Software
Houzz Logo Print
kim_wa

Help with lacunosa cutting

11 years ago

I got a lacunosa cutting that didn't do well in shipping, and seems determined to die on me. Half the leaves were yellow when it arrived, and it continued to die back when I was trying to root it in perlite. I transferred it to water (since I have had great luck this way), inside of a partly closed zip lock bag. I noticed the stems were looking dead and shriveled and made the call to cut it back some more. Now I have two very small pieces left, and not sure what to do. My other 5 cuttings from that order are doing great, but I am less than optimistic for this one. Any ideas?

sorry it is sideways, it is the one in the middle. The plastic wrap is to keep it in the water.

Comments (38)

  • 11 years ago


  • 11 years ago

    I did an experiment once, with diversifolia, comparing water rooting to soil rooting, and the soil-rooted plant formed 3x as big a root system in the same amount of time. So, I've avoided water rooting since then. But it's a bad idea to presume much from a single small sample study, so I also don't want to advise against your plan. Certainly, Hoyas can be rooted in water, and if it's working for you, then go with it.

    I do know that, when I root lacunosa in soil, it can be a butt. Some cuttings will root np and others will refuse for no apparent reason. Typically, I would just root a Hoya like this in hydroton, which (in my experience) has the highest success rate. But, if I didn't have that option, I would root it in soil, and give it some kind of enclosure, to increase humidity. You can use a clear tupperware bin or rubber-band a plastic bag over the top. But I think it's your best bet at this point.

    I never had any luck rooting in perlite, either. I know some people swear by it, but I can't seem to get it to work. I must not have the right incantation to whisper over the perlite or something.

  • 11 years ago

    I have an African violet soil mix right now, a little short on funds at the moment but I may try that with one of the cuttings since I have two of them anyways. Glad to hear I am not the only one with perlite issues, my obscura and australis cuttings did fine in it, still have curtissi in the stuff with no roots yet, and gave up on it entirely with my imperialis and diversifolia. Largely because I was sick of them getting knocked into the sink. Hmmm, I also have a lot of ripe compost and perlite. Maybe I can make something work for the lacunosa with that? Or should I break down and buy something better? All the more reason to repot my violet barn hoyas, those little pots would be perfect for this.

  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, if you have two, I would try rooting one in the AV mix with a baggie over the top of the pot. Just mix some extra perlite in there. I would skip the compost.

    lmao @ knocking the perlite containers over. I have also been there.

    Yeah sometimes it just takes a Hoya a long time to develop roots and you can't figure out why. I had this cutting of variegated kentiana that developed ZERO roots all winter. It just hung out in the east window doing nothing. I couldn't believe it when I checked. I thought for sure it had developed roots toward the center of the hydroton and I just couldn't see them. But nope. As soon as I moved it under the grow lights it grew roots. (I suspect the window it was in was too cold.) It doesn't matter so much when they are succulent, but when they are intolerant of drought like lacunosa, it becomes a real problem when they stall.


  • 11 years ago

    I will give it a go and see what happens. Fingers crossed!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Broke down, picked up some miracle grow seedling soil and small orchid bark, mixed it up with perlite and planted both lacunosa cuttings in it in a 2 inch pot. Stuck it in the bottom of a wide mouth mason jar, baggie over the top in an East facing window. If this doesn't work... Well then I will just have to order 6 more hoyas to sooth my broken heart. ;)

  • 11 years ago

    That sounds really good. If the baggie is loose over the top, you're all set. If you've rubber banded the baggie to create a seal, make sure you keep it out of direct sunlight, because they can overheat. Indirect light is better for cuttings anyway.

    If that lacunosa doesn't root now, it's not your fault. You've done all you can.

  • 11 years ago

    The baggie is loose, and its in an indirect spot at the moment. I am going to forget about it for a few days now, and see what happens.

  • 11 years ago

    Okay. Good luck! (。◝‿◜。)

  • 11 years ago

    I have about 12 lacunosa cuttings that rooted about a year ago but have done nothing growth wise since they rooted. One flowered but that was it. Now I repotted and put them outside. I hope they will take off. It seems they are hard for me to grow from cuttings.

  • 11 years ago

    I have always found lacunosa very hard to root. It's always a race to see if it roots first or drops it's leaves first. And though the rooting dome works well for most Hoyas, it always seems to exacerbate the leaf drop with lacunosa. Go figure... If you can't get them to root, your best bet is to watch the box stores for a full (freshly received!) lacunosa - an Exotic Angel plant. They're cheap for their size!

    Denise in Omaha


  • 11 years ago

    @ Mark

    Usually, when you root Hoyas yourself, as you did, they get going right away. But, it is not at all unheard of for them to act as yours is, and take a year to really start moving forward. I have a plant I was looking at this weekend, that I got from trade and is sitting in the same exact location as others rooted at the same time, and it still hasn't grown so much as a leaf. One day it will take off and catch up with the others. I've seen it dozens of times before. So, don't be too hard on yourself or lacunosa about its delays. Sometimes it's very hard to tell what is causing this (lack of) behavior.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, that is what I figured. Although, I am hoping that the move outside will help. Its been humid and in the 70's in the Chicagoland area lately. I hope this is agreeable to my lacunosa!

  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, I hope so too. I'm rooting for you.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lets hope ours pull through. So far, no new yellow leaves on mine. And thanks Denise, I am already on the lookout for one. That is the plan B, heheheh. I am glad my other 5 are rooting like champs. They were all generous, nice pieces but the lacunosa has just been mad since i got it. Sure that the boiling hot weather didn't help any on its journey clear across the country. Definitely makes me feel better about my propagation skills. Now, if I can just convince my lacunosa and a growing begonia cuttings to hang on there and root I will be happy. I have various cuttings rooting all over my house, those two are just being extra stubborn.

  • 11 years ago

    GG, love it! "I'm rooting for you!" You punny girl!


  • 11 years ago

    ;P

  • 11 years ago

    Less than a week later and one of the lacunosa cuttings is forming roots. Hopefully the other joins it, the mason jar greenhouse is doing just the trick. Thanks GG!! Didn't like perlite, jar of water in a bag, water and no bag, but the soil/mason jar/saran wrap seemed to help. I suppose, the miracle grow cutting and seedling soil could have helped too. Still... Fussy little thing! Hopefully as an adult it learns to behave. ;)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I had to put curtsii as well as lacuna in a gallon bag with about two scoops of substrate (mostly organic fine compost mulch, coco coir, perlite and different sizes of chicken grit) and then mist it daily if I can remember and just try not to let it dry out. Just because you have condensation on the bag doesn't mean the substrate isn't bone dry.

    If the substrate gets soggy, start a new bag with fresh substrate so the other stuff can dry out.

    My lacunosa is only rooting from its newer growth, so I put in a slab of cork bark.


  • 11 years ago

    Um...it's been ten people days....is that enough in plant days to notice any changes in your cuttings?

    Eager to hear an update!

  • 11 years ago

    where the cutting is taken is also important. Healthy branch, not too young or too old and about 2 to 3 inch is ideal

    I am hoping I can swap cuttings with anyone of you. I am looking for hoya lacunosa and any fragrant hoya. I already have carnosa and a short cutting of white fragrant unknown name hoya.

  • 11 years ago

    Mark, your hoya d/n bloom bc it needs more sunlight. The best is outside in the summer with dapple sunlight. Do not water until the soil is dry to touch. Mature Hoya react quickly to light; it WILL reward you very soon, I am certain

  • 11 years ago

    Laticauda, 10 days are not sufficient. Give it 2 weeks to 3 weeks, One thing I always do is to re-use clear plastic cup and use clean water for my cuttings. This way more sunlight through the entire plant helps stimulate growth and roots.

    I notice my cuttings got rotten if the weather is still cold. When it's warm and hot starting June, all my cuttings root. I live in zone 9b, the Bay Area

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Mine started rooting once I put it in a dome type set up, but died when we had a heat wave while I was out of town. It got cooked in the windowsill, nearly lost my three Aloe Vera plants too. I will try again. That window sill is usually super protected, and is where all of my other plants usually get roots on. The lacunosa was just especially finicky and took a lot of trial and error, it also got cooked some in shipping. Good advice all the same!

