The quick answer is no, this will give you too many headaches trying to make this work.

Hi, :) I think the color could work in your space and I totally understand loving something.... but if it was me... in my home, I wouldn't do the leather chair. The reason, I think the fact that they are the same, gives a look that they ran out of chairs for the set. So, basically you just picked another to match. (I have leather too, had the same issue..... wish I bought a chair like the other option you show.... instead of the matching leather. It becomes boring.) I'm saying this because I really think you have a beautiful room, and I love the furniture, pillows and fireplace ....oh the rug too. :) I don't think the leather chair would look horrible, but the other chair you picked would look amazing, in my opinion. In the end.... do what feels right to you. You have a nice room and good taste. Good luck! :)

No. Please no

I'd stay away from another leather totally, but, you could get away with an ultrasuede. Still, I would have the chair made up in a fabric.

Thanks all. validated what I was thinking. the chair is uber comfy but I agree that I need to bring in some a little contrast with fabric. or ultra suede... I hadn't thought of that.