Software
Houzz Logo Print
jon_biddenback

What is the optimal width for growing plots?

11 years ago

My woman and I are discussing converting some lawn space into vegetable gardens. We're taking some rough measurements, and I'm wondering what the ideal plot width is to allow easy reach without compacting the soil by standing on it, while still giving the plants plenty of room to grow.

Comments (14)

  • 11 years ago

    Mine are 4' and I'm happy with that [6'x4']. A strategically placed flat rock or artsy driftwood can help step from one side to the other as well.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    3' wide is better for some folks.

  • 11 years ago

    All sorts of widths can be called "optimal". Mine where I can only get to them from one side are around two thirds or so the width of ones that can be reached from both. Also, the walkways are narrow because the property is measured not in acres but in square inches so "unused" space is too valuable to waste.

    Thirdly, I try to be as intensive as one can get away with to shade the soil from wicked harsh sun, so wider is usually better there and room-to-grow isn't an issue.


    I have a lot of organic matter pressing down (in most areas) on dry sandy soil and stepping in the planting area really has no bad consequences, making foot compaction a non-issue there too. YMMV.


    You might also consider how you will weed the plots. We have no weeds (too danged dry for 'em) so need no decisions about reach-ability, which one needs if one weeds on one's knees...

  • 11 years ago

    30" works well for me. i can reach across the bed.

  • 11 years ago

    A width of 4 feet, provided access from both sides is available, should be an optimal size. Most everyone should be able to reach the center of a 4 foot wide plot without stretching.

    Many years ago I made beds 6 feet wide and found later that that was too much of a stretch.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    How tall is your woman? I'm 5'3" and find that a 4' bed is too wide to reach to the middle comfortably, so I go w/ 3' to 3 1/2'.

    My suggestion: stand and bend over and reach out and touch the ground. See what your reach is. Double that and you've got your measurement.

  • 11 years ago
    1. Lay a board on the ground.
    2. Pick up a trowel
    3. Kneel just behind the board and reach forward and dig a hole with the trowel.

    That's 1/2 the width of the bed you need, if you have access from both sides and want to keep foot traffic off the beds.

    Make sure the paths are wide enough to work comfortably so you don't end up digging up plants with your toes in the bed behind you.

    Consider a "keyhole" design for maximum growing area ...

    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/210754457537648142/

    https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/aa/a3/34/aaa334cac47c11905bc5882f83b142fe.jpg

  • 11 years ago

    Cool, I really like the keyhole design. Keep in mind you don't necessarily have to make raised beds. People seem to think they're the best, but the extra work an imported soil is not always necessary.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm with tox wrt the raised beds. Avoid if possible. There has been a lot of good advice here. Width is determined by what you can comfortably reach.

  • 11 years ago

    Those raised beds at Pinterest are high enough for wheelchair access, which is great if you need that. I have 4-6" raised beds only because my heavy clay does not drain well, and over years of adding compost and small amounts of coarser soil, they have 'fluffed.'

  • 11 years ago

    The original reason for raised beds was to help with poorly draining soil, but building raised beds can be more work initially and can be expensive if edge material is purchased. One problem with raised beds that are less than 6 inches in depth is root growth, many root crops (Carrots, Turnips, Parsnips) need something closer to an 8 inch depth.

    If there is access to the bed from both sides the width should not be more than 4 feet and if access to the bed is on only one side it needs to be narrower, about 2 feet usually.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    I don't worry about stepping on my wonderously loose soil. So I make wide beds that are 7 to 18 feet wide....works great for me.


    I think we get rather 'boxed in' in our thinking.

  • 11 years ago

    raised beds are bottomless, at least mine are, so the depth of the frame isn't the depth of the plant roots. here in the mountains the soil is poor and not wonderously loose. i think the answer to the op's question is it depends....