they are discounting the kitchen. To get to the qualifying amount, we have to put in the master vanity. For that reason we have to use the same manufacturer, but I think that it should be in another door/color. I will keep you posted when we order it.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!