The less the fridge sticks out the better it looks. But some don't care. The fridge you posted is 12" deeper than the cabinet. I would ask if the sides are black or stainless. If it sticks out that much I'd want stainless to show, not black.

With a s/s (not my favorite) the freezer is very narrow. You can't get an ice cream cake in there f.ex.

Kenmore has a French Door fridge which has a better freezer config IMO. But some do like s/s.

What's the distance from that frame for the fridge to the island? That will help you measure how much it will impede.

I have a similar design in my kitchen. The previous owners left behind a huge side by side that stuck out so far (34 deep w. Black sides, stainless front) it made it very hard to pass one another in the kitchen. When I remodeled, I chose a counter depth with really helped traffic flow and put the old fridge in the garage (not sure if you have the option of a second fridge). The counter depth I chose (Electrolux IQ Touch CD FD with Perf Temp Drawer w. Stainless color sides) has plenty of room for my daily needs, but since I live about an hr from my preferred shopping (Costco, Whole Foods, etc) I do find I use extra fridges and freezers for when I bulk shop and for drinks. As Rococo mentioned, it's all in the layout and how you would use it. HTH.

We had a SxS when we first re-did our kitchen and built a cabinet frame around it. There were 2 things I hated about it. First, it stuck out so far past the cabinet frame, and second, the gap between the top of the fridge and the top of the cabinet. This isn't the greatest picture, but you can see the gap at the top (and the sides because our SxS was apparently smaller). I thought the gap looked horrible. We replaced this fridge with a Jenn Air counter depth. The Jenn Air, KitchenAid and Whirlpool (all made by same company) were the only ones that were 72" tall at the time. New fridge in picture below.

I would go with the counter depth, 72" tall for your set up.

Thanks everyone! I'm online shopping now!