Might seem an odd question, but do you have lots of trees nearby? rustic look?

Well, I live in the city but I do have a row of pine trees in my back yard and also a Japanese Maple in the back. I have a big gum tree and a dogwood in the front.. I love the rustic look though.

Try paint stores' coordinating combos. Maybe your roof would be a paint color [check historical line].... see if light tan is recommended, etc...?