Oh, that's beautiful, Brandi! Thank you!

Here is what I would do.

I would definitely stick with classic colors, you're right about the blues it would make it look like a beach home, which is beautiful, but the home is gorgeous and deserves layers that would bring it out. My husband paints maybe he can give me some suggestions and I will text back

That is our actual house, repainted. My husband was teasing. We used a mid-tone grayish green under the eaves to bring out the corbels and painted the porch ceiling the same color. The front door is Cayenne by SW.

The updated picture with the Blue looks very nice and it doesn't look like a beach house lol

Hey Amy, your house looks beautiful! Is the blue SW Indigo Batik? I saw you comment on another post that you painted your house that color and I am trying to find pictures of it used on a house exterior as it's a contender for our house.

Yes it is SW Indigo Batik. Here's with the brick painted and set with lighting.