Software
Houzz Logo Print
dcdfamily

Brick vs Vinyl Exterior

11 years ago

Hi, new to the forum...been visiting for some time but this is my first post.

We are building our first home on our family's farm and cannot decide between a brick or vinyl exterior. We want a black metal roof with either red brick or white vinyl. This is the link to the house we're building but we're adding a wrap around porch the whole length of the front and right side of the house.

http://www.houseplans.com/plan/2179-square-feet-3-bedrooms-2-5-bathroom-traditional-house-plans-2-garage-1273

What do you think would look best - brick or vinyl?

Thanks!

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    Before I start please let me disclaimer my opinion...I am pretty far out of my area of expertise and really I am just talking personal experience not other benefits.


    I am building a house that essentially requires brick, and I far prefer siding, especially if you are building a modest home on a farm. Now, personally I prefer other types of siding over vinyl but I think I would still take vinyl over brick if given a choice. Siding allows for so many more future upgrade options compared to brick. Although, cutting through the outside of your house is not something I think you ever "want" to do, it is certainly a more viable option with siding than with brick. I am not really sure of the performance difference between the two materials and that might be enough to persuade me to a different opinion but until then siding.


    I am not sure I would even be building another house if my current house were siding instead of brick.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the response! Pros and cons to both and we just can't seem to decide. Keep going back and forth.

  • 11 years ago

    I certainly would not do vinyl as an alternative to brick! That's like going from full custom cabinets down to the stock thermofoil stuff at HD. They are pretty far apart in functionality and appearance. Well beyond apples and oranges. Oranges and tomatoes maybe.

    Hardiplank would be a much better choice. Also, a black metal roof would be a very poor choice for both long term maintenence and energy efficiency.

  • 11 years ago

    Brick would be my preference for very little maintenance. There are brick houses in my neighborhood that are over two hundred years old that suffered from over a half century of almost complete neglect.

  • 11 years ago

    Brick or cement siding like the Hardi suggested.

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you for the responses. Our first choice was brick and honestly we are trying to justify the extra expense of it. We do not have an unlimited budget but think the extra expense is probably worth it.


    greendesigns, Can you please explain your statement about the black metal roof being high maintenance and not energy efficient?

  • 11 years ago

    Drive around a neighborhood and look at the mold and mildew on vinyl-sided houses...it's there. We have friends who have their entire house pressure-washed twice a year to keep the vinyl looking clean.

    In general, brick is low maintenance.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with natural, I'm in vinyl now and have to pressure-wash mine once a year. Currently, designing a house to build that will be brick.


  • 11 years ago

    If you're building a 5-year plan house, then build what the neighborhood is suited for. If all your neighbors are brick, don't build vinyl and think it will be an easy sell in a few years. From what I've seen brick homes seem to retain value compared to alternatively sided homes (to an extent). I can say this because I happen to own a rental home which was built in 1959 - all brick. The houses in the area which aren't brick are usually priced $20k less when they go on the market. On our new build we went 3 sides brick knowing full well the vinyl would need to be power-washed. I truly regret that decision. It saved me $4k but I would gladly pay that now for a do-over!

  • 11 years ago

    I've had two houses with vinyl. It will be a fraction of the cost of brick, so you're really talking two different worlds.

    I will never do another vinyl house... like any other plastic it becomes brittle, breaks, can't be freshened with paint, and has a variety of other shortfalls.

    If brick isn't financially viable, there are some great options like LP Smartside or Hardie as others have mentioned....



  • 11 years ago

    Brick. Nothing else will do. If it's too much money, I'd sacrafice some square footage or something else. It's a worthwhile investment long-term.