  • 11 years ago

    what websites did you guys use to buy this hoya? Thanks

  • 11 years ago

    My lacunosa came from another user on here, Jan Sword. I want to make it ABUNDANTLY clear the death of this cutting in no way reflects on her and the quality of cuttings I received. That one and I just didn't get along, I bought 5 other cuttings in the same order, all were quite generous, affordably priced, and arrived well packaged and ahead of schedule. My other 5 were imperialis, obscura, diversolia aff crassipes, and australis "Mrs. G". The lacunosa, Mrs.G, crassipes, and oh yeah curtissii were all part of a bundle deal she was doing then for $15. That sale is over I am pretty sure but she has a new one now for $25 with 4 rarer species you may want to check out, its posted. Otherwise, my Hoyas have came from Violet Barn (small plants, I prefer cuttings to these but they grow fast), people I know in the real world and just ordered a few from Denise who is on here a lot. I recommend you contact both of them if you are Hoya shopping! I hear SRQ and Gardino nurseries are well loved, and Joni from SRQ is pretty awesome. I haven't had the money yet to order from either, but sooner or later I know I will.

  • 11 years ago
    Jan's cuttings are great, lacunosa is not the easiest to root without it being attached to the parent plant.
  • 11 years ago

    Lacunosa is also super drought intolerant. She and I are still learning about each other, but at least she's stopped yellowing a leaf here or there for a while......God willing, that continues to be the case. I'd really like for it to bloom for me but I'm used to "let the top inch get dry" plants lol.


    Im also having fits with the polyneura but it may be a nutrient thing, they are both EA. I reported the lacunosa but not the polyneura so I've started giving the polyneura AV feet every watering after a good flushing and shower first.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, good info. My imperialis keeps getting yellow leaf spots, not sure what I am doing wrong, if it is too little or too much water or what. I am thinking about building a spreadsheet of data on Hoyas, with various bits of sortable information to keep track of all this stuff. I will tackle lacunosa again, at some point.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yeah, my polyneura will get chlorotic spots when it wants water. It has gotten better over time with fertilizer. Now I just have to pay closer attention because the yellowing sign may not happen for me much longer!

    I recommend something with micronutrients in it. That's why I use the AV stuff or my cactus stuff because they both have micronutrients and not a very high nitrogen content which can be detrimental to succulents.


    can you get compost and ferment it into a tea? That would have everything you need and then some.

    i like using rabbit manure but plant based composts are better than any manure.

    kelp powder can help with micronutrients as well as seaweed liquid...but it's so expensive. You can also give a tad of blackstrap molasses in your watering can every once in a while or when a plant is stressed. It has just a little but of sugar and tons of nutrients including IRON. I use goat nutridrench but black strap molasses is a lot cheaper.

    Kim thanked laticauda
  • 11 years ago

    Blackstrap molasses I always have on hand, helps my own iron deficiency like nothing else. And I have plenty of compost. I use a kelp based fertilizer called Tappin' roots and feed at 1/4 strength every week, but now that I think about it may have slacked off on that. It is expensive, but a concentrate and lasts a long time. Will keep experimenting until I make her happy. Has new growth at two nodes, I must be doing something half way right... Now to figure out the other half.

  • 11 years ago
    Ferment the compost like sauerkraut or kimchi. Some people say 3 days, but I really prefer to go a full 5 days.
    It's amazing what the stuff can do.
    Kim thanked laticauda
  • 11 years ago

    I will get some going in the morning!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi guys, I notice hoya takes more time to root than any plants I have in my garden. Some cuttings take a month or more. My experience with hoya is the warmer the temp, the easier and the faster it roots, and my most easy rooting method as I find out is put cuttings in a cup of plastic clear and clean water at my window sill or outside in the shade with dapple sunlight at this time of the year, zone 9b.

    I am new to Houzz so am still learning how to navigate this site. Is there anyone so kind introduce me to Jan? I promise you guys I have a bunch of beautiful easy rooting succulent babies (hoya is one kind) I can share. I have super easy to root like epiphyllums or kalanchoe manginii for example. Anyone who has a lacunosa please contact me.

    Regarding compost, instead of using it, I recommend using Eleanor VF11, liquid fertilizer, super good for plant and no burn. I only use it for my most pampered babies.

    I use VF11 to spray for any plants that I want to reward me instantly with flowers, hoya included. I mostly use this for my dragon fruit plant to encourage blooms.

  • 11 years ago

    This is the mangini, bell shape orange flowers, blooms in February.
    Epiphyllum, blooms in May, North Cal

  • 11 years ago

    Jan is easy to find, go to the main Hoya forum page, and then just scroll down until you see one of her posts, she has a recent one titled something like 4 Hoya cuttings for $25, and leave her a comment.

  • 11 years ago

    An, please send me a pm, I have Jan's email.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio