Software
Houzz Logo Print
kellywodetzki

Soap Dispenser: yes or no???

11 years ago

Did you get a soap dispenser put next to your faucet and do you now use it every day? (we aren't getting the sprayer because I know I won't use it) I want one but hubby doesn't saying it won't get used and will just be another object in the island when one faucet will aesthetically look better… FYI Our Shaws farmhouse sink is in our island facing the dining room and our faucet is a waterstone if that matters

Comments (51)

  • 11 years ago

    I use mine all the time, and will be installing another one in my next reno. I would rather look at the soap dispenser than the soap bottle, and a lot of times my hands are too gunky to want to pick up the bottle (or open the cupboard door and then pick up the bottle). If it is too inconvenient to put a pot under the dispenser, I will just put some on my fingers and then spray the soap off my hand into the pot.

    Have you thought about getting a pretty dispenser to sit on the counter? That would give you the flexibility to hide it away when you choose.


    Pippin thanked sherri1058
  • 11 years ago

    No soap dispenser for me. I did not want the extra holes in the countertop...kinda hard to do something with them if you change your mind in the future. I'm just not fussy about things like soap bottles on the counter. I have dish soap on one side and hand soap on the other side and they both stay out all the time...doesn't bother me at all.

  • 11 years ago

    dcward89, my setup and sentiments exactly.

  • 11 years ago

    I have mixed feelings :-) I had one in my last house and I liked the fact that you didn't have to pick up a bottle with yucky hands to use it. But it didn't always work properly so we didn't get one in this house. I don't like having a bottle of soap on the counter so I got a nice little set of pump bottle and sponge holder and it looks good and works okay


    , although I still don't like picking up the bottle with yucky hands!

  • 11 years ago

    I don't have one and do not miss it. And I also didn't want another hole in my counter. My sink is so deep, that I generally leave the dish soap bottle on the bottom of the sink (I use one of those smaller bottles and refill it as needed). The hand soap is stashed under the sink and I just grab a squirt when I need it or just use the dish soap. There is no inconvenience in my eyes.


  • 11 years ago

    I like it. It's small and neat and mine works! I wash dishes once a day but wash my hands before I handle any food (I have cats), so after two months I switched from dish soap to hand soap. It's easier on my skin.

  • 11 years ago

    I prefer a small, pretty, refillable soap dispenser so I can move it around and squirt soap where needed.

    How do you function at your sink without a sprayer? My current sprayer stopped working. It's too soon to install new sink/faucet in our remodeling project and it's driving me crazy not to have a sprayer. It takes so much longer to rinse soap off a dishes and you can't just use a quick, more powerful squirt of water to remove something sticky, like oatmeal, for example. I'm sure when I get my water bill, my water usage is up without the sprayer.

  • 11 years ago

    I hate having to clean out little grooves and swoops and geegaws, so I'm planning on having a pump dispenser on the counter that I can pick up and swipe the sponge under, and when the dispenser needs cleaning, into the sink it goes. I'm also looking for the smoothest faucet I can find, but I'm torn on an air gap.

  • 11 years ago

    I love the soap dispenser. I replaced the side sprayer with it in my old kitchen and my remodel will have one. I don't have hard data on this, but I'm pretty confident that I use less dish soap with the dispenser compared to getting soap directly from the bottle.

  • 11 years ago

    I like soap dispensers, and have put one in this time around. But I don't consider them essential.

  • 11 years ago

    Our sprayer broke and I have never fixed it. The new sink won't have a sprayer. DH can't seem to keep all the water in the sink when he uses it. I would not like a built in soap dispenser. Just one more think to have to scrub around. If a small bottle gets gross, you can throw it away.

  • 11 years ago

    I am getting one almost entirely because I can used it with one hand. The freestanding ones move too much, requiring one hand to hold it and one to pump it. I am almost always holding something that makes that inconvenient.

  • 11 years ago

    I like them. Yes. some of them don't have the world's best track record for longevity - while others are going strong forever. But if you don't hit the jackpot for a good one, they can be found fairly inexpensively on amazon.


    A few months ago I replaced ours with a FOAMING dispenser. I love it even more than the regular kind.

    http://www.amazon.com/Built-FOAMING-Soap-Dispenser-Formulated/dp/B00K08RHQM/ref=pd_sim_hi_1?ie=UTF8&refRID=1MYVB7S08X09VZVW49TR

  • 11 years ago

    I love them. I have 3 holes in the counter: sink, soap, filtered water. I'd rather have that than a bottle on the counter any day. I even put one in the bathroom, although my contractor gave me the "are you sure?" look. It makes sense to me! I do like the foaming kind now, though. I just didn't want to be looking at the soap bottle from the dining area. I guess I haven't lived with a semi-open floor plan before, so I was cautious about that. In the kitchen, we use some Seventh Generation soap that is unscented and mild enough for handwashing but still seems to be good enough for getting pans clean. In the bathroom one, I just use Dr Bronners.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It would never occur to me that someone wouldn't want an in-counter soap dispenser. Interesting. I never thought about not putting one in.

    In my last kitchen, the (topside, metal part of the) soap dispenser broke within 6 months. Bad design. The one we replaced it with was never a problem and was going strong 6.5 years later.

    Lori- I've been planning to putting soap dispensers in the bathroom vanities and have wondered why people don't do it. Knowing you have them is encouraging.

  • 11 years ago

    I love them, and prior to our reno, used ours multiple times daily. Unfortunately, the two Blancos we installed have never worked properly. Barely work at all. Blanco sent replacement tubes, but it did not help. Our cheapo Moen worked like a champ for eight years. So . . . I don't know what I'd do now. Probably not bother drilling the holes.

  • 11 years ago

    I actually have a palm brush by OXO that dispenses soap into the brushes and use that most of the time. I rarely squirt from my cute little dispenser. I could probably get by with just the OXO brush pretty easily and it sits in a cute little planter with drainage so it's hidden until needed.

  • 11 years ago

    Miz Lizzie - I think our's that broke was a blanco. The long lasting one, was a cheaper brand and held up well (though was slightly less good-looking to me.)

  • 11 years ago

    I will be having one ( will be having a sprayer too). We are having marble worktops and I know from having marble in our main bathroom in our last house, wet bottle bottoms resting on the marble will leave marks.

    I think they look lovely. Just hope it doesn't break as that will be more expensive to sort out than a separate pump dispenser!

  • 11 years ago

    Just wondering if you can use foaming soap in a dispenser? I only like foaming dish and hand soap. I would be afraid a dispenser would be too much of a commitment to maybe the type of soap you could use.

  • 11 years ago

    My foaming soap dispenser (check the amazon link in previous post) is great. I fill it with a homemade solution of 1 part dish soap to 3 parts HOT water.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I had one installed for the first time about a year ago and I like it very much. I do have a deep sink and at times I will leave a bottle of dawn at the bottom if I'm washing more than a few things and I want to squirt soap right into what ever I am washing. But for everyday I enjoy having a soap dispenser. I figured at the time if didn't like it I could always fill the hole with a filtered water dispenser or hand creme but I like having the soap dispenser.

  • 11 years ago

    I didn't have one until about 4 years ago, but we really like it so will definitely be putting one in this remodel. I hate the look of a soap bottle, would never refill a pretty container, plus the bottle gets all gross with gunky hands and dribbled soap.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Dribbled soap from a bottle left on the top will eventually destroy most natural stones. Solid and sintered surfaces are not affected. A properly drilled soap dispenser will have the spout overhanging the sink.


    Pippin thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 11 years ago

    Joseph thanks for that - a very good reason other than just the aesthetic factor

  • 11 years ago

    Definitely yes for us. I have soap dispensers at my main sink, prep sink and the bathroom sinks. But, I'm one of those who has absolutely nothing sitting out on the counter, so I would never be happy with a soap bottle sitting out.

  • 11 years ago

    I hate counter clutter, too, but I think my little silver soap dispenser is kinda cute. Actually, after reading all this, I might do a soap dispenser after all with a NeverMT. Good discussion.

  • 11 years ago

    So from the people who responded 'yes' which brands last well and more importantly function well i.e. no clogging and is there one that is easier to refill? We got our polished nickel waterstone faucet on sale in a clearance for $399 down from $1200 (nothing wrong with it - perfectly new…fantastic deal) and it's gorgeous but I don't want to spend $240 on the soap dispenser…just need a classic 'polished nickel' one that will match this:

    http://www.waterstoneco.com/faucets/kitchen-faucet-hampton.php

  • 11 years ago

    There is a soap dispenser below your faucet in the link which has a curved spout. I have that. DO NOT get one like that!! The soap hangs up in the curve and drips later. I have pitted marks in my sink from it. Had to get a small granite dish to put under the spout and remember to turn the dispenser over it. Yech.


  • 11 years ago

    My old Moen was awesome. And it still is. My sister put my old sink, granite, and faucets in her canning kitchen. The old dispenser is still pumping while my new Blancos just sit there . . .

  • 11 years ago

    It seems that if you want a dispenser, stay away from Blanco. I have had two, but I have no idea what the brand. I bought them based on looks. The first one worked better, but since I changed dish detergent the second one is fine as well.. What detergent you ask? Palmolive didn't work so well, Dawn is fine.

  • 11 years ago

    I had to have one at my last house. I had it 7 yrs and ONLY filled it 2 times, once when installed, and a second time later on. I NEVER used it. I prefer to just have a bottle of handsoap or use my dish liquid

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a Grohe in my bathroom. I love it. It holds hand soap. I don't know how dish detergent would be on it. I went with the Grohe because of the dimensions and the sink overhang that I needed. I would have chosen any brand that met my esthetic and function criteria. I am glad that it has worked well for the last 1.5 years.

  • 11 years ago

    Another in the no camp. One more hole in the counter, another gadget, gizmo to break and clean around.

    Deep sinks do a fine job of hiding a bottle of Dawn, I think of my kitchen as a workplace, not a showroom...


  • 11 years ago

    A soap dispenser came with one of the faucets I ordered. It's in the going to the flea market/or sell on eBay box. One more gadget to keep clean I don't need. I rarely hand wash anything and it's easy enough to keep a small bottle under the sink. I use bar soap only for hand washing. Too many liquids have ingredients that give me dermatitis.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes to dispenser. Less eye and actual clutter. Use ours all the time. Why do you want bottles of soap on your counter?

  • 11 years ago

    Dilute with water to avoid clogging. Ours never clogs or drips. Kohler.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Mine is a Moen. I've been using it a year or so with no clogging, no drips and don't find it messy at all. Soap squirts into the sink or on my sponge, not on the counter. It takes an extra 2 seconds to wipe around. I use Caldrea soap in mine with no problems. I also keep a bottle of Dawn handy when I need it.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    "The soap hangs up in the curve and drips later. I have pitted marks in my sink from it."

    golferfirl129:

    What type of sink pitts from soap, please?

  • 11 years ago

    Joseph, it was a SS sink from HD. I can't give you the exact manufacturer. In fairness, my DH lived alone for several years before I arrived and just let the soap drip and stay in the same spot so some user error. I didn't want to buy and install a new soap dispenser so we found an easy work around.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    This would be the first time I've ever heard of soap pitting stainless steel.

  • 11 years ago

    Agree!

  • 11 years ago

    One of the perils of going with the ''free'' sink that fabricators give you. It's usually cheepchinese.

  • 11 years ago

    Lesson learned.


  • 11 years ago

    I think these are the ones we got. Have only had them since July, but so far so good. No clogging, no drips, they seem to be just long enough.Hansgrohe soap dispenser

  • 11 years ago

    I love my Franke soap dispenser. It doesn't drip and has been problem free since install three years ago. I use the one dispenser frequently throughout the day for both hand and dish washing.

  • 11 years ago

    I originally did not want one because I felt it would clutter the sink area and DH said it would be a pain to fill all the time. So after two years of using a regular bottle of soap I was getting annoyed of having dirty hands from raw meat and having to pick up the dish soap bottle to wash them. I finally convinced DH that we should get one. Luckily my brother in law was installing granite counters in his house a few blocks away from us, so his installer stopped by our house to drill a hole for us. I had DH make us a NeverMT and have been really happy with it so far. The hardest decision was picking out which brand of soap I was going to buy since I figured I would be stuck with it for awhile.

  • 10 years ago

    Guessing you have decided by now, but if you didn't do and still think you might want to have someone come install one, or if someone else is trying to make this same decision, maybe this will help. We built our home about 20+ years ago and installed a Moen soap dispenser at every sink--bathrooms, laundry room, and kitchen! It's a must have IMO. It prevents soap dispensers from dripping all over the countertop and sink and saves a lot of money on hand soap, because large soap refill containers are more economical. My dispenser holds much more soap than the little ones that float around, so I refill much less often as well. Refilling from the top is super easy if you hold the large refill container close to the sink mount's opening to prevent soap bubbles from forming. Also, I hated the way those countertop soap dispensers always tipped over when they were getting low on soap!


    We bought sinks that had a pre-drilled hole in the kitchen (white porcelain cast iron) and laundry (stainless), and we had a hole drilled into one side of the back flat area on our drop in solid surface bathroom sinks, so there's no hole in our counter top. My builder thought the latter idea was brilliant! I hope it all works out for you. Your husband probably won't care once it's installed, as long as there's soap to wash up with IMO! We put in Moen, and they still work. Make sure you get a kind that is easy to depress, because some of the Moen ones have a different kind of pump and are harder to push down and get the soap out IMO. We have and love Moen model #3910-A. Love the long soap dispenser nozzle, as it hangs over into the sink, so any drips get washed away when you wash your hands! A few years ago, we replaced only 3 of our 8 hand soap pumps with newer versions that I don't like quite as well as they have stiffer pumps (may last even longer). The newer models are #3942 and #3944; so if you like a soft east to depress the soap pump, maybe ask Moen which of their models has an easy to depress pump mechanism if they aren't still making this model. Also, I have been reading about the toxic chemicals (carcinogens, skin irritants, etc.) that are in many of the liquid hand soaps on the market at Awakening Willow's site.

    http://awakeningwillow.com/2011/07/27/get-toxic-chemicals-out-of-cosmetics-safe-cosmetics-act-of-2011/

    There are probably other safe liquid or bar soaps, but with researching ingredients that I've done so far, I believe the following hand soaps are among the safer ones: Dr. Bronner's Castile Soap (find at Thrive Market.com, the company's website, Target.com, Walmart.com. etc.), "Mrs. Myers Hand Soap"- Lavender oil or Lemon Verbena (find at Target - on cleaning aisle), "Kirk's Original Castile Bar" made with coconut oil (find at Walmart.com), and of course there's always old fashioned "Ivory Bar Soap." (Dove Bar Soap had some toxic chemicals I wasn't comfortable with.) The soap industry isn't very regulated and I found the simple "Members Mark Aloe Vera" Hand Soap" I have been using was filled with toxic chemicals, aka carcinogens, skin irritants, and deep penetrating agents. I was appalled, so please use safe soaps in your soap dispensers. A foaming soap dispenser would make the more expensive Castile Soaps more cost effective. Recipe for the dilution found at wellnessmama.com.

    http://wellnessmama.com/8631/foaming-hand-soap/




  • 10 years ago

    I'm actually really happy I didn't go with the dispenser! It's personal though

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida