Check out all these discussions for starters.

Favorites discussions

And here are a bunch about which ones do best in containers.

Best container varieties

And here is many of the 'best' discussions for cherry, yield, flavor, etc. as well as some surveys.

Best tomatoes discussions

Three words: Matt's Wild Cherry!

This year I have seven different tomatoes, only one of which did I have last year. Had a leftover packet for the one and two of us shared seeds for the others. I and my wife pretty much like anything that was growing five minutes ago. Keeping it stirred up is all part of the game.

There can't be an ultimate tomato. Anything I grow with my watering, climate, neglect and soil will not taste like the same thing you grow, wherever you are. Maybe there's an exception to that rule for the tasteless ones...

It's not supposed to be one ultimate tomato. I was asking which tomato fulfills each of those descriptions from your experience. For example, last year I'd say my Black Plum had the best flavor and the most productive, as opposed to my beefsteak (not sure which one it was), which probably only had four or five total and I didn't really like the taste. If I grew more I'd have more on the list.

<I was asking which tomato fulfills each of those descriptions from your experience.>

That's why I linked some of the previous discussions above. You'll find many discussions for each of your categories with the search and each has lots of suggestions/opinions. It is a frequent question.

Dave