Software
Houzz Logo Print
zkathy

Big hole to fill

11 years ago

I have a hole about 5' by 4', 18" deep. (We dug out a maple stump.) I can make it deeper, but not wider.

The day after I decided that I couldn't grow an Osmanthus Fragrans (Sweet Olive) because they "detest sandy soils", my sister gave me one for my birthday. Our Grandmother had a sweet olive outside her kitchen window, so there's a lot of nostalgia here.

Back to the hole. What little topsoil came out of it was co-opted by an emergency planting, so what's left is the rattyest sandy stuff. My topsoil averages less than 2 inches, underneath that is very sandy. What I have available to fill that hole is about three fourths of the original native soil, some remnants of a load of bought "planting mix" and whatever I can buy in a bag.

I'd really like that sweet olive to grow in that hole. I figure if I put all the native soil and all of the planting mix I have left, I'll still need 5 to 10 bags of something to get it to level. What should I buy?

My Grandmother's house was in New Orleans, that sweet olive was happy as a clam growing in muck.

Thanks in advance for any replys.
Kathy

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    What do you mean by "topsoil"?
    Commercially available "topsoil" or "garden soil" is not a magic elixir but is a mix that might be about 95 percent of the mineral part of soil and about 5 percent organic matter. What the soil you have there needs is organic matter, not more of the mineral part of soil. Organic matter, compost or other vegetative waste, is what is needed.

  • 11 years ago

    My highly eroded hillside garde has from 0 to 3 inches of pine forest debris on top of what's basically sand. My geologist DH says it's decomposing granite. Lots of what they call sandrock around here. Sometimes we pull out a big rock. I woke up in the middle of the night thinking I don't want to put any of that sand back in the hole if sweet olive "detests" sandy soil.

    Here's a link that I posted on the hosta forum about what I'm working with.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Nefertiti in a sand dune

  • 11 years ago

    All soil is a mix of mineral and organic components. Your soil has the mineral part and what Kimmsr said applies: "What the soil you have there needs is organic matter, not more of the mineral part of soil. Organic matter, compost or other vegetative waste, is what is needed." From the photo in the post you linked, it looks like the soil has a fair range of particle size, so with enough added organic matter, mulch on top, and proper watering in its first year and during long periods without rain in future years, you should be fine if this plant is hardy enough for your area. Remember that your maple tree was able to grow there.

    It is considered standard good planting practice to not just amend the planting hole itself, but the entire area around the plant so that water movement and root growth aren't effected by the change in soil texture. I have sandy soil with little native organic matter, so I create an entire bed that has amended soil and plant shrubs in that along with some perennials for a bit of extra color. I have readily available composted manure, but any source of organic matter added and mixed in will create improved soil. Puing an organic mulch such as wood chips on top and adding to it as it breaks down over the years will replenish the organic matter. In addition to manure, municipal compost, rotted grass clippings or old leaves (some folks have a pile of these somewhere on their property) may be available. I've moved materials in buckets in my car, or you can rent a pickup from one of the big box stores, or some of the farms in my area will deliver, or there are usually commercial suppliers of mulch and compost that will deliver a load, or you can buy it by the bag (the most expensive option in most cases.)

    Your current soil isn't going to hurt your plant if it has organic matter added, so I wouldn't worry about not putting "any of that sand back in the hole" since it's lack of organic matter rather than the sand itself that might make the Osmanthus unhappy.

    Look at the response from Kimmsr in the post linked below for some easy home tests to see what the components of your soil currently are.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Basic soil tests

  • 11 years ago

    Since you have plenty of organic matter going in, I would avoid the 'garden soil' products since they are usually heavy on the compost or peat. Go for 'topsoil', and if you have more than one product to choose from, find a torn bag (or accidentally poke your finger through it) and examine the texture so you can get what you want. I live on clay so if I buy that stuff I'm looking for a coarser texture. You seem to be looking for finer texture than the sand you have now.

  • 11 years ago

    It's better to plant in native soil - just fill the hole with matching dirt from your yard, mulch thickly and see what happens. At most, amend with no more than 1/4 compost for water retention.

    If you fill the hole with heavily amended material, you create a "flowerpot" and the roots will tend to stay inside the amended area. That's bad for the tree.

    Here's some local cultivation onfo for you.
    http://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/all/osmanthus-fragrans/

  • 11 years ago

    Don't know about sweet olives, but I generally agree with the others. If the tree likes thick, boggy soil, putting a lot of organic stuff in there---in my area woodchips are available for free at the transfer station--and having it decompose to something like the NOLA muck would probably be good. Getting the hole up to speed before planting time will be a challenge.

    You probably want to put your el cheapo organic stuff on top of the soil, instead of using it to amend the soil, which means that you will have to fill at least a few inches of the hole with something else. I would try and salvage the soil from the hole as much as possible. Things like spent mushroom media, peat moss, and maybe cotton slash come to mind as suitable amendments.

    My experience is that you can considerably accelerate the decomposition process of the woodchips on top iif you consistently add soluble nitrogen in there (and keep it moist of course).

    Most people want to proceed organically these days, but just to put things in perspective, an adult puts ought as much as 20g of urea per day. A homesteader's billygoat probably does the same. That's a tablespoonfull of urea. So, a conservative application of nitrogen in that circumstance would be a couple of tablespoons of urea per week.sprinkled on top of your chips which should be four or more inches deep.

  • 11 years ago

    Don't know about sweet olives, but I generally agree with the others. If the tree likes thick, boggy soil, putting a lot of organic stuff in there---in my area woodchips are available for free at the transfer station--and having it decompose to something like the NOLA muck would probably be good. Getting the hole up to speed before planting time will be a challenge.

    You probably want to put your el cheapo organic stuff on top of the soil, instead of using it to amend the soil, which means that you will have to fill at least a few inches of the hole with something else. I would try and salvage the soil from the hole as much as possible. Things like spent mushroom media, peat moss, and maybe cotton slash come to mind as suitable amendments.

    My experience is that you can considerably accelerate the decomposition process of the woodchips on top iif you consistently add soluble nitrogen in there (and keep it moist of course).

    Most people want to proceed organically these days, but just to put things in perspective, an adult puts ought as much as 20g of urea per day. A homesteader's billygoat probably does the same. That's a tablespoonfull of urea. So, a conservative application of nitrogen in that circumstance would be a couple of tablespoons of urea per week.sprinkled on top of your chips which should be four or more inches deep.

  • 11 years ago

    Sweet Olives are not noted for being picky about soil conditions. They grow all over the Bay Area, from the sandy Pacific edge to the mucky lowlands around the Delta.

    http://homeguides.sfgate.com/plant-care-sweet-olive-trees-34564.html

  • 11 years ago

    Lazy: It appears that the OP has a hole not only due to the former tree, but some soil was already borrowed from it for another planting, so I assumed there was no other soil available around the yard to fill it. Otherwise that would be my advice too. If that's not possible then the purchased topsoil was my recommendation so as not to overload the hole with organic matter and create a flower pot/root trap.

  • 11 years ago

    Hi and thanks for all your help. Today I put the Osmanthus Fragrans, still in its pot, and three other potted shrubs that I haven't gotten around to planting yet into the hole and filled it with what dirt I had left from the excavation. I crowded them together in the front half of the hole and the pile of dirt was such coarse sand that I was using a square front contractors shovel to fill the wheelbarrow.

    Amazingly as I got towards the bottom of the pile there was a more clay like texture to the dirt, so I filled the back of the hole with that. The back of the hole is where the sweet olive will go. More organic amendments will go in early spring.

    Everyone's settled in for the big Polar Vortex this week. I really appreciate the information you provided.
    Kathy

  • 11 years ago

    Pretty spot!