Software
Houzz Logo Print
blondie859111

Cabinet Dilemma, Input Wanted Please

15 years ago

I'm going between two cabinet ideas. Would love any advice.

1. Crystal Cabinets- French Villa Arched painted white

2. Dynasty- Brentwood painted white

Dynsaty is less expensive by about $1500.

Crystal just came out with a promo till end of Feb for free all-plywood upgrade, free upgrade to inset and free highlighting or glazing. I would use the pewter hand highlighting in that case, and go with inset. It would not save me money, but I would get a prettier cabinet I think.

I don't think arch cabinets are "in" right now, but I do adore the look of this particular Crystal cabinet. But also love the pearl bead on the Dynasty cab as well.

Link below shows both and my applicances- as well as inspiration pics of my favorite kitchens.

Thank you for any input!

lavlass would you please send me an email thru my page? thanks!

Here is a link that might be useful: Cabinet Pictures

Comments (23)

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with you about arched cabs, but those are the pretties arch cabs I've seen. If you love the look, don't worry about what is "in"! Would that vintagey kind of look work with your house? I think the Brentwood is classic and would probably be my choice because it would never look "in" or "out". Please, please, report back when you've made a decision. I weigh in on these choices, but rarely get to hear what folks chose in the end.

  • 15 years ago

    I wouldn't worry about what is in right now unless you intend to sell right away. Who knows what will be in in ten years?

    They are both lovely. I like the straight one better, but that's just me.

  • 15 years ago

    If the rest of the home will support your "French Country" choice of cabinet, go for what you love, because if it 'fits' the house, I think it can be more timeless as it will just 'look right' and 'in or out' won't be as much of an issue. I'm a simple-lines sort of person, like Ernietd, and prefer archless, but it's your new house and kitchen.

    You're scaring me though...Your blog shows the U shape plan instead of the wonderful island plan you had worked out!!..??

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you for the input. I think the rest of the house can support the french country look, but the cabinets are such a big expense that it frightens me, and I don't want to make an error in jugement!
    rhome410, i set up a "mock" island in my space, and found I could not tolerate it. I found it to be an obsticle that I began to hate. I am so used to open space that I ended up kicking it, and was so terribly frustrated- and that was without any chairs! I visited a house with an island and hung out in the kitchen and helped prepare a meal, and couldn't wait to get out of the kitchen- so this makes me think an island is not for me. They had the exact same measurements I had for clearance and it was difficult for both of us to work together.
    Although you know I truly appreciated all of your work, and I learned a lot about kitchen design from you.

  • 15 years ago

    I wasn't worried about your not appreciating my work...I was worried about you having the best possible kitchen. I am SO glad that you were able to try out an island kitchen, and mock up an island in your current space to know what will work, and in this case, won't work for you! If you are happy and won't have 2nd thoughts (something I HATE), I am happy...Because that's the whole point of helping here. :-)

  • 15 years ago

    rhome, I think the very best of it was understanding that the way the KD had the range area right in the walkway needed to be changed. That would have been tough to live with, for sure. I now have the cabinets set up so that everything will be in reach, and dish storage is near DW, and so on. I will enjoy the kitchen much more because now it makes sense! Plus my husband will really enjoy the back wall snack/coffee area.
    Thank you!

  • 15 years ago

    Blondie- I like the arch cabinets. Very pretty, but I like french country! :)

    Are you doing glass uppers in any areas? Will they have the arch top, or straight top?

    I love your appliances. Very sleek, but will be a nice contrast to the cabinets. What are you doing for countertops/backsplash?

    Your big window and french door are going to look amazing. It's going to be a beautiful kitchen!

  • 15 years ago

    I was just looking at the dynasty cabinets and I really like the brentwood. I will be honest I am not familiar with the other but the brentwood will be classy and timeless.

  • 15 years ago

    All your inspiration pictures have multi-paned, rectilinear glass uppers. Are the uppers by your range or elsewhere going to have glass and follow this pattern? Does that work for you with the arched cabinet doors? (I'm not trying to lead you to a yes or no, just stating that it's something you might want to check.)

    All the best to you in your search for the best cabinet choice.

  • 15 years ago

    My arch top cabs are slated for demo and it can't be soon enough for me! In fairness, they are washed oak, which is half the problem. In our last house the p.o. put in washed oak slab front cabs with rounded corners and edges and I did not like those either, but they were so much nicer than these arch top ones. The glaze to emphasize the arches seems dirty to me no matter how much I know it is clean. Yours would be a different tone than mine, but the effect is not far off.

    I agree with the people who said that the Brentwood cabs would be more classic. I like their cleaner lines and they could work with different styles so if you change your look, they will change with it.

    Sorry if I sound harsh about the arch tops, but I really detest mine.s

  • 15 years ago

    I have Crystal Cabinets and my island is almost like your door style. I went with the Country French and I also had glazing done. They did a superb job and I am so happy with my cabinets. I also have the Country French door in knotty alder in my laundry room. I will provide a link.

    Here is a link that might be useful:

  • 15 years ago

    I prefer the straight one (Brentwood). To me, the arched ones are too fussy...but that's my personal preference. If you prefer the arch and it fits in with the rest of your components (appliances, etc.), then get them. You're remodeling for yourself, not some unknown future buyer!


    As to your layout, overall I like it. However, there is one thing that I see a problem with and that would be a showstopper for me...you have very little prep space and quite a bit of space where it's almost useless (at least for prepping). I strongly suggest you move the range over to the right by about a foot...you will really appreciate the extra space b/w the sink and range!

    In my old kitchen, I had around 24" of prep space (approx what you have here of useful space). It was far too little and was one of the main driving forces behind our remodel (that and the cabinets falling apart!). I now have approx 42" b/w the edge of the cooktop & the edge of my prep sink and think it's ideal. Enough to have plenty of space to work in but the sink isn't too far away from the cooktop for adding water to a pot or dumping pasta.

    If the reason you left so little room to the left of the range is b/c you're looking for symmetry, then put in the following upper cabinets flanking the range: 24" + 24" + Rangehood + 24". For the base cabinets, you would have 12" + range + 24". The 12" cabinet would be ideal for storing cutting boards (and pizza stones) used while prepping. Heavy items like pizza stones & cutting boards really shouldn't be stored above waist or chest high. If they're stored higher and they slip out of your hands while getting them out or putting them away, there's the potential for serious injury if they hit you. It's better to store these items upright in a base cabinet...and cabinets work better than drawers for this type of storage for ease of access. Yes, you can create a deep drawer w/dividers to store them vertically, but, to me, it's a waste of space to do this.

    Where is the "useless" space for prepping? The peninsula and space to the right of the range. The peninsula is too far from the range and the space to the right of the range is too far from a water source.


    I only bring this issue up b/c I want you to have a truly functional kitchen with plenty of workspace where it's needed...especially prep workspace since 70% of the time/work spent in the kitchen is spent prepping.

  • 15 years ago

    michellemarie, your kitchen is stunning. I love your island, and the carvings are just beyond belief! Thank you for posting, I saved to my clippings.

    mnerg, it's not shown, but there is a coffee/snack area on the back wall that rhome suggested for me, whcih has four glass uppers. I am in hopes, if budget allows, to put glass uppers around range hood. If not now, in a couple of years.

    dianalo, that's my fear, what I think is terribly charming now, will become a source of regret in the future. A friend has the washed oak arch tops and they are sorely dated. I don't want to end up there!

    And to all- I looked back at my clippings, and ever single kitchen I saved was a square, not arched. I also took into consideration the appliances are rather substantial looking, which points more towards Brentwood.

    buehl, I thank you so much for your suggestion. You wrote this once before on a post to me, but I did not "get" it, and now I do. I will redraw on graph paper tonight, and try to post tomorrow. I think it's a great idea. The only other dilemma I have is that the ther side of the penninsula is to be my baking area- so I can put out my cooking cooling sheets, roll out crusts with plenty of room, raise bread dough, and so on. I love the expanse of room, because when I bake I love to spread out as I generally make several items in one day. However, I was hoping to have my kitchenaid mixer on a stand, and have no where for that. I have the 2 drawer banks of 33" each because thast where I need to store dishes and glasses, with flatwear in small upper drawers. Any ideas there?

    Thank you all for good input. I really would have a trainwreck of a design without your help and input!

  • 15 years ago

    Do you have a layout that includes the "back wall coffee area"? How far is it from the end of the peninsula to the "coffee area"?

    I think we need to see the entire layout...

    BTW...when you say "stand", do you mean a cabinet with a mixer lift or something else?

  • 15 years ago

    buehl,
    I will try to do one up in Photoshop and post. By "Stand" I mean that cabinet that swing up and brings out the kitchenaid mixer. I don't know if they are any good, but I would love to have one by that bank of drawers- if I could make the drawers more narrow than 33". don't know if that would be useful for dish storage though.
    Will get working on layout now. Thank you!

  • 15 years ago

    Ok! Kitchen plan as it stands now is up- link below:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Plan

  • 15 years ago

    Revised plan- I snuck anoter three inches for thecookie sheet/stonewear storage:

  • 15 years ago

    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    Blondie- I really like your plan! An island doesn't work for everyone...and from the very beginning, you were thinking about a u-shape.

    The baking area is a great idea and the peninsula gives you so much space! The second oven is going to be great. My only question, have you thought of moving the fridge over by the closet, then the snack area, then the second oven and microwave?

    It would give you more space to set down hot items coming out of the oven...and when someone opens the fridge, it doesn't block traffic by the peninsula. Just a thought :)

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Lav,
    I tried and tried to get the fridge OR the oven by closet, but the slant in the wall (which ultimately makes out entrance to MBR) makes that space useless for anything other than a closet. I wanted the fridge on one side and ove/micro on other, but then snack area was no longer centered. I've got about 4' between penninsula end and fridge, so I hope it works well. I had to make a snap decision when the electrical was ready to go and I was not!
    Thank you for the input and advice~

  • 15 years ago

    OK...how about making the 36" corner susan into a 27" cabinet that faces the DR. That frees up approx 9". I think you need at least 15" for a mixer lift (that's what they're called, btw). So, if you made the 33" drawer bases into 30" drawer bases, you would have the 15" needed. Or, if you need 18", make one 33" drawer base into a 30" and the other into 24".

    Regarding the 18" bread drawer...is 18" wide enough? If you use very little sandwich bread, bagels, hamburger/hot dog rolls, cinnamon bread, etc. you might be OK, but we have a 24" drawer and it isn't always big enough, especially in the summer when we always have hamburger & hot dog rolls in addition to the other breads. (No, I do not store the gluten-free breads there, they're all frozen. I wouldn't anyway as it's too easy to cross-contaminate in a drawer or breadbox.)

    If the drawer is deep enough to stack the bread two-deep, it would work better. Ours is in the bottom drawer of a 4-drawer drawer base so there's not enough depth to stack.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rev-A-Shelf Mixer Lift (as an example)

  • 15 years ago

    Well that makes sense...and 4 feet should be plenty of room. Your snack area is going to look very nice.

    I can't remember, were you putting any glass uppers in your kitchen, maybe over the snack area? I know they're in your inspiration pictures. Very pretty!

    Oh, I sent you an e-mail the other night, but sometimes it doesn't go through. Let me know if you need me to send it again :)

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Lav,
    I am having 4 18" glass uppers above snack area, like the inspiration pic I have posted on the site, and I think they will be staggered like the picture- but all 42" high. Up top in the cabinets I would like to put my pretty stuff that I only use 3 or 4 times a year, but love to look at.
    Below on counter will be coffee maker, paper towels, toaster.
    Next week I meet with a custom cabinetmaker to get a price. Honestly, it can't be worse than the prices I have been getting!
    I am in the midst of changing email servers so if you would re-send I would appreciate it!

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County