Software
Houzz Logo Print
kimpa600

Does anyone not like newspaper for weed blocking?

I give advice as a master gardener for my county extension office and I often talk about newspaper mulch in this forum. Does anyone not like using several sheets of newspaper then putting organic mulch on top for weed control? I think it is the best tip I have. And when I have the discipline to do it, I don't get weeds there for a long time.

I really want to know why it might not work for some climates/people. Thanks!

Comments (28)

  • 11 years ago

    Here's an opinion from one of the more extreme examples of "some climates". The most effective factor in weed control in a hot arid alkaline environment like the Sonoran Desert is water management. Mulch here isn't a weed control material, it's sun and moisture control. That's not going to be much help to a Pennsylvania audience.

  • 11 years ago

    Some do not like using newspaper because of lack of knowledge about how paper is made and the false thought that some how poisons would be introduced from that paper.

    People I correspond with in the southwest tell me that mulches are essential to growing food crops there. Cacti, mesquite, etc. do well without mulches, but other plants need mulches to grow, possibly not for "weed" control but for soil moisture conservation.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    I don't think newspaper is as ubiquitous as it used to be.

    And as an artist with training in art safety, I have no interest in adding unknown pigments to my soil. The inks may be soy-based, but the pigments in those ink are most certainly not.

  • 11 years ago

    I am a huge newspaper mulch fan. I weigh it down with seaweed and cover it with something pretty, like leaf mould or compost or hay. I let myself believe that the dyes were non-toxic.

    Worms flock to it. My soil stays moist beneath it and the seaweed "pillows" absorb and release rainwater. I rarely do it as extensively now as I use to.

  • 11 years ago

    I find cardboard to be much better.

  • 11 years ago

    I use newspaper as a weed barrier. Layers of newspaper, layer of composted manure, layer of wood chips. Breaks down beautifully, and keeps the weeds down nicely.

  • 11 years ago

    can you please help ? is green fungus on top of my cooking 35 day old batch of supersoil good like the white fungus? or is it bad and what should i do if it is?

  • 11 years ago

    While cardboard/newspaper does prevent light from reaching new weeds, it also prevents air, water and nutrients from reaching the roots of the desirable plants.

    Because of those reasons (and many others), I’ve decided NOT to use cardboard/newspaper and to just apply several inches of bark chips.

  • 11 years ago

    In my dry, low-humidity climate, newspaper becomes stiff and pushes mulch out of the way, exposing the newspaper. It does not break down quickly. In areas with year round rainfall and humid summers, newspaper breaks down from all the moisture--not here.

    unclejdog, you might want to post your question on a new thread to get good response.


  • 11 years ago

    Newspaper helps here (sunny drought ridden CA) for awhile. We usually poke some holes so the water can get through. We are in horse country and after a couple of years the weeds come back like crazy!

    We were lucky enough to get a drenching rain last week (probably or last til fall) and get our garden mostly weeded . We will be searching for something else more permanent to weed proof our garden beds. Nancy

  • 11 years ago

    Obviously, none of you live where Kudzu and Wisteria have gone wild. Both can move underground for amazing distances and show up at the base of that tomato or squash vine that you had so much hope for. A few plants can be guarded but a whole garden - no. Overnight they will entwine your beauty and pull it down (or so it seems).

    They both produce their own nitrogen so they can subsist on poor soil but they really love it when you soften and amend the soil. They are the rats of the vegetative community and morning glories are the mice. Morning glories are nearly as bad, taking advantage of every improved inch of ground.

    Better here to leave the ground uncovered and maybe mulch immediately around the trunk of whatever you care about but take your hoe to the garden daily to do combat with any stray that you didn't plant.

    Now I've learned to leave wide enough margins around everything I care about so I can till/cultivate at least weekly. Tried wide row planting and all 3 denizens took full advantage of it. Don't take take me wrong, I love gardening and look forward to each season but some things that work elsewhere may not work in the Southeast.

