The mockup is looking great! If you go that direction, I would also recommend painting your porch columns, rails, and front door to eliminate all of the white.

Another option would be to keep your dormers the color they are in the mockup and go darker on your garage door - maybe something closer to your trim color.

We ran that scenario too but I thought it looked much too dark. What do you think?

Whoops... That was a response to Emily.

I agree that they're too dark in that recent rendering. What if you "split the baby?" Maybe half way between the dormer color and your trim color... just enough to make the garage doors recess a bit.

I like that a lot. Thanks Emily! Do you think the dormer color of essentially mirroring the brick is a good idea or would you go with something else?

I do like the idea of blending the dormers into the brick. Maybe go one shade darker on them? My reasoning being that it's more of an average of the brick colors instead of the lightest shade in the variation.

Is that Khaki Brown? If so, maybe darken to Woodstock Brown? or if it's Autumn Tan maybe darken to Khaki Brown?