Software
Houzz Logo Print
malba2366

Paneled vs stainless built in fridge

11 years ago

We are re doing a kitchen in a transitional style with white shaker doors and contemporary countertops. We are going to have a 48 inch side by side fridge. I want to go with a sub zero built in and like the way it looks in stainless sticking out one inch proud. 2 of the KDs we have sat down so both said that is a very dated look and that I should go with a integrated fridge that is paneled. I feel that the paneled look will be like a sea of white cabinetry, and I personally like the way the stainless appliances play off the white cabinets. What are peoples thought on here?

Comments (15)

  • 11 years ago

    I (unintentionally) took a lot of cues from my mother's 1965 kitchen, and panelled everything in sight. The 1965 kitchen had two different stainless steel ovens and two stainless cooktops. What is the definition of "dated"?? Looks like Granny's kitchen? During the 1990's a friend of mine complimented Mother's kitchen, being that it was right on the knife's edge of the incoming style.

    YOU know what YOU like for YOUR kitchen. White shaker is not exactly up to the minute. It's pretty classic and should age well, but it's not leading a new trend that you have to match or something. Stainless as a must have look is no longer the hottest thing, but it's always been around and will never be "out". Women have rediscovered color and prints in clothes after the crow decades, but the little black dress has never, and will never, be out.

    There are design mistakes that professionals rightly try to talk their clients out of. For instance, if you had an integrated dishwasher and fitted wall ovens with your white cabinets, but decided that refrigerator cabinetry was a waste and just left a gap and plunked the cheapest, blackest big box store fridge down there, with mops and stepladder filling the gaps... In that case, the designers should be finding you solutions that cater to your budget but look a lot better. That's not the case here. You've just chosen an accepted look which isn't popular anymore.

    If they give you any more guff, tell them it's retro.

    Get the stainless!!! Let it stand proud!! Make your kitchen look like you want it to!

  • 11 years ago

    Although a paneled fridge was a very important requirement for me, I can certainly understand wanting to mix finishes, especially if you have a long wall, and a lot of cabinetry. That said, 48" is an awful lot of fingerprints to clean.

  • 11 years ago

    Personally, if it has to be integrated, I would be fine with just flat panels, but not huge shaker doors. I would go with SS in this case.

  • 11 years ago

    Your KD doesn't have to live with the kitchen. You do. Get what makes you happy. It will look fine.

    Personally I wish they made the better fridges in colors. I would love a colorful fridge to break up a run of cabinets.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I like an integrated look with stainless. Why not do that? SZ has a whole integrated line and they look great.

    With SZ, I don't love the huge vent at the top sitting proud of the cabinets. It's all you see. OTOH these days paneling is done even when it doesn't look terrific. They get some weird handles and it can look patchy. Depends a lot on the cabinets.

    My old stainless fridge sat flush. The replacement is proud by about 1". But the vent is along the bottom hidden beneath the freezer door.

    I actually agree with your KDs. Integrated will look best. Just do it your way.

  • 11 years ago

    I like the SZ built in look...to me it adds a little "bling" to the kitchen. From a practical standpoint my wife is also short and she can not reach the top shelf of the integrated SZ/Miele/Thermador fridges.

  • 11 years ago

    Serious question - how short is short? I'm 5'2-1/2" and I can reach the top shelf in my builtin Thermador.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    She is 5'2 she couldn't reach the back of the top shelf of the integrated fridges. I feel that the stainless integrated fridges look too plain...the SZ grille actually looks nice to me. I agree that with slab doors the paneled look looks great, but with shaker or any patterned doors a 30 inch big paneled fridge door looks odd to me. One of the KDs was strongly suggesting a slab door as we like the contemporary look, but It doesn't go with the rest of the house...I think shaker cabinets in frameless will give us a transitional look that blends better in the home, and the stainless Range, DW and Fridge will provide some pop in the kitchen.

    @SJhockeyfan Do you have the thremador side by side or the columns unit?

  • 11 years ago

    @rocco I totally agree that a lot of the paneling looks bad, especially when it is done on a BI that is sticking out from the cabinets. IMHO go integrated for the paneled look, or stainless for built ins that stick out from the cabinetry.

  • 11 years ago

    @malba - Sounds like you know what you want. No reason not to have it. SZ with standard install blends with every style. DD had it with ss doors on the all fridge/all freezer combo in a minimalist apartment.

    Occasionally a KD has real taste. But mostly they design cabinets not kitchens. I agree many of those panels look odd and the handles used on them the whole thing look like the kitchen started in the hardware store.

    I have inset shaker cabinet door below slab-front drawers. That might be another idea with less movement on the base cabinets. After 12 years, you do end up cleaning those panels and the slab drawers are easier IMHO.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes I know what I want...thanks for the reassuring words.. The kd comments worried me a bit because I would hate to spend $$$ and then have the whole thing look dated in a couple years. The other question is what to do with the dishwasher. We have a 2 year old miele stainless dw. I really like the stainless look with white cabs but again the designers strongly recommend paneled. Can I even panel an existing stainless miele dw? What are some opinions on the dishwasher?

  • 11 years ago

    For what it's worth, I am doing the same--48" SZ in SS. I happen to like the look and am using SS for accents, including a Modernaire SS hood. And a SS DW. Maybe I'm missing an opportunity, but the wall of panels just never appealed to me.

  • 11 years ago

    It doesn't appeal to me either. And from a practical standpoint I don't like the idea of putting painted panels on a fridge which is opened and closed all the time and a dishwasher with all the steam and water. Yes stainless shows prints but it can be easily cleaned.

  • 11 years ago

    I think it depends on the kitchen and how much SS you want/have vs. cabinetry. I went with an integrated refrigerator, integrated refrigerator drawers, and an integrated dishwasher. The speed oven, regular oven, cooktop and cooktop exhaust were enough SS for my kitchen.