Software
Houzz Logo Print
nepool

Heat pump or A/C for cooling

11 years ago

Hi,

We just built a new 2600 sq ft ranch (2000 sq ft finished basement) and installed a 93% efficiency propane gas furnace and (amazing) 80,000 BTU high efficiency wood burning fireplace (pacific energy FC30). We have a 1000 gallon propane tank buried in the back yard. The intention was to install a heat pump to offset heating costs in the shoulder season (I'm in New England - likely heat pump will not work in mid- December through early March because of extreme cold). What we didn't bargain on was how fantastic the fireplace would be and how much heat it puts out. I'm foreseeing us using that exclusively in the shoulder season.

My question is, for cooling only, is it still worth getting a heat pump or should we just go with a regular A/C unit. My HVAC guy doesn't think so. He said I could save close to $1000 by going with A/C. Will the heat pump last longer than the A/C for cooling? Will it be more expensive to maintain? And most importantly, which system cools better heat pump or A/C? I'm going to go with the same seer (14.5) for either one, so I don't think cost efficiency is a factor.

Any insight would be appreciated!


Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    What is your electric rate?...what is propane cost/gal?...post model number and brand of propane furnace...how old are you and how do you feed this fantastic wood burning fireplace?

    IMO

  • 11 years ago

    My electric bill says: .174 Generation, .067, in various distribution charges.

    Propane cost - about $2.6 last time I filled in the fall, but we own our tank so can assume we will get the best rate at time.

    We are in our early 40s and have access to free wood. Just to be clear, the stove is not our primary heat source, but will certainly take the edge off the propane furnace costs. Which is what the heat pump was also supposed to do. Just trying to figure out how long an extra $1000 investment in the heat pump will take to pay itself back in savings. More importantly, is the heat pump as good at cooling (effeciency, sound, etc...) as a normal A/C- since I'll be mostly using the heat pump for cooling.

    Propane furnace is a Gibson 92% BTU hot air furnace.

  • 11 years ago

    I can not interpret your electric rate from the information provided. You failed to provide the model number of your furnace. I will assume furnace has a conventional blower motor, not ECM or var speed. That was a mistake. Should have been at minimum var speed, 2 stage, and 95+% efficiency. You are limited though in your AC or HP choices. I like the idea of adding a 13-14 SEER HP. Gibson not my fav brand but I would probably add that brand condenser with matching evap coil.

    IMO

  • 11 years ago

    Take the total amount of your electric bill and subtract out any service charge. Then divide the number of KWh. It is hard to believe you electric rate is $0.24 per KWh but then again it is possible in New England.

    Heat pumps have the same cooling efficiency as the equivalent model AC condensers. The efficiency is a function of the furnace, coil, and condenser. Your efficiency may be limited by the equipment you already own.

    In most parts of the country it is cheaper to heat with a heat pump than a propane furnace. Since you own the tank, your propane cost is lower than most people. It may be more economical to heat with propane than the heat pump. That is why it is important you have all the correct costs for propane and electricity.

    The inverter type heat pumps that work well down to zero degrees. I am not familiar with Gibson so I am not sure they offer heat pumps of this type. I heat pump should not cost an additional $1000 compared to the equivalent AC model. Your HVAC guy is giving you bad information.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks- I think I found the model numbers: Furnace: Gibson KG7SC 92% AFUE Upflow/Horizontal Gas Furnace Model #KG7SC072D-35C. Air Handler (Coil?)- C7BAM03648C-C.


    I think my electric rate is those 2 numbers together = 24.1cents KWH


    The plan was to do a Gibson 14 seer 4 Ton Heat Pump condensing unit with matching evaporator coil (guessing that is the C7BAM03648C-C that I have). Should I go with the 14 seer heat pump or switch to a "normal" A/C compressor and save ~$1000?

  • 11 years ago

    Not familiar with Gibson furnace model numbers but just an interpretation it looks as if you have a 70 K BTU model with a 3 ton rated blower. If correct, you can not add a 4 ton rated condenser whether HP or straight AC. This should be rechecked against data plate info on furnace. And to be clear, the evap coil has already been installed at the furnace?...No way there should be a 1K upcharge for a 13-14 SEER HP condenser.

    IMO

  • 11 years ago

    I did a search on the furnace model number. This is a single stage 72K BTU furnace with a PSC motor. The furnace goes by several brand names. It is a basic builder's grade furnace. From what I read so far the "-35C" means the blower can accommodate 3-5 tons of cooling. I did see one spec that showed the motor is capable of producing 1625 CFM with a static pressure of 0.5.

    If your electric rate is 24 cents per KWh then it does not make sense to get a heat pump. It would have been a good investment to get a variable speed furnace so you could add a higher efficiency AC condenser.

    Any possibility of connecting to natural gas? If so you should explore the cost of doing that.

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all for your help on this, I really appreciate it.

    No natural gas -that would have been our first choice, believe me!

    So we have an accurate calc, I'm attaching my pic of my electric bill. I think 24c is close to being correct- we have one of the highest electric rates in the country.

    I also got clarity from my HVAC guy. The savings is $500 to drop from a Heat Pump to A/C and another $500 to drop from a 14 Seer to 13 Seer. So the $1000 savings was to go from a 14 Seer Heat Pump to a 13 Seer A/C.

  • 11 years ago


  • 11 years ago

    Forget the HP...not cost effective with a high electric rate.

  • 11 years ago

    x2