Software
Houzz Logo Print
mmidwest

Color experts needed!!!

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

I'll be upfront and say this is not a kitchen related question, but I know this forum is pretty active and I've seen a lot of great kitchens, so I know there are lots of people with great taste over here! I hope this is ok!

My husband and I are getting white vinyl windows installed throughout our home. We are also replacing the batten board siding in the back of the house, with steel siding. This will eventually be put on the whole house (6-10 yrs out). The back is completely rotten (it was a foreclosure), so that is the reason for the timing, otherwise we would wait to do it all at once. My dilemma is color. My roof is very prominent and a warm brown color. I was happy with our current color (a color the bank painted the home before selling), but was originally told the siding my husband has chosen didn't come in that color. So, I looked and debated, and narrowed it down to a medium taupe called Tuscan Clay.

Then we found out there was a select line of colors that had an almost exact match to our paint color now, called Teakwood. Anyway, I've spent so long looking at the Tuscan Clay color, that now I'm not sure if I like our original color better, or the Clay. Particularly, I want opinions on the two colors with our prominent, brown roof. Also, keep in mind this is a steel product and should last for a VERY long time. That is the hardest part of this decision. If we live here for 20 or more years, which is a big possibility, I want it to be a color that I won't get tired of and won't look dated. Something that will be easy to change the look of with a different door color or landscaping colors. I'd say timeless, but that seems illusive!

I was thinking that with either color, we would use white/off white around the windows and for the gutters and fascia. I was hoping it would help tie-in the white vinyl of the windows. Do you think that is the right direction as far as trim is concerned? I have to choose this now because of the back of the house being done now, and also the gutter in the front will be replaced at the same time (it is leaking and needs to be wider).

Without, further rambling - here are some pics!

Front of the house last summer - color still the same

Tuscan clay on left, Teakwood on right.

If you need to see a picture in different lighting, please just ask. The house faces south west, so it does get quite a bit of sun. I took these pics early to avoid glare, but the colors do warm up a bit in the sun.

So, ANY help would be appreciated. I've never chosen such a permanent finish before, and I'm nervous. I'm not very color or style confident, but am very hard on myself with the choices I make!

Any general tips on making choices? I get paralyzed and it drives my hubby nuts (though I think he was unrealistic when he first expected me to pick the siding and trim in 3 days...). This home is in a MUCH nicer neighborhood and is much larger than our previous home. I tend to feel really self-conscious making choices on such a large scale, with a very different "audience" than I'm used to.

Comments (15)

  • 11 years ago

    The sun is moving


  • 11 years ago

    Either will be fine. I'm not sure if I prefer the teakwood because it's a better match for what you currently have, or because it has the most "presence." Will you eventually replace the roof?

    M V thanked eam44
  • 11 years ago

    The roof is in good shape, there was no disclosure, but the neighbors think it was replace in the last 5 - 8 years, so it won't be replaced.

    For those that answered so far, do you think the teakwood would be ok with white windows and creamy trim? I gravitate toward cottage styling (creamy porches, etc), but wonder if the teakwood is too dark to work that way and will look modern?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm not great with color either so take my comment with a big grain of salt. I don't see that much difference between the two colors. So I'd go with the one that matches the front of the house best so you don't have a two-color house for the next decade. I like to make things easy whenever possible.

    Do the white and the cream compliment each other? Sometimes cream can look dirty near white.

    M V thanked funkycamper
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wanted to add this home could work for us, for 20 years or longer, but we don't have a crystal ball, so we do make decisions with resale in mind. A palette that could be pleasing to a lot of people is important, too.

    The back of the house is not visible at all from the front, or when driving, up the road from either direction. It is wooded behind the house as well, if that makes a difference to anyone :)

  • 11 years ago

    I think the current color, the teakwood, is very pretty, and would go well with white windows and creamy trim. That'd be my choice.


    M V thanked makmartell
  • 11 years ago

    I'm not a color expert.

