Software
Houzz Logo Print
beth9116

How do you know what grown on?

Is there a way I should be able to tell what a rose is grown on if you don't know where they were grown. The roses I bought at Lowes are definitely grafted and not own root. The same roses I bought at a nursery are own root. Is it important to know what the roses from Lowes are grown on and should they require any different care than what I'd give own root?

Comments (5)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If they are grafted it's 99.9% chance it's on Dr. Huey root stock. The other root stocks are Fortuniana, which is only for warmer zones and multiflora, which is better in colder zones. I would assume that anything at Lowe's or Home Depot or any nursery is Dr. Huey unless otherwise specified.


    The only difference between grafted and own root is that you want to plant the graft at ground level or below, depending on your zone. For Zone 8 having the graft right at ground level is good.

  • 11 years ago

    Buford is right. All the big box stores are buying large quantities of roses from big producers and they all use Dr. Huey. Except maybe if they are from Canada where they use Multiflora a lot because of its better cold tolerance. But in TX I doubt they're bringing in stock from Canadian nurseries. Particularly since a lot of those big producers are in Texas! There are some online nurseries that use Multiflora but they all state that on their web sites. As do the handful that use Fortuniana. Unless it says otherwise assume it's Dr. Huey.

    A rose is a rose no matter what the roots are. Treat them all the same. The basic difference is that own root roses may take longer to mature and get to the same size as the grafted ones. But they do eventually catch up and even out. The whole reason for grafting is to push the plant to grow bigger faster. Dr. Huey is a very vigorous grower and will push a rose to grow to maturity faster. That's a big reason why those big rose growers use grafting. They can get a bigger plant to market faster on a vigorous root stock than they can on own root plants. The quicker to market the less expensive to produce and the more money they make.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the info both of you.

    I bought one Belinda's Dream at a local nursery, about 18" tall and she had the prettiest buds on her. When I saw the same Rose at Lowe's for half the price and bigger I knew something was different. It wasn't until I started transplanting them that I noticed the difference. The Belinda's Dream from Lowes had no buds when I got her but she has now put on 8 beautiful blooms and the one from the nursery has barely even opened the buds even though they were sitting side by side on the patio, same sun, same water.

    Is one better for longevity? Are the grafted ones more fragile to temperature change? Both of mine are in pots at least for this season and are sitting on opposite sides of the patio. It will be interesting to watch the differences.

  • 11 years ago

    If you really want to know, you can try cutting a piece of the root off and planting it in a pot. 'Dr. Huey' is known for coming back from pieces left behind in the soil after removing a rose grafted onto it. While it would probably take a year or two before seeing a bloom from a root cutting, you'll be able to narrow the guesses down by looking at foliage.


    :-)

    ~Christopher

  • 11 years ago

    Not all rose roots are equal. If you have alkalin soils, Dr. Huey will be much happier and will do a better job than when he is planted in acidic soils.


    Multiflora can handle acidic soils and will make vigorous growth there and is a better rootstock in my acidic soils. It took me a long time to learn this as most 'serious' local rose growers grow in soils that are made for roses, and that don't have a lot in common with our native top soils (and the layer of clay that's under our too thin top soil. )


    Belinda's Dream seems to be happy on its own roots in good loamy soils as well as in acidic emended soil in my yard.