  • 11 years ago
    I've used cardboard for years & love it, for discouraging weeds & for deteriorating into our horrible expansive, alkaline, clay soil so that a person can dig without damage to shovel or gardener.

    When you put down layers of cardboard or paper, you get the whole package of benefits:
    weed control
    moisture retention
    temperature modulation
    &, for me anyway, a little bit of soil conditioning.
  • 11 years ago

    Some downsides to newspaper and/or cardboard that I can think of (some of these have been mentioned previously):

    - difficult to control the quantity (how much is enough; how much is too much?)

    - challenging to place in the wind, especially paper

    - a real mess if it gets wet before final installation

    - you still have to place something aesthetically pleasing on top, which may move over time due to gravity, water shed, wind, etc.

    The benefits have been discussed already, with the biggest being it's cheap!

    There are numerous 'hybrid' mulches out there, that straddle the lines between cost, ease of installation, performance, and aesthetics. My favorite is a nonwoven mulch mat: www.woven-earth.com These are made from hemp, cost effective, and [depending on your taste] look good.

  • 11 years ago

    The mulch mats, the mulch fabrics, even those made of hemp will still need to be covered by some more aesthetically pleasing material such as wood chips, straw, or shredded leaves, etc. and they will cost you dollars out of pocket. In some 50 years of gardening I have not had a problem with mulches moving due to gravity, although on rare occasions rain fall has and once (a gale) wind did also.

    Any mulch material, placed on a slope greater than 10 percent, may be moved fairly easily so some provision to hold that mulch in place will need to be made.

    kimmq is kimmsr4

  • 11 years ago
    I always put down cardboard when the wind isn't blowing gale-force & cover it with mulch before I leave it.

    Many cities offer free mulch in the form of ground or shredded tree material;
    here, we can pick it up ourselves any time, & on Saturdays at certain times, someone will load it for us;
    all we have to provide is a photo ID & a copy of our water bill.

    If your city doesn't do this, or if you live outside the city limits, you might get a tree trimmer to dump a load of trimmings, either free or for a token payment;
    when I ask for this, I always offer at least $10 for their trouble.

    You also can post a "wanted" on craigslist or freecycle.
  • 11 years ago

    kimmq,

    Part of the appeal of these mulch mats, especially hemp, is the fact that you don't have to cover them with anything else, if you like the looks. I have some in my back yard, and I think it's nice looking. As with any mulch, there are some who don't like the looks of it. If you want to cover it with something, then think of the mats as an alternative to synthetic weed fabric.

    As for the slope, I agree. There needs to be some provision to hold mulch down. These particular mulch mats are held down with anchors (either metal, plastic, or biodegradable plastic), but the same holds true for newspaper or cardboard, too. At least initially, rocks work fine on paper or cardboard until something is placed on top.

  • 11 years ago

    I have not tried anything chipped by tree trimmers (utilities, FREE, or otherwise) cuz I know they don't remove any of the vining weeds (like bittersweet) and just chip up all the seeds on the vines too.


  • 11 years ago

    Newspapers aren't very common around here. No one subscribes anymore. It's easier to get cardboard. I like them both and they decompose well in my area

  • 11 years ago

    cscrouton has never used newspaper mulch, it is apparent., because her post could not be more error filled.

  • 11 years ago

    Annpat,

    Curious where the errors are.

    Btw, it's cscruton; and I'm a male; and, in fact, I have used newspaper mulch. My father is a print journalist, so getting newsprint was never an issue.

  • 11 years ago

    "- difficult to control the quantity (how much is enough; how much is too much?)"

    Not really, 4 to 6 pages is ample, more merely blocks air movement into the soil.

    "- challenging to place in the wind, especially paper"

    Yes, so don't place the paper or cardboard in windy conditions. The same problem will exist with hemp mats or any similar material, wind will blow these around as well.

    "- a real mess if it gets wet before final installation"

    Wet paper is not easy to work with and tends to tear easily. A number of people have stated otherwise, however.

