I would place a tall decorative vase or a sculpture in a color that would tie in with whatever art you choose or a wooden crate or basket of firewood, perhaps birch or some lighter colored driftwood for some contrast, on the left side of the hearth to detract from the imbalance and break up the wide expanse of black. Even if the fireplace is gas the logs will add a homey touch. Or, an arrangement of three smaller objects of varied heights would achieve he same effect.

Keep the insert, tile and mantel black, paint everything else white. Also paint the wall behind white. Frame the art with a gothic style frame painted black. If it is too dark to see in photos, then it is too dark for the room. black is beautiful but you can't use it like this, it just sucks the light out of the room, and makes it too hard to appreciate.

If you are in the Chicagoland area.. why not have us install a television with a motorized piece of art over it? Make the space functional and stylish!

reduce the watts of the sconces by 1/3-1/2, maybe even get brass or copper instead. paint the back wall a caramel color for accent. your new canvas gives you a lot more options. oh, the paintings ? with respect to the artist, they belong on that wall.

lets start with the lighting. they are so bright it's distracting. can we see the sconces unlit? right away i would lower the wattage of those bulbs. or install a dimmer.

paint the mantel white or off white. the first art is best. it would be best to stay a little modern here. with the feel of the counter to the left, the black hearth, and the chrome lights.

I don't know about the rest of you but those scones are not working for that area ,I would have someone move them on the wall of the fireplace just like the picture that Kole posted and use different light bulbs for them, there seem to be too much of a glare then add a picture with a bit of drama to it .

Of the choices, I like the second picture best. Personally I feel that a decorative mirror would brighten up the area best, horizontal. If it had some simple more curvy design it may add some softness to the hard edged, dark fireplace. Good luck.

The rectangular shape (second option) is best. But I think a dark framed mirror would be better, and would lighten the space if you want to give that consideration. Add a tall green plant on one side of the mantle, and a pair of dark candlesticks on the other. I would keep the wall color, as I believe an accent wall would be dark and choppy.

The wall needs to be brightened with color accents that will not only make the wall pop but will make the space appear larger.

I agree that an accent color would spruce things up and I agree with those who like a more horizontal piece of art. I also think that you really need something tall and colorful on the hearth to the left side of the firebox is what you really need. It will help to visually proportion the asymmetrical stone while actually defining and enhancing the the beauty of it. It will become more of a focal point and less of a huge black spot on the on a dull wall.

It looks very stark. I agree with those who recommend painting the wall an accent color since you do not wish to paint the fireplace. I also agree that some items should be placed on the mantle in order to add interest and soften the effect of the fireplace.

Perhaps something, like a tall vase, could even be added to the floor in front of or next to the fireplace.

The area is lacking some reflection. Due to the tiled area being so dark it is creating a void in the space. Since you don't want to paint the tile or have a mirror then some simple but elegant glass tilling on the wall section would be another option. A soft grey Moroccan style would be lovely in your space. Edge-band it with a dark grey or back to complement with your current fire place tile. You then can still add a small rectangle piece of art with some other simple accents- chrome candle holders/sticks, clear glass Vase with succulents for living art and or a favorite abstract statue/object.

Happy Decorating by Lyons Design.

I like the idea of painting the 3 walls that touch the fireplace. From there I would select 1 large piece that fills the space completely or...2 pieces that are of portrait orientation.

I hope this helps.

Also I have an edesign package that offer complete furniture selections at wholesale pricing. If I pay $2000 for a bed...you pay $2000...no mark ups.

Feel free to contact me timothyriversinteriors@gmail.com

I would raise it all the way to the ceiling. Usually corner fireplaces like this, in spaces that don't have much height, feel like they are trapped...at list that is my perception... :O) therefore I often bring the height all the way up so it creates an illusion of a taller space. Here is the fireplace we designed with the same idea.

Add bling or shiny. Pillows, drapes,rug.

I personally like the old windows on mantles, add some green plants, some candle holders with white candles and maybe some string lighting

Silva9006 my bad in regard to the picture on the mantle, I meant it doesn't belong there.

I'm doing a fireplace now that was stone and concrete from the 90's. Now it's a beautiful marble Venetian plaster

I think the wall going right up from the fireplace should be continued in black...that would give it height and drama. It is a good starting point and then really the sky is the limit as to how you place artwork and accent pieces. Can you replace the fireplace screen? If so, how about silver to go with the base of the sconces (and add 3 different size candlesticks with candles in the perfect accent color)...that is what they look like but it is somewhat hard to tell with them being so extremely bright! Can you put a lower wattage, soft white bulb in them? I hope once you are finished and happy with how it turns out, you will post photos for us all to see. Good luck!

The sconces are not giving you the lighting you need. I think a dark color as suggested several times on the wall completely above the mantle. I think the main problem with this dilemma is lighting or lack thereof. You can put an abstract painting that fills the whole above the fireplace area. Install a spotlight which you can adjust in the ceiling. Add the three tall candlesticks on one side & a large pot on the floor on the other side with curly willow branches in it.

Sometimes it's not what you add on, it how you treat what the main focal point. Which was the fireplace ;)

I would change the firebox to stainless steel for a brighter look. You could change the lampshades of the sconces to a pattern pulling out the red color of the painting. Are the sconces on either side stainless steel? If that all works stand back and see what else you may need on the mantle.

Unfortunately when I looked at all three of your photos I didn't even notice the different art options since all I saw was a BIG BLACK SPOT: your fireplace. Especially with the very, very bright wall lights, it's impossible to see any type of delineation in the fireplace itself. All I saw was the big black!

I understand it is tile and that you you cannot paint it. Is there nothing in there that cannot be painted at all, in any color? Perhaps between the tile and the interior of the fireplace, a strip of something? Maybe replace a thin strip of the tile right between the outer part of the fireplace and the inner part. If not, do as another houzzer suggested and add dimension by putting in light birch logs year round, or some other "light" idea. Or I've seen neat things done with candles. Also why not get a lighter brighter fire screen? Anything at all to break up the black!

Personally I don't think painting the wall is going to help. There is enough contrast between the wall and the fireplace, you just need to develop some contrast to the fireplace itself.

This reminds me of a kitchen I replaced where I wanted ALL WHITE and boy did I get it! No contrast at all and sadly it was not great. I learned for next time to layer for dimension in the same color family.

Good luck!

Do something about those wall sconces while you're at it to soften the light .. like putting them on a dimmer.

I think the fireplace is just too dark, I can't make out many details. But if you can't change the fireplace I think changing the wall color or lighting would help. Adding some decorations to the mantle would help it not look so stark. Some candlesticks, a plant and maybe a framed photo or some twinkle lights. Lights would be really pretty and add some more light to this dark corner. Just experiment some more and good luck!

Some chrome accents around the fireplace would help. Andirons, fire screen, and leather and chrome firewood sling.. Break up all that black with a little bling..

I would get a warmer tone of bulb for those sconces. Looks like floodlights!

I like the fireplace. It is dark but embrace it. I think the walls and molding don't match that dramatic tile. As far as pics...I think you need a chunkier frame. If hung, I like the second one. If you lean the picture against the wall, the first one is nice. The first one looks a bit cramped for space when hung. I also think you need some layering. If you hang the pic then lean a second skinnier picture . Or play with heights....tall skinny candle sticks. I wouldn't worry about symmetry but try to replicate heights. Find a mantel you like on line and replicate the shape w thing you love. It may have a tall plant and you don't prefer plants but have a vase of your grandmas that is a similar height/shape. You will get the same look but the items will reflect your personality. I have expensive art next to framed matted doodles my niece did that were interesting. The items make me happy and that shows.

A rug in front of the hearth. Pick up one of the minor colors from the painting.

I did write a comment but I lost it in the posting process. It's past my bedtime. Patty F, Red Fox Design

definitely art #1 or something brighter like these :

Read most of the posts, sleep well Patty :-) amateur here, but what about wainscotting the entire wall and putting in some led lights in ceiling above the mantle? if you're going for a cozier feel, I agree with so many, ditch the sconces, they're harsh. Yup, wainscotting all three walls....would tie it all together OR accent the two side walls in darker grey and wainscott just the fireplace wall comme ca :

ps: notice the size of the art above fireplace? of course your fp would have to be to scale for your space....

Another option for fireplace mantle settings is something dimensional with texture and layers for depth of field. Here are two samples who have used Sculptural Wall Art Tile. I create a series of black and white tile that could be the perfect abstract balance to the fireplace...and the reflection of the flame on the tile relates nicely to the setting... here's one sample (hangs as a vertical or horizontal) and some install examples:

The area over the fireplace is not symmetrical, so I don't think you should treat it that way......try placing something tall on the right side of the mantel, to draw your eye away from the fact that there is more space on the left. I think that might balance things visually.

Maybe you should consider wallpaper or stenciling over the mantel. Nothing too dark or heavy, something along the lines of a trellis or some other geometric pattern, mostly white with a charcoal print. Again I think it might distract the eye from the imbalance. And I think I'd replace the sconces with something a bit larger and darker.....the fireplace is a pretty predominant size for that wall and the small sconces only make it look larger. It's always nice to have a fireplace, I hope you come up with a plan that makes you happy.

Lighting up the fireplace frame and put a mirror over in silver frame

I would consider, instead of a framed print, something more 3-dimensional and weighty to draw the eye to the right to offset the balance currently to the left. Perhaps an urn/vase with branches or something unusual/unexpected. Good luck ... it will be fun trying different ideas.

Such as this but more weight ... Mirrored vase? Black branches? Silver balls? A pop of colour? Credit: Centsational Girl

Hello, All the artworks are nice but not all of them relate well to the space above the fireplace. I agree that space needs to be a darker value color to transition between the lighter walls and very dark fireplace. I would use an arrangement of artwork and decorative items on the mantle. I would use a rectangular artwork more of the size of the 1st picture because of the proportions and vertical orientation. Add a mix of smaller horizontal and vertical elements as you move to the right side of the mantle and have them overlap each other. The earlier suggestion of a basket (it should have some height to it but shorter than the cabinet) filled with wood to the left to help transition from the fireplace to the bar/cabinet area would help. Declutter that bar surface and put up stacked shelves that span its opening over it to store either functional or decorative items. The mirror isn't working as its shape does not relate to the space. Finding the right space for things you already have is key to the design working. Think out of the box when considering where and how they can be used. The opening to the right of the is also competing visually with the other features. Consider hanging drapery panels that reach to the floor on either side of the opening to soften the transition and make it a bit less dominant. Good luck.

Could you get a nickel fireplace screen to break up the mass of black? Other fireplace accessories could help break up the massive fireplace, as well. I prefer the horizontal second art option. Add some other mantle elements, too. Hard to tell from a photo, but in your photos, the sconces do come off with a lot of glare.

I would do a large twig wreath (maybe glue a red cardinal inside) and change the light fixtures on the wall. something more decorative.

As far as the three paintings go, the first one would work best with tying in colors to the fireplace. Paintings two and three have no connection to the 'strength' of that very black, and very large, fireplace. I would actually go in a different direction and use a horizontal image, framed out in black tones, that features some sort of waterscape in taupe shades from a setting sun. I would also paint that angled wall in a taupe shade to match the painting and then go with darker light fixtures with a much lower wattage. Personal effects on the mantel will make the space feel more inviting but avoid light, stark colors--they will only make the fireplace look that much larger.

If it was my fireplace, looking at things around it...it's too dark and looks out of place. Everything is light around it. I would paint it the same color as the wall in a satin paint and hang a larger picture above the fireplace!

Put some greenery/plant on the top of the fireplace.

I agree. Start with some simple fixes; see if they work. If not, then look into more permanent changes.

Make the fireplace your focal point-put some interesting colourful vases on it that will go with the painting and use some bright paint on that wall-seeing you cant use wallpaper to brighten the wall.Consider changing the lights in that room

I would select the 2nd painting because it's scale & shape works best within the space above your f/p, however it seems to appear floating so paint your wall with an accent color selected from that artwork that compliments your space best. If you could find something similar encased in a black frame & a white matting,that would be best but still paint the wall introducing a color that works best chosen from your selected art work. PLUS, fill the empty mantel balanced with a few accessories so it doesn't look so bare (3 - 5 pieces is safe)...To soften & add warmth to the black f/p & to add a bit more dimension & interest introduce some accessories on the hearth eg. combine a tall & a medium vase with twigs on one end & perhaps a medium sized basket/container, chunky candle holders on the other end. Just make sure the proportions are balanced and the materials and color pull from the painting and your surroundings. Change your wall sconces to a more weighty appearance so it balances with your heavy black f/p; you can do this with the use of a darker finish, glass shades, size....Good luck

Add woodwork above the mantle and paint it the same color as your trim in the room. This will provide a dimensional backdrop to feature your artwork.

Still work in progress.

Yea You! You can use the table runner to add more dominant/bold color to balance the black and to change seasons and moods. It reminds me of winter snow right now. Classy.