Software
Houzz Logo Print
designsaavy

Let's Talk Garbage.....Disposals.

11 years ago

Any preferences and why? I will have a single undermount stainless steel sink with center/rear drain. Not sure that it makes any difference.

I've never bought one before, just always used what's already been in the home.

Comments (19)

  • 11 years ago

    I have the insinkerator 1 HP. It is probably overkill but never had a jam!

  • 11 years ago

    I have been looking at the Insinkerator line of disposals, probably the 3/4 hp Evolution Essential for a single bowl stainless sink. One question I have is regarding disposals with single bowl sinks. Do people find more vibration or a weaker sink "bottom" or "floor" with a single bowl versus a double bowl setup?

    The double bowls, having the center partition, seem like a stronger setup, but I'm curious if users with single bowls have noticed any difference when it comes to their disposals, either from a weight perspective or from a weight and vibration (when in use) perspective.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nope.

    There are batch (put stuff in then apply a lid with a magnetic switch) or continuous (hole stays open and turned on by an external switch). Each have their proponents.

    With a single bowl, you may want to look at lower profile units. These will give you more room underneath.

  • 11 years ago

    I like batch because there's no way my kids can stick their hands in the garbage disposal while it's running. Bonus, no yucky flange to clean.

  • 11 years ago

    I haven't heard of anything new in disposers, but there might be something new out there. The last new thing was the Viking about ten years ago. It really was better. The Insinkerator Evolution, which was designed to the same specs, isn't as pretty to look at when you open the cupboard, but takes less space. In performance reviews, they come out pretty equal. That's for the regular feed. I don't know if there's a batch feed equivalent.

    One thing to keep in mind is that in the advertising materials they'll tell you about the things that the disposer can handle, but leave out that which it should handle. For instance, eggshells plus soap equals clogged pipes. Together, they form a kind of mortar. Plant eggshells in the garden for the calcium, or put them in the trash (or if you have hot compost (takes meat) that's another alternative. Don't put them in your pipes. Similarly, heavy and fibrous things, even if they make it through the disposer, are hard to get all the way through to the sewer. Once it's there, your local authority has to use your sewer rates to treat everything you've put through. Some have great treatment plants and want you to use the disposer more. Others have plant composting and would rather you put your scraps in the green bin. I have the latter, and use my Evolution mostly for small bits and crud left on plates and in containers.

  • 11 years ago

    Anyone have a batch feed? If so, what model and how do you like it?

  • 11 years ago

    I have had both batch and continuous feed Insinkerators with various HP. I've only had 1 or 2 jams with my less than 1 HP continuous feed, none with the others. I find the batch feed disposer a nuisance, but that's just my preference. No small hands to worry about here.

  • 11 years ago

    I just went from an old Insinkerator to the new 3/4 HP Evolution. What's new in disposals? Noise. This thing is quiet. There is little vibration. It seems to be a smaller size, too. That's what's new.

    I rarely use the disposal. I got out of the habit when living on a septic system. Even with sewer, I don't use them often. I'm old school, no air switch. This is a nice unit.

  • 11 years ago

    I had a batch feed. Purchased by my contractor a couple of years ago when we moved in and had a garbage disposal out in so no idea on brand and they just demoed my kitchen yesterday for our remodel so I can't check.

  • 11 years ago

    I would only add:

    (a) the Insinkerator Evolution Pro Excel (1 HP, I believe) has a drain slightly slightly more distant from the flange than historical Insinkerators, and one's plumbing dimensions should be checked to ensure compatibility.

    (b) the flexible folded gasket in the throat is designed to form an acoustic water seal while grinding, making the unit nearly silent. The opening when relaxed is fairly small. This limits the ability to just wash stuff through without some manual help. On the other hand, the grinding part is so much lower than the throat that hazard is minimal.

    kas


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Have a batch feed (like crl, because of the kids) and like it. Insinkerator.

  • 11 years ago

    Ditto teachmkt1. Best decision I ever made.

    I grind everything in mine. Not once in 42 years have I had a plumbing issue from egg shells or the other things that I consider to be urban legends. I use my disposal too often for anything to stay in the drain line for long.

    I do stay away from grinding large quantities of fibrous things like artichoke leaves or celery. Also no raw pasta or rice. They will sit in the trap and swell.

  • 11 years ago

    Egg shells and heavy use of dish detergents (like Dawn) and fibrous stuff (particularly potato peels) and older garbage disposals --- not an urban legend. Depends on your pipes, the age of your disposal, and other factors.

    My house had a 20 y.o. ISE (1/2 hp Badger, IIRC). I do a lot of entertaining. Guests help cook. Some of them run potato peels and the butt ends of aspaargus down the disposal. Even after I replumbed the kitchen and drains with PVC, the fibrous stuff would cause blockages at least one a year. Three years ago, the case on the old ISE cracked. I replaced it with a 3/4 hp ISE Evolution. I'm still paranoid enough to check the pipes periodically. No blockages. No build ups.

    I bought the 3/4hp Evolution model because it was less bulky and left more room under the sink, and also because, in my kitchen, I did not have to modify any of the sink plumbing. (The old plumbing required a tiny bit of tweaking a couple of slip joints to fit properly).

    I've found the ISE Evolution models to be dramatically quieter that the Badger it replaced. Kas mentioned the collar in the sink. The upside is that the collar/throat cover pops right out for cleaning. The downside is that the rubber flanges are stiff and the central opening (the part not covered by the flanges) is rather small. You may need to push things through the flanges. Some find this seriously annoying. Some (like me) do not.

    I've never tried a Waste King, so I cannot speak to their effectiveness, durability or noise levels.

    I'm agnostic in any debate over batch-feed versus continuous feed models.

  • 11 years ago

    There's no comparison with a Badger. That's a light duty unit designed for apartments where no one cooks much. The Evolution is the only Insinkerator model that I know of that's designed to the new specs. It sounds like WasteKing has their own new specs version, now, as well.

    No urban legend on the eggshells. My plumber did a diatribe about it while showing me what had created the hard to remove blockage. I use a more soap-like, mild dish liquid. The eggshells turned it into mortar. My plumber says most of his calls are for snaking, and much of that is caused by eggshells and coffee grounds.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for all the information.

    Typically, I've always scraped our plates in the trash, and only the occasional piece here or there goes in the garbage disposal.

    Since we are remodeling with a deeper, single bowl undermount sink and accessories to use on its ledge, I was wondering about chopping and prepping at the sink and being able to put mostly vegetable scraps down disposal.

    I wouldn't put meat or bones and have never put egg shells in there.

    Which one would work best for my situation, considering a little more limited space with the deeper sink?

    Which vegetables, etc. to avoid putting in there?

    Regarding maintenance, what do pros recommend in keeping blades sharp, Disposer clean, etc?

  • 11 years ago

    I have used both a Waste Kind and an Insinkerator. Both were good. The only problem I had with my Waste King was a bad O-rind between the top part and the motor part. Started to seep on the outside and I had to replace it. Could have just replaced the O-ring but had to take the impeller out and ever could get the nut to release. Speaking about noise, the higher end models have a rubber neck between the unit and the sink attachment. Stops vibration. They are also wrapped with thick insulation to reduce internal noise. Not noise free but less noise. And speaking about clogs, I have plugged up our current model. Celery is a no no but you can choke the drain line by stuffing a lot of fibrous stuff like carrot and potato peelings and even lettuce. I found out that the connecting pipe supplied with the disposer has a baffle that keeps coarse stuff from plugging up the sewer pipes. Great engineering for us kitchen dummies.

  • 11 years ago

    The new 1 HP top of the line Incinerator Evolution is super quiet and seems to chew up anything you feed it. I replaced the ¾ HP compact version with this one because my wife thought the other too noisy. She really likes this one.

  • 11 years ago

    I didn't know about the egg shells but haven't had a problem with our ISE. I think mine is 1 HP too - minimum 3/4HP, I will have to look at it, but only one or two clogs when I really overwhelmed the sink with something and those were cleared with a regular plunger. I won't put any more eggshells down the drain. I may look at the newer Evolution or the Waste King if they are quieter, for remodel. I keep a stainless mesh screen in the drain hole (the type from any hardware store for a couple of bucks) to catch most peelings and dish scrapings, then I empty that into the trash. The stray pieces go down the ISE. Never any celery or grease, or meat. Once a week or so I put the screen into the DW to clean it well.