Software
Houzz Logo Print
ssmith58

privacy wall for freeway noise

11 years ago

Trying to comb through all the back log of message is hard to find exactly what I looking for on selecting a bamboo species, or maybe even having multiple species. So I've started a new message to speed up process and ask for advice from folks here on selecting bamboo.

I'm looking to grow a bamboo wall for blocking freeway noise. I live in rural area just happens my property doesn't really have any trees blocking today. I'm hoping a large wall of bamboo will reduce a large portion of the noise.

My main criteria are: Cold Hardy, fast growing, approx. 30' tall. (more detail below)

1. I live in zone 5B, but would like something more hardy, probably to zone 4. Last year we had record cold and I lost several trees. So it can get colder than expected. Plus this bamboo will be fully exposed next to freeway, so want it very hardy.

2. Would like fast growing variety. I need to cover area approximately 1000' x 40', about 1 acre. I'm already 50 and don't want to wait another 50 years for it to fill in. I'm also not worried about spreading outside this area. More won't hurt.

3. I figure about 30 feet high (or more is okay) just to be sure noise gets blocked. The ground slopes going toward the freeway. Therefore I figure little extra height to adjust for the slope.

I want it dense for noise reduction, but I don't really understand difference between clumping and running bamboo for this case.

Please let me know what suggestions you have to doing this project. What species, how many, how far apart to start, anything that is good advice to help me plan this.

Thank you in advance.

Comments (9)

  • 11 years ago

    While a large bamboo grove will provide good visual privacy, you will be disappointed if you expect it to make any significant reduction in freeway noise. I've been growing bamboo for years -- over 70 kinds -- and I am quite familiar with its properties. I'm sorry, but no matter what type or size of bamboo you plant it will simply not be able to significantly attenuate freeway noise. In addition, even though bamboo is relatively fast growing after being planted for several years, you would need to spend tens of thousands of dollars right now to get enough plants to establish a fairly dense grove in say 10-15 years. I'm sure it sounded like a good plan, but I just don't think it will do what you want. I know there are people who will disagree with me, but, during the time I have been growing bamboo and bamboo hedges, I have lived along a busy street and near a freeway: the bamboo did not do anything to make me forget about the traffic noise. I'm not saying it might not have some slight effect, but the time, money, and trouble it would take to grow such a grove is way out of proportion to any benefit you might derive.

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you for you honest feedback kudzu9. I was really hoping not to hear this, but it is understandable.

    My thought process on starting this project is because when traveling for business I've see many homes in Southern California use them to block the street and such. I was thinking maybe they were more than just blocking visibility and also blocking some sound.

    Guess I'll starting looking for other natural/plant ideas. Can't really build a physical wall because it would be just too out of place, and bit impractical, for where I live.

  • 11 years ago

    I felt bad to be discouraging, but I thought you'd rather hear that than put a huge amount of effort and money in and then be disappointed. I'm not sure any planted barrier will give you the sound decrease you would like. I live 1/2 mile from a freeway, and the sound travels through a thick stand of trees and bamboo that sit between me and the freeway, especially on rainy days when the tires make more noise. Even solid walls, which I know you don't want to do, have limitations when it comes to freeway noise.

  • 11 years ago

    A screen of golden grove bamboo could provide visual privacy. Plant some Norway spruce too. Add a water feature to create sound. For sound the best thing you can do is insulate your house. Use triple pane windows, acoustic wall panels, and ceiling panels,

  • 11 years ago

    I've always liked pine/fir/junipter for noise reduction. But yes, not a huge difference and it still takes years. I would say they change the sound of the noise, a softer muffled sound, not really a reduction.

    Not being able to see the traffic though is even more important to me. I've always gotten used to the sound, seemed more like a rushing river. But seeing cars/trucks zooming by is not something I think I would like. Out of sight, out of mind. 14 years 50 yards from 880 in San Jose.

    One trick I do to cheat the time is to plant way closer together than needed. Then cut down trees to thin as needed. For sound reduction I'd keep the thick branches near the ground so no pruning. And cut trees before lower branches get too much shade and die back.

    My experience with how fast bamboo grows and sound blocking is the same as kudzu9.

  • 11 years ago

    I had to keep searching but seems the Federal Government isn't all bad. I found the following statement on the Federal Highway Administration web site regarding use of vegetation as nose reduction.

    Appears they already know that any amount isn't really going to reduce the noise. Only thing I would accomplish is to cover up the site of traffic as waterbug_guy suggests.

    [quote]
    Can Trees Be Planted to Act as Noise Barriers?

    Vegetation, if it is high enough, wide enough, and dense enough that it cannot be seen over or through, can decrease highway traffic noise. A wide strip of trees with very thick undergrowth can lower noise levels. 30 meters of dense vegetation can reduce noise by five decibels. However, it is not feasible to plant enough trees and other vegetation along a highway to achieve such a reduction. Trees and other vegetation can be planted for psychological relief but not to physically lessen noise levels.
    [quote]

    Here is a link that might be useful: Highway Traffic Noise

  • 11 years ago

    5 decibels is not a huge reduction, unfortunately.

  • 11 years ago

    tcameronk-
    You're entitled to your opinion, but I still think that bamboo barriers in even more temperate climates will take years to grow and will not produce a huge reduction in sound. Also, being in Zone 5B means the OP will lose most of the foliage and probably many of the culms each winter. I just don't think bamboo is a realistic solution.


Sponsored