    I think the only color siding that is timeless is white. Your storm door looks white. Do you like how that looks against your siding options?

    There is a lot of lovely architectural interest in your house and I think it could handle white beautifully. Once those windows become white vinyl they're going to become a much more prominent feature against the taupe-ish body color.

    I'm sure readers are going to gasp at the idea. But honestly, if it were my house, I'd probably explore whites. Creamier whites, so as to not be too stark against your warm brown roof.

  • 11 years ago

    Very cute house! I would go with the Teakwood. The other one will wash out in bright light and look yellowed.

    M V thanked Errant_gw
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all for you comments and input! I hope to respond more tonight. Apparently there is life outside of siding and trim....I was immersed in it this afternoon :)

  • 11 years ago

    I like the teakwood. I think it will look better with the creamy white trim.

    M V thanked wifeoferp
  • 11 years ago

    Benjebride - I'm not a big fan of vinyl/metal siding in white. I also really only like white houses with a black roof. Maybe it's because I grew up in a cream house with brown roof and never thought it very attractive. Thanks for the idea though! I do agree, that white, done right is timeless! By "timeless" I guess I was hoping for not time-stamped!

    I took some pics with the Teakwood and some trim options with the white vinyl color of the windows. Hubby says "decide TODAY".

    I had another thread started on Sunday, in the home décor section. I wasn't getting very many responses at the time, so I decided to post in kitchens as well. Someone in the décor thread, asked to see some trim options with the Teakwood. I posted some pictures just a bit ago, in that thread and it was time-consuming. I'm no sure my kids would make it through me posting them here as well! If you would want to comment over there, on the trim pics I added, I would appreciate it. I don't know if it is bad etiquette to put a link here, to the other thread, so just tell me if it is!

    [Teakwood with some trim options[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/exterior-color-help-cant-get-color-i-really-want-for-siding-dsvw-vd~2917603)

    I'm sure you'll want to scroll to the bottom, where I have 2 posts of pictures, from today. The thread is long since it so full of pictures and it started before I even had a sample of the Teakwood. In the beginning of the thread, I was debating the Tuscan clay with another, lighter color.

    Thanks again for all your help. How did color paralyzed people ever manage without the help of nice strangers on the internet?!

  • 11 years ago

    I like the teakwood but something else to consider if it has not been mentioned before. If you redo a section now with the intent of doing the rest of the house in 6 or so years, are you going to be able to find the colour again or are you going to have to redo the entire house? or live with the back not matching the front and sides? Something to think about. It might be worth it to you to find a way to do the entire house or put off on doing it until you have the funds. You said it was rotten in the back but how bad is it? Could it possibly wait or is it necessary that it is done immediately? Lovely house btw!

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, my preference would have been to patch what is there in the short term. That is not my husband's preference though. So that isn't what we are going to do :). I'd rather play it safe. In our favor (depending on your perspective) is that our installer is a family member. I think he will tell us if he hears the color is being discontinued. At that point we could figure out how to get it done. The front is in good shape, but the sides are rotting as well, just not as bad as the back. Our family member thinks the might have 5 years left. He said this steel company has been around for a very long time, so the company isn't likely to disappear. This color is in a new line, so it could work either way. If the line doesn't take off, it could go away. But if the line does work out, it's possible the other color line could be discontinued. The new color line is more current colors.

    The back is ROTTEN in sections. We avoid touching it to not damage it any further. There are wood peckers taking advantage of the easy pecking :)

  • 11 years ago

    I am with the majority in preferring the teakwood-- I think it looks better with the roof. The other color is good but seems to highlight the reddish brown of the roof more, and (personal preference) I don't care for that. But either color is fine, really, you won't offend your new neighbors with either choice!

    BTW, vinyl window frames can be painted, if you find that you don't like the bright white. Mine were painted 12 years ago and have held up well -- but some are showing wear & tear now.

    Your house is very charming!