Software
Houzz Logo Print
luckyme7

Review my kitchen lighting

12 years ago

I posted this in the lighting forum and realized there isn't much traffic there as it is in this forum.

Please see my attached kitchen layout and review my lighting. Our builder gives as standard 6 LED lights(the kind that are affixed in the ceiling like recessed) in the kitchen. Are these lights good enough? We plan on using the island heavily for prepping and possibly even homework. My lighting vendor says LEDs shed more light than pendants which are going out of trend anyway as folks are preferring the clean look of LEDs that don't block the view from kitchen to family room.

Also I will be having chandelier in breakfast nook, which is immediately off of the kitchen and a ceiling fan and 4 more LEDs in the family room. She suggested that pendants in the kitchen may make it too busy. Since pendants are non-standard whereas LEDs are standard in my kitchen is it worth incurring that expense?

Also if we can manage with 6 LEDs in the kitchen, is the position marked here good? should we move one directly over sink?
I have also attached my full first floor plan for reference ( the kitchen in that plan is outdated though)

PS: I know some of you here will be heartbroken that we went with corner pantry - but we feel it will work for us. The layout is finalized at this point. We just need to finalize the lighting.

Comments (10)

  • 12 years ago

    My full first floor plan. (kitchen in this plan is outdated - for kitchen layout refer the image in my original post)

  • 12 years ago

    I know this is not a shy group....any feedback?

  • 12 years ago

    Nope, not good enough. You need under cabinet lighting. If any of the uppers have glass doors you need in cabinet lighting. Pendants are a personal choice but I'd still have two fixtures of some sort over that island. You need a light over the sink. You are going to be standing between the lights and the surfaces you're working on, that means you'll be standing in your own shadow unless you have lighting in front of you. That means under cabinet and over the sink and over the range (make sure your hood has good lights.) if there are any full height cabinets make sure there are lights either in or focused into those cabinets. How is the pantry lit? Essential to have good lighting in there. Every part of every shelf should be visible.

    If this was my kitchen I'd have 12 cans put in plus under cabinet and in cabinet lighting. Cans, under cabinet and in cabinet should each be on its own switch and should be dimmable. I'd probably swap out a can over the sink for a light fixture of some sort and possibly pendants over the islands. Also independently switched and dimmable.

    If the cabinets do not go all the way to the celing I'd add up lights above them, also dimmable.

    Do not skimp on lighting. This is a work space and no one ever complained about too much light.

  • 12 years ago

    I think you should have a light directly over the sink.

  • 12 years ago

    How about lighting in the pantry? I'd suggest a motion activated switch and an overhead light.

    We have 12 CREE LED overheads with multiple zones between kitchen and breakfast area (total footprint 18 x 25) but I don't like to use them because they give off too much light (and they're on the best dimmers possible). I much prefer the hanging lights over the island and the UCL, vs. the cans.

    Agree with others that lighting over the sink and cooktop needs to be good.

    Good luck, sounds like you are getting close!

  • 12 years ago

    Yes, we will have light in the pantry. Debating on UCL since I don't have a lot of upper cabinets. The builder gives an option of fixed lighting under cabinet for a lower price. We may go for that instead. Would lights over island mar the view to family room?

  • 12 years ago

    I have 5 800 lumen cans in a 120 sq.ft. space (12.5' x 9'); when on full this is brighter than needed but still enjoyed. My units are positioned just over or off the counter edges so illuminate them well. I do have an additional pendant over the sink but rarely use it because the overall lighting is so good -- same with the UCLs which I could have done without (or with smaller units). The LED ceiling units do disperse light better than the old fluorescents did.

    I don't think that 6 units is nearly enough for your much larger space that includes another work zone (the island).

    If they are going to be positioned so far from the counter edges I think that you will want UCLs.

    As to "marring the view" that just depends on your taste and the placement (and the pendants!). I have seen many pendants over islands in this forum that enhanced the view, others I was not so crazy about. If you install cans I think that you can use an adapter for the pendants, then if you tire of them you can convert them to the LED units. Or vice versa.

  • 12 years ago

    I think you need more lighting.
    My kitchen is much smaller. Total is 11x 17 feet and no island.
    I have 5 LED cans around the kitchen plus one over the sink on a separate switch.
    I also have a pair of semi flush incandescent in the center.
    Love my LED UCL.
    The placement of your cans are going to cast shadows on your counter work areas.
    Definitely put one over your sink
    Upgrade to include more lighting while you can.

    Our pantry has a motion sensor light which is perfect. DH would be unhappy when I would leave the pantry light on - and now it is not an issue :-)
    Also UCL rocks

  • 12 years ago

    I agree you need more lighting. I love and use my ucl and I only have a few upper cabinets. Definitely put a light over the sink on a separate switch.

  • 12 years ago

    Regarding the number & placement of can lights in the kitchen, I subscribe to David Tay's recommendations at link below.

    Traditional lighting design emphasizes layering rather than spatial zones, with ambient, task, and accent being the conventional layer types. But there's room for interpretation in kitchens. For example, a recessed light is clearly ambient, but is it also task? I would argue that a recessed light places 28" from the wall per DavidTay's recommendation is in fact a task light as well. How about undercab lights - many consider them task lights, but I use them mostly as accent lights.

    Regarding number of circuits, I recommend that you think about use cases like a typical morning, mid-day, prep with one person, prep with many people, after dinner when you've retired to another room, overnight when you have house guests, ...

    I understand that conventional kitchen lighting layout includes a dedicated circuit over the sink, but I recommend against it. Better to have a a single ambient circuit that provides sufficent light to prep and cleanup. Again, if recessed lights are placed 28" from the wall they will provide sufficent task light for the entire counter, includign the sink. And it's best not to center a light over the sink because it will cast unpleasant shadows.

    Here is a link that might be useful: DavidTay's LED recessed cans guide for kitchen