Is that the first pod on the plant? Looks like a runt. It's small but if it taste like habanero then it most likely is. Reapers have tails but you may come across some that have stunted tails. But the skin on yours it too smooth.

Yes that is one of the first pods on the plant. The others that arnt ready yet are bigger and I don't see any tails like you mentioned. I've had a feeling for a while they weren't reapers

Did you let the nursery know? Did you purchase more than one and only this one did not grow true? Often seed labels or plants get moved so it's not too uncommon to buy something that turns out to be something else from a nursery.

I havnt called them yet. I got the last one that was labeled reaper and I got one that was labeled trinadad scorpion and I'm thinking that one isn't true also.

Do you have any pods on the Trinidad Scorpion? Could you post a pic of those peppers if you have them?

Well that was nice of them to offer you replacement plants. Those do look like habanero's. It's not a total loss though, you can do lots with habanero's. They look healthy.