    "- you still have to place something aesthetically pleasing on top, which may move over time due to gravity, water shed, wind, etc."

    Newspaper, cardboard, landscape fabric, or other similar weed block mats (including hemp mats) were never meant to be the only mulch material. While they may allow one to use less cover material (wood chips, shredded leaves) they still need that cover to properly function because a thin layer of paper is not going to do what mulches do very well, 1. Aid in suppressing unwanted plant growth, 2. Aid in soil moisture conservation, 3. Aid in soil temperature moderation, and 4. add organic matter to the soil.

    I have never seen gravity move mulches, but I have seen rainfall (around an inch an hour or more) move mulches from slopes but not flat planting beds. I have also seen wind
    (whole gale usually) move mulches as well as soil

    kimmq is kimmsr


  • 11 years ago

    Pretty much what Kim just said.

    Don't apply in the wind. If it's always windy where you live, yes, don't use a newspaper mulch. (I have laid newspaper in the wind, though. I lay in the direction of the wind with my weight (my seaweed) on hand.) 6 layers of newspaper is always adequate here on my property. Maybe you would need more or less, but it's very easy to figure out. I don't understand your gravity comment, but my newspaper adheres nicely to the ground here in Maine after it gets wet and I have never had it migrate. I have had wood chip mulched paths travel. My yard runs downhill to a lake and sometimes my paths do, too.

    A lot of people deliberately wet their newspaper prior to application. They're erring, of course, but, just the same, some misguided people actually prefer applying wet paper to dry.

    My reading vision is horrible. I can't even see well enough to see if I misspelled your name. I was surprised to see this morning that I assumed your gender. And got it wrong! Sorry.

    Lastly, so what if you have to apply something attractive over newspaper if it means you have a weed-impervious, worm-filled (worms Love! newspaper) gardening season? I cover mine with seaweed and chipped leaves.

    I do worry about the ink. I had allowed myself to be reassured about that, but Lisa has made me worry again.


  • 11 years ago

    I'm curious, Annpat. Why is it in error to wet newspaper before applying to garden? Wouldn't it make contact with soil better?

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, but it's awkward to handle---floppy and wanting to cling to itself. The method has a large following, though.

  • 11 years ago

    While I appreciate the feedback, and this discussion is kind of the point of a 'discussion board', I still don't see where my post had "errors". Between the posts of this thread, I have read that between 4-6 layers of newspaper is recommended. Instead of pointing out an error, you actually confirmed my statement. It takes trial and error to find the right amount (i.e. "difficult to control the quantity").

    We'll have to agree to disagree about mulch mats and aesthetics. I can only speak to synthetic weed block and hemp mats. The synthetic stuff looks horrible alone, and I don't know anyone who doesn't put something over it. The hemp mats don't need anything over them, unless you don't like the looks. I think that's probably one of the competitive advantages of this product. If it's innovative, that doesn't make it wrong, or "never intended." The website says it can be used alone, so I don't know where the "never intended" comes from.

    True about gravity. It takes water, wind, foot traffic, or animals to move mulch on hills, along with gravity. I thought that was kind of assumed at our ages. My gravity comment referred to whatever is put on top of the newspaper on a hill, not the newspaper itself. It's spelled out clearly in my first post.

    No worries about the 'errors' in your post, annpat. Just trying to make a point! The term errors is pretty strong...

    To be clear, to answer the OP, I have used newspaper as mulch, and it has been successful. There are downsides to using it, just as in any specific type of mulch.

  • 11 years ago

    I use newspaper under hay in my vegetable garden. If I had to lament a drawback, I'd say every few years it all does not completely breakdown and I find huge chunks of brittle paper when I rake up in spring. I simply add it back to my compost pile, where it breaks down very quickly. I'm not stymied, but a newbie might be, so if I were giving a class, I might mention that, so newbies aren't discouraged.

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional