Software
Houzz Logo Print
snappyturtle

Brookhaven v. UltraCraft

18 years ago

Hi all. I went to my local kitchen design center and they carry Plain & Fancy, Wood Mode, Brookhaven and UltraCraft. I told the kitchen designer I was looking for cabinets for a second home so didn't want to spend a ton and wanted painted maple cabinets. She immediately suggested Brookhaven and dismissed UltraCraft as for rental apartments. But searching this forum I've found some very positive reviews of UltraCraft and when I went to their website I saw that they have the door style I want and more finishes than Brookhaven.

I then e-mailed the KD and told her I want a quote for UltraCraft and she just sent me back an e-mail saying they're poorly made and that they would end up costing more than the Brookhaven. Is that true? (And if it's true, why are they carrying UltraCraft?)

I would love to hear what you all think about this and about your experiences with either cabinet line.

Thank you!

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    I've used Kraftmaid, ultracraft, and KitchenKraft and I can tell you that the door quality, hardware (drawer slides) and finishes are equal to ANY cabinet brand I've encountered. The cabinet boxes however are particle board, so I think it's fair to say that there is an objective quality difference with the boxes, but honestly, I think this cost savings is a fair trade-off for cabinets that look like they cost twice their price.

    Lastly, for me the most attractive attribute of Ultracraft is their frameless construction. You get noticably more utility (room) out of your drawers and cabinets because of the Frameless construction.

    my 2 cents.

  • 18 years ago

    Brookhaven offers frameless too. That's what I have in my kitchen -- or half of it. We used Woodmode for the rest and they mix beautifully. They do have a 10 yr warranty. I don't know anything about Ultracraft, but Brookhaven won't be a mistake.

  • 18 years ago

    lol. my heart skipped a beat reading this, since i ordered my ultracraft yesterday afternoon! the kitchen shop did not have an install of the cabinets, but i'm happy with the door finish. i don't live in a rental, but it is a condo - a narrow galley. and i didn't see a reason to spend a ton on cabinets in this layout.plus, since i'm going with white, thermofoil was a good/economical option. i would, of course, like them to stay intact for awhile! the guy i bought from had the same door style put in his house a year ago. i'm sure he got a great deal, but i expect he had some handle on quality to go with them.

    i'm not sure if brookhaven does thermo or not; i think it was the avalon door i was originally interested in, but never had it priced.

  • 18 years ago

    I would strongly disagree with your KD concerning the quality of Ultracraft. I have painted maple Ultracraft in my baths and laundry room and am very happy with the quality and looks. They have Blum glides and plywood construction and are very well made. Wouldn't hesitate to use them again.

  • 18 years ago

    here we go again, the KD is also cabinet sales person, remember that. My KD tried to sell me Brookhaven even though Dynasty was a lesser price. Brookhaven is the lesser line of Wood-Mode, can't beat that hand rubbed finish on their doors. I tried like heck to find out how brookhaven constructs their boxes, they do not like to give that information out. What are they trying to hide? I am sure they are not all plywood boxes, its MDF or the like. You can bet they cost more than ultracraft which is why she doesn't want to give you an estimate, lesser commission. If you can go some place else for cabinets, do so. Lots of cabinet companies out there. I myself decided to go with Dynasty (Omega) quality plywood box construction, even though I fell in love with the Brookhaven door finish. I also found a different place to buy my cabinets. When I look through the finished kitchens I can spot Brookhaven/wood-mode cabinet instantly. Sigh :(

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you all for responding. Wisrose -- you are right. I will press her for a quote on both cabinet lines and see where we end up.

  • 18 years ago

    After I posted I found another very recent thread with positives; linking in case you haven't seen it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Ultracraft comments

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, that was me in the other link saying that I was very happy with Ultracraft. I have the Destiny line in my kitchen and powder room, and the Vision line in my laundry room and mudroom. Both are very nice! They seem to be well made, solid, finished beautifully, and have really nice full extension glides with soft close feature. The finishes are beautiful and very consistent. I didn't look at BRookhaven, so can't compare them, but I would recommend Ultracraft without hesitation. (Don't know anything about the Entree line, though.)

    Its funny - my KD (who sells several brands) had been to an Ultracraft training session and had watched a video of the manufacturing/laminating process, and kept talking about how impressed she was by the quality. I guess it depends on whose propaganda you choose to believe. It is almost impossible for the consumer to know the truth sometimes. Bottom line is that there are many good cabinet companies out there. Find a style/finish/price point you are happy with, and then talk to others who have used that brand to make sure there are no red flags.

    Good luck!

  • 18 years ago

    You have to wonder why a KD would say that about a line the store carries - how odd!

    I don't know enough about each to comment - certainly I've never seen a bad review of Brookhaven on this site. I would probably find out if I could order a sample from each company in the finish I want (ie a sample sized door) and choose. There's no reason why a KD can't bid out the costs for you in a couple of lines. If they will only offer you a free bid for one line, I'd offer to pay for the other bid. That's just my approach ... spend a little to get maximum information. I think having real samples (not just little blocks) so you can make up your own mind is a huge plus.

    Sorry I don't know more about each line. We have an order placed for Brookhaven. Maybe this link to how Brookhaven is constructed will help?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Brookhaven construction