Software
Houzz Logo Print
halocline

Hard Chop - Opinions???

11 years ago

Hi everyone,

This is a Green Island Ficus and, I've been thinking about cutting it back for a while.

Here are some pics from different angles.



This is where I'd like to cut.


This is more of a close up.


All opinions will be appreciated.:-)

Rob

Comments (17)

  • 11 years ago

    Hey, Rob, I don't grow ficus (other than the outdoor wild kind).

    I wonder if the plant could tolerate being chopped even lower?

    Josh

    halocline thanked greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
  • 11 years ago

    I would like to cut it there because; I want to grow the lower right branch out a bit, then cut it so it grows back the way it came, giving the tree a curve w/o having that wire trained look.

    I might have a pic of a similar tree; from the nursery where I got this idea. I'll have to check.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    Rob:

    You do not state the age of the plant, however, I agree with Tapia that patience is the better course here. If I view your intended cut correctly, you would sacrifice all but the one limb you wish to develop. I cannot calculate the exact percentage, however, that represents well over half of the productive plant being removed at once. You may risk too great of a shock in my opinion. I would cut below the main "V" eliminating the upper portion. Also clip that little three or four leaf branch sticking out the back in your bottom photo. That would leave the "Goal" branch, one above it and a small one with a couple of leaves, opposite your favorite. At the same time, reduce the now unwanted top branch down about half of the leaf growth. This would leave adequate resources for the plant to continue to live. Over time reduce the remaining unwanted growth after the plant demonstrates generation of new growth. If it survives, your "Goal" branch should receive a majority of the new growth. You can work that branch's new growth to suit your ultimate design. Since that branch is the lowest, you can always get down to it by continued cutting, regardless of what the other branches do. Also, as Tapia said, that little counterpart branch may develop into some sort of interesting yin yang scenario. If not, you are a clip away from your original goal.

    halocline thanked dalpoindexter
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ahh, I found it.

    Thanks for the feedback guys.

    By - " w/o having that wire trained look.", I don't mean I'm discounting that," you'll get the most natural look via wire training." Actually, that sound's like a crude way of saying - I'm just no good at wiring. Not to brag, (since I'm relatively new at this) but I've really become quite good at it; might be my favorite bonsai task. (Taking it off, not so much.)

    Anyway, this is also a Green Island Ficus, (albeit, it's about 10 yrs. older than mine.) and how I got the idea for the shape.

    I've been inspecting it a bit closer each time I go to this nursery.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    BUMP.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you have questions, Rob ..... or are you looking for comments re something you mentioned?

    Al

    halocline thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 11 years ago

    I posted this pic because, I believe this tree was shaped, by implementing cuts, similar to what I am considering for my tree.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    This might sound harsh, and you know I wouldn't take a snarky tone with you, but it's better to learn now than later - the tree you're admiring was formed by weaving a flexible F retusa whip around 2 parallel and horizontal wooden fence rods or wrapping around a wooden dowel with one end of the dowel stuck in the ground. It was allowed to grow for 2 years in China before it was lifted and shipped with thousands of nearly identical trees to the US. It has the unmistakable look of a tree produced in an operation similar to a production line (often called a cookie cutter tree). Many folks, new to bonsai, buy these trees and grow them for a few years, until they see enough similar trees to recognize them as far from unique, then chop them hard. More experienced artists look at only the root structure, which is usually very poor, and decide if correcting the roots is worth the effort. If they decide it is, they either layer off the top and train a low branch as a new leader to improve taper, or simply chop and discard the top, retaining only roots and lower trunk as a fresh start. I have quite a few F retusa that started out as chops of trees like you pictured, but none look at all like they did when purchased.


    The upside is, if it looks good to you and you want to use your tree to emulate it - all that matters is you have fun ...... and learning about the plant as you go is a very big help, too. If you decide later you want something different, you can chop it back and start fresh. The tree is very forgiving if you treat it right & don't make it mad.

    It's rewarding to build a tree in the style you envisioned from the outset, and takes a somewhat different set of skills than "finding the tree" in a plant you've sort of let grow wild for a few years, but the later is definitely quicker.


    Al

    halocline thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, in all the research and shopping I've done, I know what you're talking about.

    These are trees in a nursery I went to last Friday, and good examples of what you're describing:



    The tree in my previous comment was definitely manipulated by some kind of structure, but, seeing it in person, it look's like there were significant cuts (where the cambium is healing over) at two of the major turns in the trunk, which is why, like you suggested on my tree; let the big branch grow, and use the small vertical one as the new apex. At some time in the future, cut that one; directing a branch to grow back to the left. (If that makes sense.)


    BTW-I am well aware of the mass production of cheap 'bonsai' trees from China (some w/ a single minimum order of 10,000 pieces). I am the proud owner of at least 5.

    Here is a pic of the tree that first interested me in bonsai. It was a last second purchase, (and I mean last second, I was next in line at the register.) and I didn't even notice the 'bonsai' label until I got home -


    That IS Gritty Mix, NOT glued on rocks.:-)

    While I have your ear, this is the tree that ultimately led me to the "tapla" files:


    If anyone else has any further input on the original topic, please, feel free.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, I compromised on the cut.




    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    ..... probably a good time to stop cutting & let that little guy do some growing so he's got the juice to make it through the winter, eh Rob?

    Al

    halocline thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 11 years ago

    Yep.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    Rob: I think you showed wisdom and also overcame the primary difficulty most have with Bonsai, PATIENCE. If it were easy, everyone would do it. At least that is what they say. Let your friend mend, show you some individual initiative and you not only have everything you were interested in at the start, you may find something new and exciting. It would be stupid to say something about how you can always cut it off, but not put it back on, so I won't. Good Luck, and post when you make changes. Also, I bet the tree that inspired you, did not follow the original plan of it's owner.

    halocline thanked dalpoindexter
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes I like what Ive done, but lets get back to my original plan. I went back to the bonsai nursery and took some more pics of their Green Island ficus. It's not a cookie cutter, it was grown in Florida, the owner thinks its about 10-12yrs old. Al is right, it was grown around a stake, not by cutting, price: $499.00. the owner said it was ok for me to move it around for these photos.

    This is where I thought the first cut came to change the direction of growth.



    You can clearly see the stake marks left behind.

    In this next one, you can even see some of the stake still stuck in the tree.


    And here's a cool jade.


    It's about 3ft tall.

    Rob

  • 11 years ago

    Rob: I just spent about one hour composing a response to your latest post before my internet provider decided to crash without saving my answer. So I will be brief. Your original post does not jive with the latest pics of a tree which obviously curls around a former support. A cut or removal does not affect the future form of a tree. The cut you reference is new and is done to clean the trunk. Your original project has the potential to show the bend and then the growth you referred to in you earlier posts. Take the second to last photo against the blue sheet on Sunday at 6:14. Cut off everything above the right hand turn and your tree will bend and then move upward. I do not see how that relates to the latest photos. I can say one thing for sure. Material removed does not affect what remains unless it causes infection. Trees are not balanced. Taking weight from one area does not cause another to bend or move. Your project has a strong lower limb which if encouraged to grow while removing competition, should hopefully produce the results you originally talked about. I am sorry if this seems blunt and awkward, but my great response went into the void.

    halocline thanked dalpoindexter
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The tree in the latest pics is the tree that inspired this thread, and yes that cut in the second photo is fresh, but there is an old cut on that bend (actually there are two)that are nearly healed over and looks like they were a substantial part of the tree at some point.

    "I can say one thing for sure. Material removed does not affect what remains".

    Not true. I often use the clip and grow method, and that proves the opposite of your statement.

    I believe by using the CG methodology alone, I could get a tree to grow in a similar fashion as the one in the above pics. (It would take alot longer.) I however, will implement a stake.

    Rob

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations