Software
Houzz Logo Print
katyakatya1

Really need help about a stubbornly leaking roof

11 years ago

I wonder if anybody has anything to say about it - ot better yet, recommend a good specialist in the Nashville area. A home owner here has been experiencing a leak, seemingly from the roof, which proved itself impossible to fix ot to diagnose. Repair people have been around the house several times, mostly painted over the damage, only to have more leaking and water damage a few weeks later. The roof has presumably been patched. They typically act rather strange, for instance refusing to recognize any water damage at all. The ruined wall area is growing; recently the curtain rod has fallen out of the wall at some distance from the original leak site. There has to be something different about this particular leak. There has to be a reason why several teams were unable (or unwilling?) to do anything about it. The home owner has spent a lot of money on it. It feels like the house is falling apart and we are helpless. Please let me hear some opinions, we are getting desperate.

Comments (6)

  • 11 years ago

    Are you the home owner? It doesn't really matter, but it seems weird to talk about this in the third person and then switch to 'we' at the end.

    How many repair people have been out and attempted to fix it?

    The roof has presumably been patched.

    By one repair person or have there been multiple attempts?

    What do you mean that they refuse "to recognize any water damage at all"?

    I think I'd start ripping off the drywall and looking at it from the inside to see if you can trace where the water is coming from. Is it possibly a leaking pipe instead of a leaking roof?


  • 11 years ago

    I am her sister! That's why I talk like that.

    Multiple attempts, yes.

    The kind of wall it is, it seems there shouldn't be any pipes, I really don't know what kind of pipes they would be.

    Refuse to recognize, like they look at it and say "I don't see any water damage at all".

    The roof is quite new actually, replaced 4 years ago. And yes, already patched on top of it. Ripping of the drywall is a good idea, I wonder if we should do it ourselves or there still are professionals who would do it competently.

    Thank you!

  • 11 years ago

    Does "multiple attempts" mean 2 or 10? Big difference. You might have gotten a couple of bad roofers.
    Do you mean roofers when you say 'repair people' or are these just random people that do odd jobs?

    Ripping off drywall is pretty easy. I'd do it yourself. If you can't see where the water is coming from at that point, then you can always call someone else. Be aware that water can travel quite a distance from where the leak is to where the damage to the drywall occurs, so don't assume that the leak is right above the damage.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pictures of the damage, and an outside shot of the roof line may help. It's nearly impossible to diagnose from an explanation, and roof leaks are sometimes difficult to diagnose even when on the site.

    Just because the roof materials are newer, does not mean they were installed correctly. Having a patched roof on a newer installation leads me to believe the materials were not installed correctly to begin with.

    You are assuming it's a roof leak or maybe a gutter leak. Does this structure by chance have the air handler in the attic? If so, it could be a condensate line/drain/pan problem.

    Please post some pictures.

  • 11 years ago

    why not go into the attic after or during a rain & look
    for water stains or even dripping water.
    understand that water may enter higher up than
    where it exits.
    if you can pinpoint where it exits, then you'll
    have a starting point.

    just Monday I found 12 nail holes in shingles from
    walkboard install...by the roofers.
    darn 30/12 roof pitch.

    best of luck